Jump to content
The Official Site of the Vancouver Canucks
Enter Search Term. Use arrows to navigate between autocomplete results. If no results appear, use Enter to do a full site search.
Forum Closure ×
Canucks Community
Forum Closure
  • entries
    79
  • comments
    263
  • views
    91,147

The Final Selection - My Team Canada Picks

Jason Chen

Entry posted by Jason Chen

707 views

 Share

As the date for Steve Yzerman to reveal his team fast approaches, and after a whole two months of countdowns, it is now time to reveal my picks. So without further ado, here it is:

GOALIES

Martin Brodeur

Roberto Luongo

Marc-Andre Fleury

DEFENSEMEN

Scott Niedermayer 'C' - Shea Weber

Chris Pronger 'A' - Dan Boyle

Duncan Keith - Brent Seabrook

Jay Bouwmeester

FORWARDS

Rick Nash - Sidney Crosby - Jarome Iginla 'A'

Patrick Marleau - Joe Thornton - Dany Heatley

Martin St. Louis - Ryan Getzlaf - Corey Perry

Jonathan Toews - Mike Richards - Mike Fisher

Brenden Morrow

And that's your 23.

There's no doubt about it - the league's best goaltender this year will be the starter and that's clearly Brodeur. Hanging up another gold medal along with breaking Terry Sawchuk's shutout record will be a year to remember. Luongo is the hometown favourite and will get the nod as the backup but Fleury has the big game experience. He was arguably Pittsburgh's MVP last year. The three goalies are heads and shoulders above any other Canadian goalie in the league.

The name that will draw the most amount of debate will be Washington's Mike Green. The league's leading scoring defenseman with 36 points in 37 games is an offensively talented player that deserves a spot on any team - just not this one. Big question marks were raised about Green's defensive play, and while it has improved by a significant margin this year, his key contribution - offense - is almost nullified by the presence of Niedermayer, Weber, Boyle, and Keith. While you can't replace or replicate Green's offense, his defense is still considered a liability. Mike Babcock noted that on defense Canada has the ultimate edge over all the countries so I think he'll be looking for players that can really play both ends of the ice rather than specialize in one area.

Two Flames, Dion Phaneuf and Robyn Regehr, have also been omitted because I don't feel either bring something indispensable to the table. Phaneuf is no doubt a talented player who loves the atmosphere and the big games but sometimes he gets a little carried away, resulting in dumb penalties that can really put his team in a hole. How well he responds to a loud Vancouver crowd is a big question mark. While Regehr has been a big-time shut-down player for the Flames, his offensive skill is limited and his skating ability is not in the same league as the top six, save maybe Pronger. Canada's ability to get up and down the ice quickly will be a deciding factor in the tournament.

TSN made a big deal about having three right-handed shots and three-left handed shots in the top six. While that will be taken into consideration, I doubt that is a major deal breaker. Babcock has only one right-handed regular on his Detroit squad (Brian Rafalski) and they seem to do just fine. It'll make things easier to have more right-handed shots but I don't think it's a necessity. Either way, I have followed the same pattern but I daresay even though I have Keith as the third pairing it would not surprise me if he ended up moving up.

Drew Doughty will be a favourite pick for those who want Canada's new batch of young stars to step in. At just 20 years old, he's the go-to guy for Terry Murray and the surging Kings. He logs big minutes and comparisons to Niedermayer aren't unfounded - he plays a more offensive style and uses his skating to cover a lot of ground. He's smart and poised with the puck. But there's just simply too many players to pick from and the pressure is going to be immense. I think the deciding factor will be that Doughty has only one full regular season under his belt and too little experience at the international level. The defending gold medalist Swedes went with experience, and so will Canada.

<img src="http://www.canada.com/entertainment/health+will+play+role+canada+final+roster/1936967/1936982.bin?size=620x400" class="imageFloatLeftFramed">The first two forward lines were easy to pick. Crosby plays with Bill Guerin and Chris Kunitz, two power forwards, so putting him between Nash and Iginla shouldn't be much of a problem. Canada's top line has enough hustle, skill, and strength to carry the team. This will be Crosby's first Olympics and what better way than to make his debut in his home country and as the tournament MVP?

The second line was also easy because I've decided to take the San Jose trio. A lot of pundits who picked the trio have split them up and I don't see the logic behind it. It's clear that Marleau thrives with his two usual linemates, why not just keep them together? The chemistry is already built-in. There's no sense in taking Marleau if you're not going to play him in an offensive role.

