This poster has made up my mind for choosing Ehlers over Nylander.
With regards to Ehlers, since when is pumped up stats a con? He was a plus 51! Playing with Drouin means he should be a great line mate for a decent NHLer (ie Sedins.) For me, comparing Nylander to Kessel and Ovechkin is not a compliment (Both minus players.) Saying he plays with men (who aren't good enough for the NHL mind you), over and over, is not a great reason either. Nylander not going to the dirty areas often is also a bad sign.