Jump to content
The Official Site of the Vancouver Canucks
Canucks Community

What should the asking prices be for each player excluding the Sedins?


Tom Sestito

Recommended Posts

I don't make many Canuck related threads, and I rarely make post-game type threads. Since Lebrun has stated everyone but the Sedins is untouchable, what should the asking prices be if Gillis decides to make some moves?

Goalies

Luongo = late first, two seconds type deal. Not a super high value, because of how the rest of the league perceives his contract.

***Lack = Ben Bishop/Ben Scrivens type deals. I know we value him at more than a late 2nd, or an OK young roster player, but that's pretty much the type of market that there is for goalies.

Forwards

Zac Dalpe = Late third

Jannik Hansen = 2nd + mid tier prospect or a late first.

Higgins = He'll have value for a contending team. Same as Hansen

***Kassian = Same type of player at the same level.

Kesler = top prospect + 1st or a top ten draft pick in a deep draft. (Schneider type value) Or even, look at the Mike Richards trade. Wayne Simmonds, Brayden Schenn and a second? I'd bend over back for a return like that.

Richardson = Late 2nd, early 3rd.

Schroeder = mid-late 2nd.

***Sedins won't be moved, period.

Sestito = 1st round pick

Weise = equally stupid fourth liner

***Booth = equally as bad contract

***Burrows = ... what do we even ask for him at this point?

Defense

Bieksa = 1st round pick, good prospect.

Edler = 1st round pick, good prospect.

Tanev = Young forward with equal value like I've been suggesting for since the season started.

***Garrison = 1st round pick, mid prospect.

***Hamhuis = 1st round pick + top prospect or another top ten pick + maybe..

Stanton = late 2nd, early third.

I'm not valuing these guys at what we as a fan-base value them at. I'm trying to value them at what other GM's might value them at. Guys with stars are players I don't expect to move under any circumstance (IN THE NEAR FUTURE), and the reasons range from bad contract to loyalty +.

Kind of stealing the idea from LucBourdon on HF.

I'm also proposing we have just one trade proposals thread.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Forwards:

Kesler: 2 B grade prospects, young roster player (23-26)

Burrows: Late 1st round pick (or packaged in bigger trade)

Higgins: Forward prospect ( C - B- range), 2nd round pick

Hansen: C grade prospect (forward or defence)

Weise: 3rd or 4th round pick

Sestito: 3rd round pick

Richardson: Mid-level prospect, 4th round pick

Dalpe: Mid 3rd round pick

Kassian: Early 1st round pick (10th-12th overall)

Booth: Getting a 5th-6th round pick would be a great return

Schroeder: Mid 2nd round pick

Defence:

Hamhuis: Top six forward, defence prospect, early 2nd round pick

Bieksa: Defence prospect (B level), mid-late 1st round pick (19th-30th)

Edler: Either a top prospect and a 1st or a young top six forward and a 1st round pick

Garrison: B grade prospect, early 2nd round pick (31st-40th)

Tanev: Mid 1st round pick, mid-level forward prospect

Stanton: Mid-late 2nd round pick

Goalies:

Luongo: Forward prospect, mid-late 1st round pick

Lack: Late 1st round pick or early 2nd round pick

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Forwards

Zac Dalpe = 3rd

Jannik Hansen = 2nd

Higgins = 2nd

***Kassian = I wouldnt trade him but if I were to, a late 1st and a prospect. (no point in trading for a similar player because whats the point then?)

Kesler = top prospect + 1st or a top ten draft pick in a deep draft. (Schneider type value) Or even, look at the Mike Richards trade. Wayne Simmonds, Brayden Schenn and a second? I'd bend over back for a return like that.

Richardson = 3rd.

Schroeder = mid-late 2nd.

***Sedins won't be moved, period.

Sestito = 3rd rounder

Weise = no value

***Booth = 4th rounder

***Burrows = ... what do we even ask for him at this point? Late 1st (would be a great player for the playoffs playing 2nd or 3rd line with PK duties)

Defense

Bieksa = top 20 1st round pick and a decent prospect.

Edler = 1st round pick and a prospect.

