No its not comparble at all. Edler to Philly actually makes sense as they need D, whereas your proposal doesn't make sense for either team since Anaheim has Hiller.
It was a comparable deal. Getzalf is more established and higher valued than Edler. It was to show you that a bunch of people are overvaluing Edler.
(Value Of) Alex Edler to Philadelphia
Posted 04 January 2013 - 09:29 AM
In my eyes drouin is overrated he can score in the qmjhl but did nothing in last two gold medal games that canada lost. Fox will be better pro than him talk to me in five yrs
ryan kesler is going to the chicago blackhawks ... quote me on it
Posted 04 January 2013 - 10:16 AM
But why would Anaheim? They have Hillier as noted by another response; but also phenom prospect John Gibson who will probably be WJC MVP. To quote Bob MacKenzie; "I think Anaheim will be set in goal for a very long time!"
Not only will they not want to trade Couturier because he's a big part of their future, he is also cheap.
Schnieder, Gaunce, 1st FOR Getzlaf
Posted 04 January 2013 - 10:33 AM
Lets go bigger; Edler,Higgins, Lou and Gaunce, Philly buys out Brizzy and we get Simmonds, Couturier and Coburn?
I'm not so sure they wouldn't give him up. They got giroux schenn and couturier. Obviously they're going to posture and say no way, those 3 are off the table. But we're not going to trade a 26 yr old all star dman for anything less than a blue chip prospect coming back. So they look to find common ground with other pieces.
What if we counter with someone like gaunce included. That is a better fit long term for a 3rd line center. We get possibly a future number one center and they replace him with a guy that will fall into place. Now we're getting ripped there so they need to add more but it's a way to negotiate to a fair deal for both. Neither guy is willing to get fleeced but there is a deal there that can help both teams.
Edler is better than simmonds for immediate help
Couturier is better that gaunce for future help
Add in an evening out pick or 2
It balances out but the kicker is the uncertainty of edler resigning. I understand that but holmgrens got huge balls and wouldn't be surprised to see something like that.
Edit.. As for us needing a dman, that's where the luongo trade comes in... I hate to see edler go but if we can get a decent replacement for him via luongo, then I think this is the best possible way to maximize return on the situation. Get someone to bite and over pay for edler and get good replacement by maybe over paying with a Lu package. Or even just go with an adequate replacement for Lu straight up
Posted 04 January 2013 - 10:48 AM
Posted 04 January 2013 - 10:56 AM
could land you elder and a prospect, but that is too much cap to take for a team
Posted 04 January 2013 - 11:00 AM
Posted 04 January 2013 - 11:36 AM
Posted 04 January 2013 - 03:33 PM
true but if we are able to sign edler we should keep him i mean our defensive core isn't good enough for us to lose our best D
Good thing we're not trading Hamhuis.
Posted 05 January 2013 - 04:27 AM
Draft picks, other players. Sometimes teams need to be patient to wait for the right opportunity.
if the flyers want a number 1 d man and they are not willing to move schenn or couturier, then who are they going to trade to land an all-star/future all-star.
Posted 06 January 2013 - 12:52 PM