Jump to content
The Official Site of the Vancouver Canucks
Canucks Community

Master Radishes

Members
  • Posts

    7,979
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    6

Everything posted by Master Radishes

  1. I was always leaning far more towards him and that should have been clear. But I did genuinely type out a post voting for 112 before deleting it. I did struggle with voting out a hard claimed TP role, regardless of suspicions.
  2. Let's start with one. If we nail a third scum, we can go from there. I just meant that, for now, it's as good a scum pool as any. Doesn't mean we can't also discuss other suspects.
  3. I don't think we do - yet. We don't necessarily know what the mafia is thinking, and this player has been playing as TP up till now, and so there's zilch for us to go on. But by the end of this round we'll begin to see if anyone has changed behaviour or reads or anything.
  4. Ah ffs, I'm going to have re-read all 103 pages, aren't I? In the mean time, just going to throw this out there: hasn't 112 ended up in a he-said-she-said claim situation with both Aladeen and AV? Also interesting: Aladeen's reads list constantly had Stamkos as one of his few TP reads, yet never justified why.
  5. 5) Jazz - if he were mafia and Baka claimed Sheriff, he would surely share it with his scummates only. Why bother with the TP PM and all those shenanigans as well? Jazz isn't known for being a 'tricky' players either, as far as I recall of his past games. So I don't see this making sense. 1-4) Everyone else. Sorry. Actually, in the midst of doing this, I began to change my mind as I read over past posts. Now I need some rolls of tinfoil. Will continue later.
  6. Assertion: the mafia knew to kill Baka because at least one of them (BW, 112, MH, Jazz, Stamkos) was in the PM. Does anyone disagree with this? It's obviously possible they took a lucky shot or KP investigated him or something, but the simplest answer is that one of the five other players knew. And this is nearly 50% of remaining active players, so it stands to reason at least one is scum. Suggestion: everyone rank the five players in order of who you think is most likely to be the scum. A short justification would be appreciated as well. I'll do mine now.
  7. Regardless, discussing game mechanics isn't going to solve the game. Scum are still scum and will still be acting as such when posting.
  8. I just assumed it was a role from past games that I wasn't in.
  9. Just had a quick Google and can't find it elsewhere. FFS, did we just let zfetch set up a game without knowing what one of his roles does?
  10. What's the Ironman role? If it's been used before it was a game I didn't play in.
  11. Zfetch listed all possible roles in the OP. Also let's not forget his mid-round announcements. Short answer: Zfetch game. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
  12. And now I must get on with work. I'm sitting in the staff room doing this instead.
  13. I think we need to put off worrying about that. If a TP has become mafia we can't use past behaviour. We'll just need to pay attention from now as we discuss ongoing lynch candidates.
  14. MH, 112, BW, Stamkos all knew. And Jazz, but I can't see why he'd reveal if he were scum. Stamkos is the obvious candidate. But I don't think the other three are auto cleared. MH hasn't been confirmed as judge, and BW and 112 are both bold enough to bus a mate early and hard. A bit tinfoily at this point but still plausible. How many scum are we thinking - 5?
  15. Samesies. (Hey, I did call out AV early in round 2 even if I admittedly came very close to voting for 112 just based on precedent of not lynching hard claims.)
  16. Something about Baka's posting this round makes me think 'scum' as well. I may have missed it, but did Doubt Tea make much of an appearance this round?
  17. Were they the ones about me playing a wolf game this round? Yeah, I can see where that's coming from. I blame real life holding me back. We can discuss it after AV dies? Or after whatever crazy crap Zfetch has pulled does whatever it's doing.
  18. Yeah right. This isn't for you guys. As mentioned earlier in the thread, my school is getting a sudden inspection so I need to be in early and staying late to make sure my team is perfect. (I'm the head of my department.)
  19. I genuinely don't know how to vote. I'm not even convinced it's going to matter either.
×
×
  • Create New...