It's cause schroeder is really undersized, while nylander and ehlers are giroux size. You're right in that we can't really predict what any of these players will become, but I just want to hit a home run over the safe pick. People say someone like ritchie is safe because if he busts he can be a 3rd liner, whereas nylander/ehlers would be out of the nhl.
Well who has the highest floor isn't appealing to me because you can acquire many third liners through trades and ufa. This team is full of 3rd liners and that's why we suck because we have 3rd liners playing with kesler on our 2nd line. Nylander/ehlers have the higher ceiling, but are higher risk, but if the risk pays off we can have a star on our hands, something I don't see with ritchie/virtanen. I'd rather roll the dice and get a star player over the safe player with size because this team really lacks offensive talent.