Mafia - Pike's Place Market Murder [MAFIA WIN!] - New Game Sign up in Progress

[diesel_3]

2 minutes ago, Zfetch said:

J23 is the no-brainer vote imo

Any hard evidence?

Or just because he is jumping on votes?

[Master Radishes]

AV must have been the SK. He could/would have claimed Vig to save himself otherwise. Vig missed R1 too, so most likely did the same here.

 

J23 and Armbar are my top suspects still. But I agree with BW that we need to discuss this thoroughly.

[Master Radishes]

2 hours ago, Beluga Whale said:

There's 6 players so it's either 4 Town vs 2 mafia or 3v3 (most likely imo).

I don't think it can be 3v3, as technically the Mafia win then, no? It's clearly 2 scum left.

 

Other than general inactivity, why Diesel?

[Master Radishes]

9 minutes ago, Zfetch said:

J23 is the no-brainer vote imo

I think so. But let's give it a good discussion. We're getting to that point where we can't afford to leave any stone unturned.

[diesel_3]

I feel i've been fairly active.

I keep going back to each persons posts from the previous votes, I know i'm on @Zfetch's radar, but I honestly believe him to also be a TP.

 

Lots of shade being tossed towards J23 and Armbar, Wanting more hard evidence or theories on both.

[Master Radishes]

11 minutes ago, diesel_3 said:

Lots of shade being tossed towards J23 and Armbar, Wanting more hard evidence or theories on both.

Cliffs:

 

J23: bandwagoning every vote, has apologised for doing it but then continues to do it; doesn't give thoughts or opinions of his own

Armbar: his behaviour on the DC vote from R2 was sketchy: he started the vote without much reason, jumped off it when it picked up and tried to get others to do the same, and only rejoined it (without a given reason) once it was clear DC was doomed

 

I think the 'hard' evidence is against Armbar, in that his actions speak of a Mafia; whereas the 'soft' evidence is against J23, in that it's his behaviour that is suspect.

[diesel_3]

13 minutes ago, Master Radishes said:

Cliffs:

 

J23: bandwagoning every vote, has apologised for doing it but then continues to do it; doesn't give thoughts or opinions of his own

Armbar: his behaviour on the DC vote from R2 was sketchy: he started the vote without much reason, jumped off it when it picked up and tried to get others to do the same, and only rejoined it (without a given reason) once it was clear DC was doomed

 

I think the 'hard' evidence is against Armbar, in that his actions speak of a Mafia; whereas the 'soft' evidence is against J23, in that it's his behaviour that is suspect.

Hm, good points.

I also think that you and BW are bigger personalities in this game, I really can't see having a more quiet TP and all the strong vets as Mafia/Special.

So, if it is 4v2...Me, You, Zfetch, BW as TP and Armbar, J23 as Mafia? 

 

Just my quick breakdown, The Votes have been all over the place, so it's tough to pick up a strong pattern.

[J-23]

Armbar is mafia for sure he tried to bus a teammate by voting DC. Also, he's been quiet recently. MR, and BW are also very suspicious right now. I'm not mafia. I'm TP.

[Zfetch]

MR, why are you not mafia?

[Master Radishes]

1 hour ago, J-23 said:

Armbar is mafia for sure he tried to bus a teammate by voting DC. Also, he's been quiet recently. MR, and BW are also very suspicious right now. I'm not mafia. I'm TP.

Is this guy for real?

[Master Radishes]

5 minutes ago, Zfetch said:

MR, why are you not mafia?

Because T-rex made me a TP.

[Master Radishes]

Vote J23. Signing off for bed (for me) since no one is talking much.

 

Zfetch: your thoughts on BW, Armbar, and/or diesel?

[Zfetch]

7 minutes ago, Master Radishes said:

Zfetch: your thoughts on BW, Armbar, and/or diesel?

BW started strong and has now disappeared. If I were mafia I'd probably reverse that activity. This round is pivotal to see how he acts.

 

Armbar I feel is TP but the more and more he is inactive and the more that everyone is calling him out without voting him is making me wary of him. I am starting to think he could be mafia.

 

Idk bout Diesel. Gut says mafia head says not. He's a coin flip imo. 

[diesel_3]

Too many people have been quiet today and honestly don't know where i'm going to vote.

My earlier thought was Arm, J23 possible Mafia.

 

Still want to see how the day plays out.

[Beluga Whale]

4 hours ago, Master Radishes said:

I don't think it can be 3v3, as technically the Mafia win then, no? It's clearly 2 scum left.

 

Other than general inactivity, why Diesel?

If the town has a vig in the game they can still win from a 3v3 or any tie. 

 

It's not that he's necessarily been that scummy but nothing he says seems very genuine. I particularly didn't like the post below:

 

4 hours ago, diesel_3 said:

Nah, I barely even know what's going on, I figured I was so obviously TP since i'm new and wouldn't be trusted with an actual responsibility.

I have no idea how each person plays from games past. I'm TP all the way.

None of these reasons are valid evidence for you being town at all. In fact I've seen a lot of excuses and defending from you all game. Obviously I don't know how you play but that type of behavior is more often associated with scum than town.

[Beluga Whale]

I'll say it again, no one should be insinuating the roles aren't distributed entirety randomly.

[Beluga Whale]

4 hours ago, diesel_3 said:

Hm, good points.

I also think that you and BW are bigger personalities in this game, I really can't see having a more quiet TP and all the strong vets as Mafia/Special.

So, if it is 4v2...Me, You, Zfetch, BW as TP and Armbar, J23 as Mafia? 

 

Just my quick breakdown, The Votes have been all over the place, so it's tough to pick up a strong pattern.

This bothers me too. The rationale to put MR as town does not compute and i don't like how diesel is talking to MR like he knows he's town when there's really no reason to be so certain.

[Armbar]

Has Diesel contributed a single original thought all game? I'm seriously asking.

 

This guy definitely hasn't:

 

vote J23

 

[Armbar]

4 hours ago, J-23 said:

Armbar is mafia for sure he tried to bus a teammate by voting DC. Also, he's been quiet recently. MR, and BW are also very suspicious right now. I'm not mafia. I'm TP.

It's like Stamkos and MH had a baby.

[J-23]

3 hours ago, Master Radishes said:

Is this guy for real?

Yes I'm for real.

 

Vote: MR