Tanev = (I wouldnt trade him as his play is worth more than his value but value would be 2nd rounder)

***Garrison = late 1st round pick or a good prospect.

***Hamhuis = 1st round pick + top prospect

Stanton = late 2nd, early third.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Goalies

Luongo = 1st round pick + a contract coming back

Lack = 2nd round pick + mid-tier prospect

Forwards

Zac Dalpe = 6th-7th round pick

Jannik Hansen = 2nd round pick+ mid-tier prospect

Higgins = 2nd + 3rd round pick

Kassian = Late 1st/Early 2nd round pick + a solid prospect

Kesler = 1st round pick + top prospect + roster player

Richardson = 3rd round pick

Schroeder = 4th round pick

Sestito = Prospect

Weise = 6th/7th round pick

Booth = Booth+retained salary for a similar contract

Burrows = 3rd round pick at this point. When he's playing well, 2nd + a mid-level prospect

Defense

Bieksa = 1st round pick + mid-tier prospect

Edler = 1st round pick + top prospect

Tanev = 1st round pick

Garrison = 1st round pick + 2nd round pick

Hamhuis = 1st round pick, 2nd round pick, 2 mid-tier prospects

Stanton = 3rd round pick

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Goalies

Luongo = Late first/2nd + B prospect

Lack = 2nd

Forwards

Zac Dalpe = 4th

Jannik Hansen 2nd + B prospect

Higgins = 2nd + B prospect

Kassian = Young player of the same calibre. (Coyle, Couturier, etc)

Kesler = Top prospect + late first

Richardson = 2nd + 3rd. (Would be the only player I wouldn't trade)

Schroeder = 3rd + 4th

Sedins = Free for cap space

Sestito = 3rd

Weise = 5th

Booth = Free

Burrows = expiring overpaid ufa

Defense

Bieksa = Late first

Edler = 1st round pick, young forward prospect

Tanev = Young forward with equal value

Garrison = 1st round pick + B prospect

Hamhuis = 1st round pick + top prospect

Stanton = 2nd round pick

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't make many Canuck related threads, and I rarely make post-game type threads. Since Lebrun has stated everyone but the Sedins is untouchable, what should the asking prices be if Gillis decides to make some moves?

Goalies

Luongo = late first, two seconds type deal. Not a super high value, because of how the rest of the league perceives his contract.

***Lack = Ben Bishop/Ben Scrivens type deals. I know we value him at more than a late 2nd, or an OK young roster player, but that's pretty much the type of market that there is for goalies.

Forwards

Zac Dalpe = Late third

Jannik Hansen = 2nd + mid tier prospect or a late first.

Higgins = He'll have value for a contending team. Same as Hansen

***Kassian = Same type of player at the same level.

Kesler = top prospect + 1st or a top ten draft pick in a deep draft. (Schneider type value) Or even, look at the Mike Richards trade. Wayne Simmonds, Brayden Schenn and a second? I'd bend over back for a return like that.

Richardson = Late 2nd, early 3rd.

Schroeder = mid-late 2nd.

***Sedins won't be moved, period.

Sestito = 1st round pick

Weise = equally stupid fourth liner

***Booth = equally as bad contract

***Burrows = ... what do we even ask for him at this point?

Defense

Bieksa = 1st round pick, good prospect.

Edler = 1st round pick, good prospect.

Tanev = Young forward with equal value like I've been suggesting for since the season started.

***Garrison = 1st round pick, mid prospect.

***Hamhuis = 1st round pick + top prospect or another top ten pick + maybe..

Stanton = late 2nd, early third.

I'm not valuing these guys at what we as a fan-base value them at. I'm trying to value them at what other GM's might value them at. Guys with stars are players I don't expect to move under any circumstance (IN THE NEAR FUTURE), and the reasons range from bad contract to loyalty +.

Kind of stealing the idea from LucBourdon on HF.

I'm also proposing we have just one trade proposals thread.

1st of all, if all you get is a late 1st pick and a couple 2nds for Lu... You're crazy if you think that's all Lu is worth.

Also, Lack is worth a 1st round pick as of next year. He's also untouchable especially if you were trading Lu, he's a young promising Goalie who is showing flashes of brilliance.

Kassian is also young, you do not trade young and promising players when rebuilding.

Same with Dalpe

Kesler + Sedins aren't going anywhere

Richardson is a vet you would keep in your bottom 6 for leader ship.

