Recommended Posts

8 minutes ago, stawns said:

Well, I think JB just shut the idea of trading edler down completely.  

It was always HIGHLY unlikely but until I see a signed extension or a passed TDL I'm not declaring anything 'fait accompli'.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, aGENT said:

It was always HIGHLY unlikely but until I see a signed extension or a passed TDL I'm not declaring anything 'fait accompli'.

fair enough. 

  • Hydration 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Edler has played great this year....but Hutton is still an upgrade...!

 

Edler is 32 years old and has just figured it out....finally...the mistakes are fewer, the bad pinches almost not there anymore and the slow feet are being better mitigated by making the right decisions....but he is 32, it's only going to go south from here...

 

Hutton has made big strides this year and I see no reason that he won't continue to improve, he is 25 years old and just coming into his prime.

A Hughes/ Edler pairing would be a mess in my opinion ...but a Hughes / Hutton pairing may work out well, Ben moves better than Eddie and is the right age to be a role model but not an elder statesman that Quinn feels he has to acquiesce to all the time...aka Edler...

Trade Edler for a first and resign him in the summer if we want too....

  • Confused 1
  • Upvote 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
42 minutes ago, Rollieo Del Fuego said:

Edler has played great this year....but Hutton is still an upgrade...!

 

Edler is 32 years old and has just figured it out....finally...the mistakes are fewer, the bad pinches almost not there anymore and the slow feet are being better mitigated by making the right decisions....but he is 32, it's only going to go south from here...

 

Hutton has made big strides this year and I see no reason that he won't continue to improve, he is 25 years old and just coming into his prime.

A Hughes/ Edler pairing would be a mess in my opinion ...but a Hughes / Hutton pairing may work out well, Ben moves better than Eddie and is the right age to be a role model but not an elder statesman that Quinn feels he has to acquiesce to all the time...aka Edler...

Trade Edler for a first and resign him in the summer if we want too....

What are you even talking about? Edler has been a very good defense man for a long time. :picard: Just like every player he has up and down years.

 

Plus trading UFA and then resigning them in the summer almost never happens in real life. Although it sounds like a great idea it does not happen. Just sign Edler now with a team friendly contract if possible.

 

 

  • Hydration 2
  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, CRAZY_4_NAZZY said:

 

 

Ummm. I hope your full of crap JB. If Hughes plays 11 games you will need to protect him leaving one less option for you at the expansion draft. I hope he said that for optics. 

  • Upvote 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, Rollieo Del Fuego said:

Edler has played great this year....but Hutton is still an upgrade...!

 

Edler is 32 years old and has just figured it out....finally...the mistakes are fewer, the bad pinches almost not there anymore and the slow feet are being better mitigated by making the right decisions....but he is 32, it's only going to go south from here...

 

Hutton has made big strides this year and I see no reason that he won't continue to improve, he is 25 years old and just coming into his prime.

A Hughes/ Edler pairing would be a mess in my opinion ...but a Hughes / Hutton pairing may work out well, Ben moves better than Eddie and is the right age to be a role model but not an elder statesman that Quinn feels he has to acquiesce to all the time...aka Edler...

Trade Edler for a first and resign him in the summer if we want too....

If Edler really wants to help the team, this is what he does.  But I can also see the merits of being a one team long term guy, because today, its ultraaaaaaaaa rare.  I am fine either way, but prefer the first.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
21 minutes ago, aGENT said:

I took that as:

 

'We're well aware of the 10 games and have a plan in place to keep him under that limit. Hence I'm not at all worried about that'

Gotcha. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, rekker said:

Gotcha. 

Hopefully anyway :lol:

  • Hydration 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 hours ago, Rollieo Del Fuego said:

Edler has played great this year....but Hutton is still an upgrade...!

 

Edler is 32 years old and has just figured it out....finally...the mistakes are fewer, the bad pinches almost not there anymore and the slow feet are being better mitigated by making the right decisions....but he is 32, it's only going to go south from here...

 

Hutton has made big strides this year and I see no reason that he won't continue to improve, he is 25 years old and just coming into his prime.

A Hughes/ Edler pairing would be a mess in my opinion ...but a Hughes / Hutton pairing may work out well, Ben moves better than Eddie and is the right age to be a role model but not an elder statesman that Quinn feels he has to acquiesce to all the time...aka Edler...

