His little sheriff ramble at the beginning of the game was definitely weird. His scum reads were not any better (maybe we should repay those a visit). I think he can be trying too to fit in. I'm pretty sure he's new to mafia too, so he can have absolutely no idea what's going on. I think we should take a look at the reads he's provided us earlier in this game.
Side note: ever since he became a PoE he's been awfully quiet.