Honestly
And I've stated this being my opinion only.
I've been a Vees seasont icket holder forever, I watch the rockets maybe 20-30 games a year. I watched some amazing defensemen come from the Okanagan. Makar moves and plays the game like nobody else. When I saw the Doyle cup in Penticton here I was sitting with old Vees alum and almost to a person admitted that Makar moved better and faster than Keith but also still managed to make plays at a far mroe successful rate.
Now bear with me, I am NOT saying Makar IS Keith or will be a Keith, I am saying that Keith as a Vee vs Makar at the same age, there was a noticeable difference.
Fabbro last year, one of the top D in the draft, no comparison I'd take a risk on makar every time. My opinion only here again.
Makar does in fact have the highest boom/bust rate of the D men in the 1st round, but also possiby the highest floor.