Trade Edler for a first and resign him in the summer if we want too....

I can’t take you seriously when you talk about how he’s improved this year, but that somehow he absolutely must go south from now on. Who’s to say he won’t continue and improve (even if just slightly) for the next 3-5 years? You literally just admitted he improved at 32, so why does it absolutely have to stop? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 1/31/2019 at 5:28 PM, Alflives said:

Letang is really good.  So is Doughty.  So was Keith.  So was Chara.  Great D men make their D core (and goalies) look a lot better than they really are.  These great D also make the forwards look better too.  We have Quinn coming, so he will be our super, elite, generational, great D man.  

Although, I do really like EK too.  If we sign him, then we have two super elite guys!!!

True... although Fleury has continued to look fantastic after his move from Pens...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 1/31/2019 at 5:32 PM, The Lock said:

Haha You are right that it would be hard to copycat, but one could also point out that if by some miracle we won the draft lottery and drafted Hughes, we'd effectively have done just that in having Pettersson and Hughes as a one-two punch (and having Horvat as the 3rd center would just be ridiculously hard for opposing teams). Boeser would be our Kessel (not a serious comparison before someone whacks me on the head for suggesting that). Hughes would be our Letang. Think about that. ;)

 

I'm obviously not saying that will happen. What I'm saying is knowing where we stand in the draft later on could have a major impact on who we target come free agency. That being said, Pittsburgh has brought in veteran defense from time to time like Martin, etc.

 

Would be funny to see that happen though. Can we live in Neverland just once?

Drool.... Although with Gaudette, Sutter and Beagle around as well, maybe either Hughes or Pettersson moves to the wing, keeping Horvat as 2nd C having two dynamite top lines TripB being our 2nd line Wowsa...

Add a free agency top defender to the mix, maybe even Trym, and we are in business for real....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
19 hours ago, Rollieo Del Fuego said:

Edler has played great this year....but Hutton is still an upgrade...!

 

Edler is 32 years old and has just figured it out....finally...the mistakes are fewer, the bad pinches almost not there anymore and the slow feet are being better mitigated by making the right decisions....but he is 32, it's only going to go south from here...

 

Hutton has made big strides this year and I see no reason that he won't continue to improve, he is 25 years old and just coming into his prime.

A Hughes/ Edler pairing would be a mess in my opinion ...but a Hughes / Hutton pairing may work out well, Ben moves better than Eddie and is the right age to be a role model but not an elder statesman that Quinn feels he has to acquiesce to all the time...aka Edler...

Trade Edler for a first and resign him in the summer if we want too....

Whaaaa?

 

Hutton has taken some good strides this year, but is not close to Edler IMO.  If anything, Hutton progress has helped lighten the load enough on Edler so he oant making mistakes.

 

Edler has had some ups and downs so far, but is a work horse.  He has been playing against top lines for 10 years and holds his own.  Ideally he would be our 2nd-3rd d man.  Hutton hasn't taken the mantle away from him and is nowhere near as good at the same age as Edler.  

 

IMO Hutton has been the guy we have vs the guy we want.  He has truly benefited from Trymakin's sulk and OJ injuries.  He is an okay second pairing guy.  He shouldn't cost alot and we need the depth.  Hughes will push him down shortly and if Hutton becomes our 5 d man then we are in a good spot.  

 

Also Hughes, Hutton and Edler are all LHD.  They shouldn't be partners.  IMO Hutton should play with Stetcher,  Hughes with Guddy and Edler with Tanev.  

 

Switch Stecher and Tanev depending on match ups.  Edler Tanev could be a good shur down and I think Hughes could carry Guddy and bring our Guddy's potential.  

Edited by Phat Fingers

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, HorvatToBaertschi said:

I can’t take you seriously when you talk about how he’s improved this year, but that somehow he absolutely must go south from now on. Who’s to say he won’t continue and improve (even if just slightly) for the next 3-5 years? You literally just admitted he improved at 32, so why does it absolutely have to stop? 

His improvements have been all mental...as you would expect from a 32 year old...he isn't getting faster, hitting harder or any other physical attribute.

