I tend to agree with both of you a little. Watching Jake, I see a player who is both afraid of the opposing players and his coach. I assume he's getting mixed messages about being physical, but if he hits and causes an odd-man rush, he sits, so he has to overthink his physicality and his game. I also think he doesn't have a supporting cast of grinders/skill to support a heavy/cycle game to keep a cycle going, so a lot of his hits are 1 and done, and then the puck is out of the zone and heading for a scoring chance the other way. Overall, I think he wants to play a heavy game, but is so damn tentative/confused because of coaching, supporting cast, but most importantly the opposition's ability to turn nothing into something so fast with their speed, stick play and overall breaking down the Canuck's systems in all zones (offensive, defensive and neutral zones)