*Big Spoilers*
I'd like to start a conversation about the Time Heist. I would like to critique it in a logical way, not in a movie/entertainment way, but in a LOGICAL way.
Here is what happened in the movie first:
First Group: Captain America + Iron Man + Ant Man + Professor Hulk go after 3 stones (Mind Stone, Space Stone/Tesseract, Time Stone) Location/Time New York 2012
Second Group: Thor + Rocket go after the Aether (Reality Stone) Location/Time Asgard 2013
Third Group: Black Widow + Hawkeye go after Soul Stone , War Machine + Nebula go after Power Stone (Morag, Vormir 2014)
I can understand why the movie set this up on a "entertaining" level, but from a logical perspective it would be interesting to see some changes.
Logical Approach:
1. The most unknown infinity stone is the Soul Stone. No avenger has any experience of it, its location, not even its power. It wouldn't make sense to send two extremely low powered heroes to go get it on this critical mission (yes black widow and hawkeye are pretty low powered)
2. Also, Vormir is on a completely different planet. It is LOGICAL to at least send Rocket or Nebula to Vormir because of their outer outer space planetary experience
3. So let's say Rocket goes to Vormir, plus another powerful Avenger say Iron Man (who could survive in space with his suit), it makes LOGICAL sense
4. Out of the two, Rocket and Iron Man would have to sacrifice for the soul stone, I'd say it would be Rocket, but he LOGICALLY make a fight over it (I think Iron Man would kill Rocket in order to continue the mission)
5. For the NY team, if Iron Man doesn't go, then the team is left to Captain America, Ant Man, and Professor Hulk (either Black Widow or Hawkeye can join)
6. Professor Hulk goes to the Ancient One to get the Time Stone, I think that went pretty well
7. Captain America picking up the Mind Stone with the use of Hail Hydra is pretty clever, so far so good
8. Relying on Ant Man, Black Widow and Hawkeye to secure the Space Stone/Tesseract? They might not be able to do so... they either have to fight through the 2012 Avengers to get the Space Stone/Tesseract, or steal it under their noses somehow. Ant Man with the combination of Hawkeye's arrow move again might work.
9. For the Asgard team, from the viewer's perspective this was kind of easy. The only problem was Thor's depression or PTSD. Who would have been able to get the Aether/Reality Stone while Thor is consoled by his mom? I could see Black Widow sneaking in pretty well. If Rocket could sneak in, I'm sure Black Widow could as well.
10. Or the most logical approach is for the team to see that Thor is in NO shape or form to actually function on a CRITICAL mission, and he gets benched from the mission, relying on Black Widow to do this mission on her own.
11. If Thor DOES get benched, then they free themselves 1 round trip of Pym Particles, and give them to a group that they see might have difficulty, for example one of the NY team members.
12. If the NY team has an extra round time trip, who will use it in case of their failed mission? The most reliable would be Captain America.
13. Captain America wouldn't think to go New Jersey 1970 (that was Iron Man's knowledge)
14. Considering they already have the Time Stone, and the Mind Stone, he just needed 1 place in time to get the Space/Tesseract
15. Where would Captain America go to get it? A place that ONLY CAPTAIN AMERICA knew where the Tesseract is FOR SURE?
16. Captain America would pick the time when he saw it while fighting Red Skull (end of Captain America 1)
17. There would be two Captain Americas fighting Red Skull, and our Cap would have to explain to Past Cap why he needs the Tesseract. Then time jumps back home.
So in the logical approach, these changes were possible:
-Rocket and Iron Man get into a fight on who will sacrifice their soul
-Iron Man would kill Rocket, getting the Soul Stone
-NY team could fail their mission, and not have Tony there to find a back up plan
-Thor gets benched, frees up Pym Particles
-Extra 1 round time trip extra for the NY group, who would use it?
-Captain America uses the extra time jump to get the Tesseract during his first fight with Red Skull (end of Captain America 1)
What are your thoughts?