 

So even if the mental side of things continues to improve ...the physical side is heading south, in 3 years time he will be to slow to be effective.

 

I would love to have him traded at the TDL and then resigned in the off season for 2-3 years at 4M or less ...but giving him a 5-6 year deal now would make me cry....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Phat Fingers said:

Whaaaa?

 

Hutton has taken some good strides this year, but is not close to Edler IMO.  If anything, Hutton progress has helped lighten the load enough on Edler so he oant making mistakes.

 

Edler has had some ups and downs so far, but is a work horse.  He has been playing against top lines for 10 years and holds his own.  Ideally he would be our 2nd-3rd d man.  Hutton hasn't taken the mantle away from him and is nowhere near as good at the same age as Edler.  

 

IMO Hutton has been the guy we have vs the guy we want.  He has truly benefited from Trymakin's sulk and OJ injuries.  He is an okay second pairing guy.  He shouldn't cost alot and we need the depth.  Hughes will push him down shortly and if Hutton becomes our 5 d man then we are in a good spot.  

 

Also Hughes, Hutton and Edler are all LHD.  They shouldn't be partners.  IMO Hutton should play with Stetcher,  Hughes with Guddy and Edler with Tanev.  

 

Switch Stecher and Tanev depending on match ups.  Edler Tanev could be a good shur down and I think Hughes could carry Guddy and bring our Guddy's potential.  

Hutton is playing better than Edler did the last 3-4 years....

This year Edler has cleaned up a lot of his bad pinches that lead to goals against ...seemingly every 2nd giveaway....so Edler is playing better this year and while it might not be an aberration, he is still going to be 33 next year and even slower than this year.

 

Hutton has finally lost the goofy kid attitude and is now a man and is on the upswing ....

 

Just watch...!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 hours ago, rekker said:

Ummm. I hope your full of crap JB. If Hughes plays 11 games you will need to protect him leaving one less option for you at the expansion draft. I hope he said that for optics. 

I think that "being worried about it" and being stupid about it are two majorly different things. While JB should not waste any energy being worried he should be intelligent and practical and play Hughes only the max # of games while protecting him in the ED.

 

Edit: I see agent already said this.

  • Hydration 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
13 minutes ago, Rollieo Del Fuego said:

Hutton is playing better than Edler did the last 3-4 years....

This year Edler has cleaned up a lot of his bad pinches that lead to goals against ...seemingly every 2nd giveaway....so Edler is playing better this year and while it might not be an aberration, he is still going to be 33 next year and even slower than this year.

 

Hutton has finally lost the goofy kid attitude and is now a man and is on the upswing ....

 

Just watch...!

Edler has a much better body of work and is a vet in the locker room.  Hutton has turned it around this year, but nearly played himself off the roster after his last two stinker seasons.  

 

Edler carries the team at times, plays massive minutes and look.at our record without him.  Edler over Hutton all day long, but we dont have to make that choice, we can have both and Hughes and OJ on left side until Edler retires or Trymakin returns and Hutton is likely dealt.  

 

IMO Hutton is not as good as OJ and Hughes will be.  I also felt that Trymakin out played him when they were here together a few years ago.  

 

Hutton reminds me of Brent Sopel.  Good player, but replaceable.  

Edited by Phat Fingers
  • Hydration 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
25 minutes ago, Phat Fingers said:

Edler has a much better body of work and is a vet in the locker room.  Hutton has turned it around this year, but nearly played himself off the roster after his last two stinker seasons.  

 

Edler carries the team at times, plays massive minutes and look.at our record without him.  Edler over Hutton all day long, but we dont have to make that choice, we can have both and Hughes and OJ on left side until Edler retires or Trymakin returns and Hutton is likely dealt.  

 

IMO Hutton is not as good as OJ and Hughes will be.  I also felt that Trymakin out played him when they were here together a few years ago.  

 

Hutton reminds me of Brent Sopel.  Good player, but replaceable.  

Though he’s a leftie, Tryamkin spent most of his games at right D.  If he comes back, in my opinion, he makes a better partner for Hughes than anyone else on the Canucks.  Hutton has come a long way this year, and when we are playing teams that play with high pace and press us hard in our end, he and Stetcher become our two most effective D’s because of their mobility - and for the moment at least, that seems to be the trend of the NHL.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.