Schroeder, young and promising.

Sestito, no 1 is trading for Sestito

Booth Buy-out

Burrows a B+/A- Prospect or late 1st

Higgins why would you trade someone for the same thing?

Hansen wouldn't be moved

Bieksa agreed

Edler Young Semi developed prospect (Hertl/Yakupov category)

Tanev wouldnt go anywhere Young and promising to continue to be amazing

Garrison agreed

Hammer would stay for veteran presence on the blue line

Stanton.............YOUNG AND PROMISING lol

You don't trade good young players in a rebuild.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Interesting lil tidbit

D Sedin last 106 games 25 Goals

D Booth last 107 games 22 Goals

Yet Booth gets crucified and Sedins avoid any criticism. Just don't seem right.

D Sedin 25 goals 55 assists 80 points. +21 6 GWG over 1 plus season.

D Booth 22 goals 22 assists 44 points. +1 1 GWG over 2 plus seasons.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The club has been missing 3 key pieces for the last 3 years.

Top six legitimate sniper to score 25-35

Third line center to play against other teams top line and score 15

PP QB

When we were top dogs in the league. We had guys who filled those roles. Even if it was for only. 2-3 seasons . Burrows performed like the finisher the Sedins needed. Ehrhoff and Salo both QB 'Ed tge leagues best PP while Manny filled in nicely for his 3/4 of a season before his brutal eye injury. The guys MG brought in to replace or upgrade these positions have not worked out due to injuries or a severe drop in play.

David Booth was brought in to play a top six role and pump in 20-30. We all know how well that is going.

Sammi Pahlson, Derrick Roy and niw Richardson couldn't shut down most teams third lines.

Garrison and Edler can't QB a PP if it was a five on three every time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Realistically, without overvaluing our players.

Goalies

Luongo = late first rounder (20-30), 2nd rounder, and a solid 3rd liner (Eg. Chris Kelly, Steve Ott, etc)

***Lack = 2nd rounder or another solid 3rd liner.

Forwards

Zac Dalpe = 3rd rounder or a prospect who hasn't panned out (eg. Luke Adams, Jon Blum, Victor Rask, etc)

Jannik Hansen = 2nd rounder or a B-level prospects (eg. Ty Rattie, Scott Laughton, Tom Wilson, etc) or a solid 3rd liner straight up (Helm, Peverley, etc)

Higgins = Same as Hansen

***Kassian = an underdeveloped prospects (Matt Pumpel, Nathan Beaulieu, etc) or a solid 2nd liner (Gallagher, Pominville, Gagner, etc.)

Kesler = decent 2nd liner (Nyquist, Franzen, Brassard, etc), and a blue chip prospect (Mantha, Lazar, Toffoli, etc). Or a 1st line winger straight up (Ladd, Pacioretty, Lucic, etc)

Richardson = 2nd rounder

Schroeder = 2nd rounder

***Sedins won't be moved, period.

Sestito = 4th liner or a 4th rounder

Weise = same as Sestito

***Booth = equal bad contact

***Burrows = decent 2nd liner or a late 1st

Defense

Bieksa = 1st round pick or B-level prospect

Edler = Solid 2nd liner, straight up or a mid 1st rounder and a decent 2nd liner

Tanev = decent 2nd liner or mid 1st rounder

***Garrison = late 1st and a decent 3rd liner (Raymond, Talbot, Clutterbuck , etc)

***Hamhuis= mid 1st and a solid 3rd liner or a decent 2nd liner.

Stanton = 2nd rounder

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If there is going to be a shake up to make this team better it has to start with the Sedins (don't care that they got extended for 4 more years). These 2 are supposed to be our go to guys, when was the last time you saw them take this team on there backs and say let's go boys (NEVER!!!!), oh they have had some great /good games and usually against bottom feeder teams that don't play a physical game or a game that is out of reach( not much of that even, this year). Don't get me wrong I still think that they can very good players but I firmly believe that they should never be the focal point on this team, at best they should be complimentary(2nd line) on this team. Since LA, Ana, SJ,Stl, Chi.all are bigger and faster we need to try and join them, so, how do you do that, not overnight. We have 1 asset on D that can get us headed in that direction and that is Edler (lots of takers, just not sure where he would want (NTC - Det/NYR/TOR are my guesses). Next is Luongo, same as Edler, just different teams (Florida ?? has to be as East coast). Then the Sedins, this tougher as they also have a NTC but need to be packaged together (less teams = less return), Columbus, NJ,Buffalo (????). We have lesser players that could be moved also, Hanson/ Weise but I was focusing on our core. After moving these guys,if you can, then we get rid a few of our scouts ( not a good track record), the draft is where we have to improve if we want to join the elite teams again. Most likely never happen but if I was GM this s where I would start.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't make many Canuck related threads, and I rarely make post-game type threads. Since Lebrun has stated everyone but the Sedins is untouchable, what should the asking prices be if Gillis decides to make some moves?

