I don't like the idea of trading Hunter and the 6th for 1st..
If we make that trade and one of the top 5 slips, I'd say it isn't worth it.
Obviously we won't know which choice was better sure, either way, for a number of years... But in our situation I'd much rather have multiple prospects with high ceilings compared to one that might be considered more of a "sure thing". We just don't have any sort of depth with prospects. We need more, not less.
If this was the only move we made, and there wasn't a grander scheme to acquire more good prospects, I'd rather play it safe and go with quantity over projected quality.