Jump to content
The Official Site of the Vancouver Canucks
Canucks Community

mephnick

Members
  • Posts

    548
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by mephnick

  1. The amount of people willing to bet the rebuild on a kid who's never even been a 1B in the league is insane to me. Have you people followed hockey? Stud goalie prospects bomb all the time when made a starter. Most teams in the league are running 1A/1B goalie tandems now. That's how the NHL works. What's wrong with signing Marky for 5 years and having him and Demko split starts as Demko grows into the 1A role over a few years and then takes over when Marky's contract is up? Does Demko expect to be one of 3 goalies in the league getting 60 starts? I doubt it.

     

    If you want to make the playoffs in the next 2 years, you have to sign Marky. Management wants to make the playoffs in the next 2 years. They will sign Marky and offer up something to Seattle to protect Demko. So get ready to lose a decent young player (Virt) and a pick. That's the cost of expansion. Better than losing a top 10 goalie in his prime.

    • Cheers 4
  2. People are overrating the Rangers I think. Their defence as a whole is still weak. Lundqvist and Gorgiev aren't above average goalies. After Panarin/Zib their O still leaves a lot to be desired.

     

    They'll be a really good team in a few years, but not this year.

     

     

    On the other hand Minny is being faded hard by people for no reason. Glad they're up there on this one.

  3. Let's be honest. People "hate" on Jake because he was picked over better players that we wanted more and then failed to live up to the team's hype. Same as Juolevi.

     

    It's one thing if the consensus pick flops, it's another thing if a reach flops. It makes the team look stupid. I don't remember anyone who was calling for Jake over Nylander, Ehlers or even Ritchie. Now obviously it isn't Jake's fault he got picked at 6, but that's obviously where the hate comes from. If he was picked at 25th, no one would complain.

    • Upvote 3
  4. On 9/6/2019 at 1:23 AM, mll said:

    “Comparables sometimes play a part in a negotiation, but in the case of these players, they really don’t — unless you’re comparing yourself to a 10.2(c) player.”

     

    The last star 10.2c winger was Johnny Gaudreau who signed for 6x6.75 in 2016.

     

    Given the raise in contracts since then, I think 6-6.5 is the best Brock can hope for given 3 years.

  5. 25 minutes ago, Monty said:

    Yeah, Jake has been a terrific 6th overall pick...

    Jake is pretty much an average 6OA pick. Historically if your 6OA becomes a middle 6 player that's a pretty standard to good outcome.

     

    Maybe people have gotten used to these stacked drafts lately, but 6OA is the territory of the Filatov's, Brule's and Fata's as much as the Monahan's.

    • Upvote 1
  6. 12 hours ago, Warhippy said:

    Oh wow, didn't expect to see that at all.

     

    The more we see these top 10 drafted players not panning out the more I feel a shade less angst over the picks Benning has made

    Once you are out of the top 2, the chances of getting a bust skyrocket.

     

    That's why I'm so confused why Canucks fans treat 1st round picks as untouchable treasures.

    • Like 1
  7. 10 hours ago, debluvscanucks said:

    It must be a tough decision to step away...but it shows how very tough it is to get ready for a season. 

     

    Pretty much. I work with a few guys who played at a high level (AHL, NHL plugs etc) and they always say the biggest relief when they finally gave up was not having to prep for another season. A couple of them got in to other sports and never even wore the equipment again.

     

    If that can happen to a 25-30 year old, imagine being 37 and staring down another off season regime and training camp when you've already accomplished so much.

    • Upvote 1
  8. 3 hours ago, Pete M said:

    I believe the article said..."chaulk it up to injury"...just need to read between the lines...good read though and interesting analysis.

     

    "Perhaps there’s an explanation for Sutter’s struggles last season: health. After all, he missed 56 games and it’s hard to believe he was 100% for the 26 games he actually played." 

    Then don't base an article with a clickbait headline on that season?

     

    It's still poor journalism whether he gives himself an out or not.

    • Cheers 1
  9. 1 hour ago, shiznak said:

    Are you serious?

     

    He has had every opportunity in Edmonton to succeed, playing the majority of his time with either McDavid, Draisaitl or RNH as his centermen.

    Yeah. Poolparty (or his agent) demanded to play in the NHL, got time in the top-6 and couldn't do it. I don't think this is really on the Oilers.

     

    I think the guy is just not very good. Top 5 picks bust all the time. I'm not sure why everyone gives Puljujarvi the benefit of the doubt as if he's some star being held back.

    • Cheers 1
  10. On 8/19/2019 at 3:38 PM, Rindiculous said:

     Even with the huge turnover of playoff teams from year to year, analysts still always choose 14-15 of the same teams from last years playoffs to be in this year. 

    This annoys me so much. Analysts, Reddit, blogs whoever, always pick the exact same teams to make it the next year when on average 5-6 teams new teams make it every year.

  11. 6 hours ago, stawns said:

    How is paying RFA players UFA money on their second pro contract working out for teams that do it?  Oilers?  Leafs? 

    Hard to say. It just became the new normal.

     

    Young hockey players want to be paid in their prime like every other sport. Do you think this is a fad or something? Like..seriously? It's not going away.

     

    Every team will have to deal with this.If Debrincat scores 35+ again this year do you think he's signing for 6x6? LOL

  12. 40 minutes ago, stawns said:

    If I'm Benning I set an internal cap salary and players who expect more than that get moved.

    Your internal cap has to somewhat reflect market value or you end up being Melnyk and losing everyone.

     

    7mil for a PPG player with 40g upside is good value.

     

    I'd rather pay for players than save the Aquilinis some cash and becoming that team that loses all it's stars the second they become expensive.

×
×
  • Create New...