Goalies

Luongo = late first, two seconds type deal. Not a super high value, because of how the rest of the league perceives his contract.

***Lack = Ben Bishop/Ben Scrivens type deals. I know we value him at more than a late 2nd, or an OK young roster player, but that's pretty much the type of market that there is for goalies.

Forwards

Zac Dalpe = Late third

Jannik Hansen = 2nd + mid tier prospect or a late first.

Higgins = He'll have value for a contending team. Same as Hansen

***Kassian = Same type of player at the same level.

Kesler = top prospect + 1st or a top ten draft pick in a deep draft. (Schneider type value) Or even, look at the Mike Richards trade. Wayne Simmonds, Brayden Schenn and a second? I'd bend over back for a return like that.

Richardson = Late 2nd, early 3rd.

Schroeder = mid-late 2nd.

***Sedins won't be moved, period.

Sestito = 1st round pick

Weise = equally stupid fourth liner

***Booth = equally as bad contract

***Burrows = ... what do we even ask for him at this point?

Defense

Bieksa = 1st round pick, good prospect.

Edler = 1st round pick, good prospect.

Tanev = Young forward with equal value like I've been suggesting for since the season started.

***Garrison = 1st round pick, mid prospect.

***Hamhuis = 1st round pick + top prospect or another top ten pick + maybe..

Stanton = late 2nd, early third.

I'm not valuing these guys at what we as a fan-base value them at. I'm trying to value them at what other GM's might value them at. Guys with stars are players I don't expect to move under any circumstance (IN THE NEAR FUTURE), and the reasons range from bad contract to loyalty +.

Kind of stealing the idea from LucBourdon on HF.

I'm also proposing we have just one trade proposals thread.

I think your undervaluing Sestito. At least add an A prospect.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You don't trade good young players in a rebuild.

Completely agree, you don't trade young players in a retool either. Kassian has been the second best player only to higgins over this last stretch, he's taken so much steps forward and looks to be a real asset. Same can be said about Lack's play

Tanev, Schreoder, Kassian, Lack, Stanton are all good young pieces moving forward and should not be moved

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Forwards:

Kesler: 2 B grade prospects, young roster player (23-26)

Burrows: Late 1st round pick (or packaged in bigger trade)

Higgins: Forward prospect ( C - B- range), 2nd round pick

Hansen: C grade prospect (forward or defence)

Weise: 3rd or 4th round pick

Sestito: 3rd round pick

Richardson: Mid-level prospect, 4th round pick

Dalpe: Mid 3rd round pick

Kassian: Early 1st round pick (10th-12th overall)

Booth: Getting a 5th-6th round pick would be a great return

Schroeder: Mid 2nd round pick

Defence:

Hamhuis: Top six forward, defence prospect, early 2nd round pick

Bieksa: Defence prospect (B level), mid-late 1st round pick (19th-30th)

Edler: Either a top prospect and a 1st or a young top six forward and a 1st round pick

Garrison: B grade prospect, early 2nd round pick (31st-40th)

Tanev: Mid 1st round pick, mid-level forward prospect

Stanton: Mid-late 2nd round pick

Goalies:

Luongo: Forward prospect, mid-late 1st round pick

Lack: Late 1st round pick or early 2nd round pick

Wow. Some times it's obvious when a fan has only followed hockey for a short while. Seriously what is this crap? I mean wow, just when I thought I had seen it all.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

D Sedin 25 goals 55 assists 80 points. +21 6 GWG over 1 plus season.

D Booth 22 goals 22 assists 44 points. +1 1 GWG over 2 plus seasons.

