Jump to content
The Official Site of the Vancouver Canucks
Canucks Community

Master Radishes

Members
  • Posts

    7,979
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    6

Everything posted by Master Radishes

  1. Actually, if it's going to be all MH spam, I'm outta here now.
  2. And to be honest, my first thought when Zfetch posted his 'warning' was that the round has already ended. As BW mentioned, he's used that mechanics before (to hilarious results). So maybe it doesn't matter.
  3. Agh, I operate on multiple re-reads, and this game has been too active/I've been too busy to do that. According to all convention, we should lynch 112. AV has hard claimed. But everything else (i.e. behaviour this game, meta, and so on) makes me suspect AV far more. So I don't know what is the best course of action. But we can't leave both alive - one has to go to resolve this.
  4. They've already been revealed... It does, however, tell the mafia what the specials are doing tonight.
  5. Thinking about this using their meta (admittedly it's been awhile since we've all played): AV does not seem to be acting according to his TP meta. I don't remember him being so aggressive about his suspicions. He's not really trying to gamesolve other than this. 112 is more engaged than she has been in recent games, as I recall it. She's always active, but she's making bigger, more targeted posts, less spam, that sort of thing. Is that a good thing, or a sign of a particularly vested interest in this game, i.e. a role? I'm more inclined to accept 112's claim based on this - AV hasn't played like a TP so far.
  6. My initial impression was to give believing him a chance. He did spent about two pages accusing 112 of being SK before claiming, so it clearly wasn't completely random. And certainly, if he is telling the truth, I can see his logic in determining 112 was SK (as opposed to another role). It would be an odd choice for an SK to target Aladeen, but it's a choice I can see 112 making. It would have been nice to have left an earlier breadcrumb, but not everyone thinks to play that way so I don't think we can use that as hard proof against him.
  7. BW, I haven't missed your question. I'm just going to give it a thorough read-over first and my time here is still only sporadic.
  8. In a vacuum AV is more suspicious; in fact, there's little suspicion I'd pin on 112 based on her behaviour and reads and such. But one of them is lying, and AV has claimed a TP role.
  9. General rule of thumb: if two players are fundamentally opposed in their claims, we need to vote one out. Other general rule of thumb: if a player hard claims a TP-friendly role, we don't vote them out. Logically, I suppose 112 is the lynch. I'm not convinced of her guilt, but...
  10. I've been poked enough this game. And when Aladeen pokes, he pokes hard.
  11. It doesn't matter what you think about your own posting - to me, I don't often see a difference between TP112 and M112. Hence why I refused to categorise you at that point. And yeah, there wasn't much to go on, hence calling those two TP leans. Not sure why you're dragging this up. It's just an early game reads list.
  12. Quick thought: as suspicious as I myself have found AV, if he's hard claimed a role and we have no actual proof he's lying, then we can't in good conscious vote him out at this point. Unvote
  13. Hate to shout j'accuse! and run, but it's my bed time.
  14. Also, there was no mention of 'BW always doing it' being a reason AV didn't believe it.
  15. This was not long after BW's claim he caught my using PMs. A few people were already voting for me and I looked to be a clear-cut wagon at this point. My only defender. Does a real TP post this with such confidence? He made no attempt to follow up on it, either, just left it lying there for posterity's sake.
  16. There's like 7 people visibly online right now. Why so little chatter? And who will 112 catch using PMs next?
  17. Yes it is. I said as much at the beginning of the post.
×
×
  • Create New...