I've seen Zero Dark Thirty a few times now, probably 3. and it just gets worse with each viewing for me. I think I gave it like a 9 the first time, maybe a 7.5 the second time, then I'm probably at like a 6 now.
to me now it's just a very average telling of a very above average story, with nothing particularly unique about the film itself, and nothing is gained from repeat viewings
Argo is more or less the same for me. liked it at first, but then by the second viewing i just was like, OK, there is nothing really here.
2012 was a really poor year in film, IMO. in hindsight, Moonrise Kingdom may be my favourite of the year. I loved Life of Pi in theaters, but still haven't re-watched it.