And,

D.Sedin = $7M

D. Booth = $4.5M

Are we really expecting Booth to keep pace with our "star" forward? No. And I don't see much of an improvement in stats

Daniel has to be better. Period.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sestito = 1st round pick

:picard:

1st of all, if all you get is a late 1st pick and a couple 2nds for Lu... You're crazy if you think that's all Lu is worth.

:picard: Two seasons of desperately trying to trade him, and at the end no team was willing to even give up two second rounders for him. Even delusional MG gave up on trading Lu and fans still overvalue his worth

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't make many Canuck related threads, and I rarely make post-game type threads. Since Lebrun has stated everyone but the Sedins is untouchable, what should the asking prices be if Gillis decides to make some moves?

Goalies

Luongo = late first, two seconds type deal. Not a super high value, because of how the rest of the league perceives his contract.

***Lack = Ben Bishop/Ben Scrivens type deals. I know we value him at more than a late 2nd, or an OK young roster player, but that's pretty much the type of market that there is for goalies.

Forwards

Zac Dalpe = Late third

Jannik Hansen = 2nd + mid tier prospect or a late first.

Higgins = He'll have value for a contending team. Same as Hansen

***Kassian = Same type of player at the same level.

Kesler = top prospect + 1st or a top ten draft pick in a deep draft. (Schneider type value) Or even, look at the Mike Richards trade. Wayne Simmonds, Brayden Schenn and a second? I'd bend over back for a return like that.

Richardson = Late 2nd, early 3rd.

Schroeder = mid-late 2nd.

***Sedins won't be moved, period.

Sestito = 1st round pick

Weise = equally stupid fourth liner

***Booth = equally as bad contract

***Burrows = ... what do we even ask for him at this point?

Defense

Bieksa = 1st round pick, good prospect.

Edler = 1st round pick, good prospect.

Tanev = Young forward with equal value like I've been suggesting for since the season started.

***Garrison = 1st round pick, mid prospect.

***Hamhuis = 1st round pick + top prospect or another top ten pick + maybe..

Stanton = late 2nd, early third.

I'm not valuing these guys at what we as a fan-base value them at. I'm trying to value them at what other GM's might value them at. Guys with stars are players I don't expect to move under any circumstance (IN THE NEAR FUTURE), and the reasons range from bad contract to loyalty +.

Kind of stealing the idea from LucBourdon on HF.

I'm also proposing we have just one trade proposals thread.

Just so we are clear. Luongo isn't worth a 1st and blue chip.

But Setitio alone is worth a 1st?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

:picard:

:picard: Two seasons of desperately trying to trade him, and at the end no team was willing to even give up two second rounders for him. Even delusional MG gave up on trading Lu and fans still overvalue his worth

Two seasons of having 2 goaltenders and the entire league trying to bottom dollar Gillis. New season of rising cap and decent cap hit with no goaltending controversy and an olympic showcase.

Seriously people, STOP looking at the last 2 seasons as some sort of indicator as to why Lou cannot be traded. The cap is rising by SEVEN MILLION this year alone and could rise by as much as SEVEN MILLION next year.....

A top 10 goaltender with a $5.33 million cap hit will be very attractive when back ups are all demanding $4 million in 2 seasons

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Goalies

Luongo = 1st and a prospect

***Lack = Worthless 3rd round pick at best, he's got less than 20 NHL games

Forwards

Zac Dalpe = Late third

Jannik Hansen = multiple 2nd round picks, 2nd and 3rd or 1st round pick to a contending team in the 25-30 spot

Higgins = Based on contract same as Hansen

***Kassian = Untouchable

Kesler = 1st round pick and blue chip prospect or multiple blue chips. Johansen and a 2nd/3rd wennberg/Rychel

Richardson =4th and 7th round pick MAYBE

Schroeder = Lucky to get a 4th round pick right now

***Sedins = Untouchable

Sestito = 5th round pick

Weise = 5th round pick

***Booth = Buyout

***Burrows = ... Package for 2nd and 3rd

Defense

Bieksa = 1st round pick

Edler = 1st and blue chip prospect

Tanev = Untouchable

***Garrison = 1st round pick

***Hamhuis = 1st round pick Solid B prospect

Stanton = Untouchable

This is about realistic
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...