You accuse others of assuming and having unrealistic trade proposals while your proposals and assumptions are exactly the same except much to far in the Canucks' favor.
Okay which of these two deals is more slanted in either teams favourKing of ES's deal:
Luongo + Ballard for PaajarviGollumpus's deal:
Purcell + Aulie + 1st for Luongo + Sauve
It doesn't take a rocket scientist to see that Gollumpus's deal is much more realistic and much closer to a legitamite deal than King's is.
Your sole reasoning on your proposals is Gillis's wish list to Santa and that Luongo would be happy as Schneider's backup indefinitely.
Where are you getting this information??? He never said that, your just making stuff up to try to put a point behind your "unreasonable" argument.
And futhurmore, what this comment you just made, and the one he acctually made in his post, aren't even in the same context. Your refering to different things.
What if I told you that Brian Burke said the most he would trade for Luongo is Komisarek, a cap dump for a cap dump? You would completely dismiss this idea even if every other GM in the league was saying that's what they would offer for Luongo.
Your logic is circular and one sided.
This is pretty hypocritical of you to say.
Your logic is anything you say goes, it doesn't matter if it is in context with the original post or not, if you say something, your right.
Okay so now onto this last part. (Btw I didn't know you were that close to Brian Burke & the other GM's that they would tell you that information, oh wait, it's purley your speculation in a hypothetical situation that isn't likely at all). So really I'm not even sure what that was about since it is just your speculation about an unrealistic hypothetical situation.
And if your really underrating Roberto that much, then I suggest watching and paying attention to hockey a little more, cause then you would realize that Komisarek is overpaid for what he provides, and that he can barley stay in line-up.
Where as Luongo provides a good enough level of play to warrant the money he gets.
Basiclly, one is a 5th, 6th or 7th defensemen that is overpaid, and the other is a star goalie that in my honest opinion (after watching ever single game last year) was the best player on the president trophy winners.
Edited by Smashian Kassian, 05 November 2012 - 12:48 AM.