People complain that we should've gotten more for the goalies, like a draft pick. Does Mathias, Markstrom, Horvat, and a 2nd sound even to anyone? The fanbase will never like a trade unless we're the clear winners. Nothing else is acceptable.
I'm not arguing that the trades were fantastic. The saga dragged on way too long and that diminished everyone's value. Its the main reason Gillis was dismissed, it was a total mismanagement of assets. However, given the market at the time of the trades, it was the best that was possible.
Tallon had Gillis over a barrel in the Luongo trade, Florida was the only place he was going to go, and everyone knew it. Schneider had a few destinations possible, and the Jersey trade was the best one in the short term (out of division) and the long term (Horvat is going to be a stud and a fan favourite for a number of years).