Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Lui's Knob

Asset Management lately (grade)

35 posts in this topic

I'll give MG some credit as the current Canucks GM that he's had a very impressive and quality start to his tenure, up until the surprising Hodgson deal. He's tried to make some bold moves (signing Sundin, signing Luongo to long term deal), attempted to find some reclamation project players (Torres, Lapierre, etc), but I feel lately his player/asset management has been nothing but an embarassing and oddly inexplicable failure...

1) Luongo/Schneider debacle since the playoffs and the fact he's still here (including the drama with McPhee and Nonis)

2) Malhotra decision (which appears he wants out but Gillis doesn't want him traded)

3) Inexplicable reason for putting Volpatti on waivers (and getting nothing for him in return; perhaps McPhee's way of accepting Gillis' apology)

4) The whole Kesler injury thing with him, his Agent and AV/MG

5) Kesler again playing injured when he should of sat (played on a broken foot since Dallas game; now out 1-2 months)

6) Kassian getting 5 minutes on the 4th line (how does this help his play when we need him to be contributing on the top 6 forwards?)

7) Picking up Cam Barker....Cam Barker?? (how about Ben Lovejoy for a pick?)

8) Inability to recognize the team has been missing a major intangible (drive?determination/scoring?coaching?depth? special teams?toughness?grit?leadership?ethic?) in their game since the SC Finals or at least since the Boston game last year...

9) The constant dealing with Florida and somehow we end up with damaged and somewhat overpriced goods (see Booth = injured, overvalued; Ballard = also injured, tough tranisition, still barely played; and even now Garrison= again also injured, tough start to season, although I'll give him more time to adjust but not off to a great start)

Who knows who's making the calls particularly this season (let's hope it's not Dave Gagner, our Florida 'throw-in' for Bure and who mis-managed Cody at the time), but they're not like previous years of asset management/top class NHL standard under MG's reign...what gives?

4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The thing that bothers me the most is Kassian is on the 4th ???? line, If he's not going to help us for another couple seasons then MG should have kept Hodgson or traded him for some help now.

3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

All depends on the big picture /plan. But with what's been made known to the public, the things that actually have happened and haven't and the situation at hand and how it has been implemented - is questionable.

Up until last summer, I think GMMG has done a good job. Now I'm not so sure about what he's been up to lately...

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Totally agree. MG has, as I put it lost focus. I site it further back though. I think it starts with the Samualsson deal.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Explain how Kesler's injury relates to asset management please.

3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

All depends on the big picture /plan. But with what's been made known to the public, the things that actually have happened and haven't and the situation at hand and how it has been implemented - is questionable.

Up until last summer, I think GMMG has done a good job. Now I'm not so sure about what he's been up to lately...

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

He really seems lost right now. Watch him trade Luongo and we get another player like Booth back as our main piece.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

5) is clearly false. It has been reported by numerous sources that two prior CT scans came back as negative for any sort of fracture. As soon as the third CT scan showed a fracture, Kesler was placed on IR.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ok i agree someone is asleep at the wheel of this ship. however, lets at least assign blame to the right spots if we are going to do this;

1) lluongo/schneider is a good thing. If it werent for 2 awsome goalies we would be a basement team this year.

2) I agree malhotra should be traded if he wants to play still. Only good if someone wants him tho.

3) remains to be seen what the reason for this is, Im sure an interviewer will ask.

4) whaat? kesler was trolling the media.

5) A broken foot can feel like a bruising (remember it was missed by x-rays), Also a skate-boot makes a pretty damn good cast. at least blame the medical staff for clearing him to play. Last i checked MG doesnt do medical.

6) This is a coaching decision, you nut. MG doesnt coach.

7) Barker is a depth pickup. he hasnt even played in the big club this year. Why does it matter?

8) again you seem to be confusing MG for part of the coaching staff.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I remember when we won 6 games in a row, and management looked liked they could do no wrong, especially with how both goalies were doing well. Now they're both doing poor, we're 2-2-2 and they're awful. But look on the brightside, we're in a division with Edmonton, Calgary, Minnesota, and Colorado...

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

having 2 goalies is no longer making any sense, especially when we are getting injured.