Getzlaf and Perry was another pair that was easy to pick, but what of the left winger? You could take a dark horse left winger like Mike Cammalleri or Dustin Penner, or even a lefty centre like Jordan Staal, Eric Staal, or Vincent Lecavalier. Since I don't think Cammalleri or Penner deserve spots, you can count them out. Lecavalier and Eric Staal are interesting choices because despite their disappointing seasons they're extremely talented players and maybe a selection to this team will rejuvenate their game. Jordan Staal will also be a popular pick but I don't think his offensive talents are suited for that line and he plays much better at centre than on the wing. If he is picked he'll be a fourth-line player, not a utility third line, which is why I went with the right-handed Martin St. Louis. The third highest scoring Canadian and a natural right winger will play the left side simply because he can. I think St. Louis is a very creative and smart player who is all heart. He's the engine that drives Tampa Bay.

The fourth line will generate the most debate. Mike Richards was always my pick for the fourth line centre job and there he will stay. He's had his up and downs this season but he is still a very good two-way player that brings an edge to the game. He has always done a magnificent job for Canada so I don't see why he can't do the job again in February. Toews was also an obvious pick but will have to play on the left side because of Richards' lack of versatility. Another centre, will be rewarded for his strong play this year and that's Mike Fisher. He's another capable two-way player that has really flourished under Cory Clouston and his confidence is at an all-time high. Either way, all three players can take face-offs and Babcock can use them as he pleases. Brenden Morrow takes the last spot and even though he hasn't done much in terms of putting the puck in the net, he's one of Canada's most rugged and tough forwards. If Canada needs a little spark on their team expect him to draw in. Morrow lined up on Richards' wing during the original Red-White scrimmage in August.

You can debate for hours on the exclusion of goal-scoring machine Jeff Carter and Canada vet Shane Doan, but I don't think either player has played well enough to warrant a spot. Don't write them off just yet though - injuries could happen between now and the start of the Games. Still keep your eyes on Lecavalier, the Staals, Patrice Bergeron, and Brad Richards as well.

 Share

3 Comments

Recommended Comments

The Kassassin Train

Just a quick thought for all those big game experts out there doubting Luongo's BIG Game mentality.

"Several months later, Luongo competed for Team Canada in the 2004 World Cup as Martin Brodeur's backup. He had another opportunity to step in for the starting goalie when Brodeur pulled himself out prior to the semi-final game against the Czech Republic due to a sprained wrist.[66] Filling in for Brodeur, Luongo made 37 of 40 stops in a 4–3 overtime victory[67] to put Team Canada into the finals against Finland where Brodeur returned and Team Canada captured the championship 3-2.[68]"

Link to comment
Jason Chen

I think a lot of the criticism on Luongo's "collapse" in big games has come from the game six drubbing from the Hawks. I don't think this particular criticism is unfounded, but keep in mind that Luongo had Canada playing in front of him. There's little doubt that Luongo will falter in the Olympics, but it's undeniable that he doesn't quite have the experience Brodeur or Fleury has, especially the last two years when the Pens reached the Finals twice.

Link to comment
Jason Chen

I was three off: Bouwmeester/Doughty, Staal/St. Louis, and Bergeron/Fisher.

I don't think Canada could've gone wrong with any of those six players. Doughty was my eighth pick right behind Bouwmeester and it did catch me a little off-guard how Yzerman went with a young star with zero playoff experience but I understand the logic behind it. Doughty is the future face of Canada's defense much like Ray Bourque, Scott Niedermayer, and Al MacInnis once were. Not a bad company.

Eric Staal's recent surge brought him back onto Canada's radar and it would be my bet that he was the player that was being deliberated into the wee hours of the morning. After posting just 9 points in 17 games the first two months, Staal has already 17 points in 12 December games. I believe the thinking is that Staal will continue his strong play into February because he's finally back on his game. A little curious about where he will play because I doubt it will be at centre ice. Staal wins a mediocre 41% of his face-offs.

Fisher was my pick as the utility forward but it is hard to fault Canada for going with Bergeron, who has had amazing chemistry with Crosby and performed well with the red and white. The Bruins forward has really came back stronger than ever since his concussion a couple years back. Along with Richards we will see a lot of him on the penalty kill.

Link to comment

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...