Me being a Coutier fan, I have to disagree a little with your assessment.
Cloutier was a phenomenal regular season goalie and set several records during his time, such as being the first Canuck goalie to record three consecutive 30 win seasons. And he did it at a time when the game could end in a tie, so no shootout wins to add to that total. While Markstrom has passed Cloutier in games played, he is still behind in wins. Cloutier is also still 3rd all-time in shutouts for the Canucks and 3rd in GAA.
If it wasn't for Cloutier's playoff record, I think he would already be on your list.
btw - In case you didn't guess, I would like to nominate Cloutier. Again.