Trade schneider and be done with it, we have Lack, Cannata and if we get a high first pick in this years draft, then we can use our own first rounder this year to draft a goaltender

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Explain how Kesler's injury relates to asset management please.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Canuck Fans...... :picard:

1) Luongo/Schneider debacle since the playoffs and the fact he's still here (including the drama with McPhee and Nonis) Yea i really hate Gillis , Damn him for giving us the best goaltending duo over the last three years :sadno:

2) Malhotra decision (which appears he wants out but Gillis doesn't want him traded) Malhotra will be part of the coaching staff him and Gillis talked about other options for next year thats why he wasnt traded

3) Inexplicable reason for putting Volpatti on waivers (and getting nothing for him in return; perhaps McPhee's way of accepting Gillis' apologyoh my Gillis just gave away a career minor leaguer for nothing :picard:

4) The whole Kesler injury thing with him, his Agent and AV

MAYBE YOU SHOULD BE BLAMING KESLER HIS AGENT AND THE MEDIA

5) Kesler again playing injured when he should of sat (played on a broken foot since Dallas game; now out 1-2 months)

XRAYS SHOWED NO BROKEN BONES WHEN HE CAME HOME THEY DID A CT SCAN shows a hairline fracture

6) Kassian getting 5 minutes on the 4th line (how does this help his play when we need him to be contributing on the top 6 forwards?) ever herd of a utility player can play all 4 lines thats a tool for AV to utilise

7) Picking up Cam Barker....Cam Barker?? (how about Ben Lovejoy for a pick?)

wow crying about barker ... the guy hasnt even played yet :emot-parrot:

8) Inability to recognize the team has been missing a major intangible (drive?determination/scoring?coaching?depth? special teams?toughness?grit?leadership?ethic?) in their game since the SC Finals or at least since the Boston game last year...

you do realize the canucks are stanley cup favorites right we have plenty of drive?determination/scoring?coaching?depth? special teams?toughness?grit?leadership?ethic?

9) The constant dealing with Florida and somehow we end up with damaged and somewhat overpriced goods (see Booth = injured, overvalued; Ballard = also injured, tough tranisition, still barely played; and even now Garrison= again also injured, tough start to season, although I'll give him more time to adjust but not off to a great start

only thing I agree with is signing ballard

GO CANUCKS GO

let the haters hate

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

cdc has so many people that are smarter than gillis, better coaches than AV and better players than what's on the team...personally, i've never managed, coach or played in the nhl, so i can't say that i'm right and they are wrong...what i like about them, is they don't panic and make dumb moves that don't help the club or fit into the cap space.....AV will get this team back on track and gillis will make changes that make sense...

3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Totally agree. MG has, as I put it lost focus. I site it further back though. I think it starts with the Samualsson deal.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

cdc has so many people that are smarter than gillis, better coaches than AV and better players than what's on the team...personally, i've never managed, coach or played in the nhl, so i can't say that i'm right and they are wrong...what i like about them, is they don't panic and make dumb moves that don't help the club or fit into the cap space.....AV will get this team back on track and gillis will make changes that make sense...

3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

MG had a plan to build a team based on what he thought the NHL wanted which was speed and finnesse. When the league decided to allow the Bruins to brutalize those kinds of players with impunity in front of the whoel world, it was obvious, MG missed the boat (perhaps not his fault).

His ability to re-build the team to one that can withstand that kind of playing environment while retaining it's offence has been less than stellar.

He appears lost as to what the identity of this team is and it shows in the on-ice product.

HIs decision (or support) to go with Cory in the playoffs last year was a bold one and could be respected at the time. Had he dealt aLU and set the team on a new direction, it woudl have made sense. Failing to pull the trigger before this seaosn started has not played well with LU's value or the team (Cory) and now is a mess.

MG really needs to pull a rabbit from his hat that addresses all this and puts the team back on a clear path. RIght now, it looks like a rudderless ship.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The thing that bothers me the most is Kassian is on the 4th ???? line, If he's not going to help us for another couple seasons then MG should have kept Hodgson or traded him for some help now.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

this just proves how brainless MG is , when that trade went down he looked into the camera with a straight face and said this is the player we need in our lineup today to help this team go deep in the playoffs , no one else anywhere said he was ready to make an impact but MG. All analysts on tsn, sportsnet ect all said kassian is still a few years away from making an impact but MG thought he knew better than them. and he was dead wrong. hes coasting on a core of players that nonis and burke put in place. MG and AV are the equvilant of bill clinton (hear me out) everyone looks back to how good the economy was in the states when bill was incharge, he was a good pres ,but the tech and internet boom that provided hundreds of thousands of jobs in the states just happend to happen when he was president he had nothing to do with it. MG and AV just happen to be in charge when these great players that other GMs brought in hit their prime. AV didnt turn sedins kesler burrows ect into the players they are and MG didnt bring them in.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.