-
Posts
20,719 -
Joined
-
Days Won
20
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Blogs
Gallery
Everything posted by Aladeen
-
Yup that is a definite knock against him and you may very well be right but again him wanting to be investigated by the sheriff could be an old style mafia thinking as that is how the town alliances were always formed back in the day. So yah it’s scummy to say that but it’s not necessarily definite that he would only say that as investigation immune maf.
-
Also I will say that MR literally said you and SS feud was v/v and since I have come to sus him since his medkit comment and “forgetting how they worked” I think he may actually know that’s the case as he likes to know things in mafia.
-
SS is a town lean because of his posts after you dropped the possibility of having investigated him. You getting an investigation was definitely a possibility at that point and he didn’t change up how was posting. It’s not concrete but I think if he was scum he would have reacted differently. You may be right on SS but I just don’t see the case against him as solid as against AV.
-
If by some miracle he is town, we would still gain some information because the SK would still be reluctant to vote his ass out. So best case scenario he is SK who initially gave up and then we just focus on mafia. Next best he is mafia and imo the most likely scenario. Still not bad as this will likely rule out a couple of townies from being maf. finally if he is town then I think some info as to who the SK is could be derived from the way he gets lynched.
-
Obviously if he is mafia the mafia aren’t on board with lynching him and the SK isn’t on board with lynching him as this takes out the “prime SK suspect” of the game. To me we get the most information lynching him. Who resists lynching of AV,?why would any townie resist his lynch? It’s not like he’s been helpful, literally only scum benefit from AV remaining in the game at this point.
-
As mafia he still has the plausible deniability of doing it for the lulz. The target from the SK is now off his back, obviously he would bank on the town not lynching him from believing he was SK which turns out to be a correct assumption. Not that big of a target obviously since I am literally the only one finding his claim along with his gameplay worthy of a lynch at this point.
-
That is literally what I just said.
-
That could be the case, but as I pointed out there is some advantages of doing that if he was mafia. Sus of being SK = not targeted by SK, at least not sus of being mafia, sheriff would probably pass on investigation, maybe get a read on who the SK actually is. I see no down side as mafia no upside as SK or town
-
Stated in a plain sentence that happened to be perfectly timed to roles being handed out at that.
-
Or it could be that it was legitimately trying to be helpful to the town especially for those like me that missed that. That allowed me at least to realize why fetch killed 3 that nightfall. Before that I thought fetch may have literally made a mistake that NF. My point is that you are using something benign to try to get others to sus out LHF as MR would put it and not that you are actually seeing this guy is scummy through any sort of logic.
-
If he was scum and nobody else noticed that wouldn’t he be more inclined to keep that little tif bit of information with his scum buddies? Why share it with the town if he is literally using that information in the hopes of an MK?
-
So what? Where do you get from NIK quoting “the SK is already active” to mean “as scum I want to eliminate him at night”
-
Wth does that even mean? His only real threat besides the town... if he is mafia the SK is literally the only other role in the game besides the town. You are saying things that mean nothing at all. If he is town his only real threat besides the mafia is the SK. That is exactly the same as your logic.
-
Never even brought it up but on the flip side keeping yourself unanon with the alibi of fantasy hockey reeks of scraping for town cred.
-
Explain to me why it’s scummy for NIK to point out that the SK was already active?
-
Beetlejuice beetlejuice AVjuice
-
AVs game since his WIFOM: i want to point out this post, could be that AV realized his mistake posting about getting randed as the timing was too perfect. It would be in his interest for the town to ignore angleshooting at this point. votes for NIK literally because NIK read the NF report. K I think this is true. this post is in reference to me obviously, at no point has he addressed my concerns or even acknowledged them or responded to me directly yet he drops it wouldn’t surprise him if this was a scum play? How? In what way? Why would it be advantageous for me as scum to go hard after one townie that’s not the sheriff? None of these questions are even considered by AV. Really did he try to promote discussion? He threw shade and a vote on NIK for literally reading the nightfall report as if that is something only scum would have done? How is that promoting discussion? AV has done zero game solving, has half assed thrown shade at players, deliberately ignored any and all points made against him, criticizes players making a case against him while any “case” he has made against players is completely devoid of merit in the slightest.
-
Town leans LL Ceres BJ SS Qwags - slight Scum leans AV Virt Otherwise MR falcon - slight neutral NIK
-
Ok since LL came out as sheriff this increases the odds of AV being scum quite substantially IMO. Since there was only 2 TS that got a PM vs 4 scum means just on numbers alone AV is 4x more likely to be scum than town. There is no doubt in my mind that he got a PM due to post NF dynamics. His play has not helped his case as I have yet to see anything townie he has posted. I could theoretically use the same logic for Virt as well, his interest in the game peaking post nightfall would suggest a role. If I was to guess what role each got I would say Virt is SK whereas AV is Maf.
-
I explained my reasoning on why SS isn’t someone I think we should lynch this round. That still holds true now. But If it came down to thunder dome between you and him at this point I would vote for him.
-
2 townleans is a far cry from townsolving
-
I think AV is more likely maf than SK
-
I know you weren’t asking me but my top 4 lynch candidates: 1. AV - timing of his wifom SK claim, riding your coattails egging on lynching of SS without actually taking the lead on it. No scumhunting, no game solving just limp questions trying to steer suspicion onto falcon without stating why he thinks he’s scum directly. 2. Virtanen87 - his inactive apathy to zealous post-nightfall back to inactive apathy seems to me like a player who is hiding cause he was exposed like a cockroach when the kitchen light comes on scurries back under the stove to the safety of the darkness and scum PM. 3. MR - has he done any sort of scumhunting? He has given town leans and that seems to me about it. I didn’t like the medkit post even if he had an excuse that it was early in the morning and he forgot how they worked. 4. Otherwise - bit of a angle shoot here to be honest. If I had have randed scum I don’t think my heart would have been in this game to carry on and I think this is what happened to kurisu.
-
Have to agree being SK is so rare 1/x players if the game even has one. It is my favourite role so I don’t see it as dire consequences, it would be more of a reward.
-
Yup falcon is on the radar but again it’s likely that he was LL’s investigation so I am willing to see where that goes and revisit him next round. So at this point I put falcon into more likely SK than mafia.