You and James isn't so far apart... He talks primarerly of tha last 15 games with Loui on the line.
Then, he talks about Horvats line as a great match to the best of the other team because they aren't forced to play defensively.
When Beagle is on they are mostly in dzone.
Horvat, with Loui, is often in ozone, outscoring the best.
So you both can be right...