Also nothing about "youth returned" is alignment indicative, for all we know is that when you steal powers, like you did to LL, like you probably did to NIK, J says something like you steal the youth of your target, your target has had his youth returned after you stole it for one round.
J23 would not under any circumstances give only townies verifiable quotes without informing the mafia of those quotes otherwise he created a game of angleshooting and it is literally in his rules no angleshooting.