Jump to content
The Official Site of the Vancouver Canucks
Canucks Community

Where's Wellwood

Members
  • Posts

    6,886
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    1

Everything posted by Where's Wellwood

  1. Assuming that gbassi was the doctor, then since MR wasn't saved that round, mafia kill comes first.
  2. Yeah but in a real town, if you're one of the bodies buried in the ground before the Mafia is found and killed, nobody would say you won against the Mafia.
  3. Also,can someone make a round by round voting summary for each of the remaining players?
  4. For the more experienced Mafia players out there, what's the convention for being a dead member of the winning faction? Like, if you were a TP and the TP won but you died already, is that considered a game you won, or did you lose because you died? Is winning along with the other members of your faction contingent on surviving till the end?
  5. The only problem is we never know if ??? is aligned with the TP or mafia.
  6. I don't even know anymore. At this point, BHB, Luciferase, and SS don't ring true to me. But then BM didn't either and he's not mafia. I also wouldn't be surprised if Kes or BDM is doing an excellent job at hiding.
  7. This seems like a vote for a TP trying to be disguised as a joke. Could be mafia. Trying to make yourself seem like TP by stating the obvious and what's already been stated? Or actually TP?
  8. Is the hit being looked at by Shanahan?
  9. I can't believe Edler made a good defensive play!

    1. Mainly Mattias
    2. Kryten

      Kryten

      Edler was behind his goalie instead of in front of him knocking guys and pucks away. I fail to see how that was a good defensive play.

    3. Where's Wellwood

      Where's Wellwood

      He directly prevented a goal. Everybody lauds Bieksa for his goal line save, but when Edler does it he was positionally bad? Okay, he was, but if he wasn't there, Minnesota scores.

  10. Anybody know what Dreger said about the Canucks recently?

    1. Mr.DirtyDangles

      Mr.DirtyDangles

      sounds alot like this

  11. I'm pretty sure these three are mafia Caboose Bo Hunter Booth Big Mike based on how they've posted in the game and in Caboose's case, circumstances of Aladeen saving him from a lynch. and 2 of these 4 are probably mafia Peaches One one two Silfverberg Snipes Luciferase vote Caboose because he's the one with the most concrete reason for suspecting him.
  12. I was under the impression that gbassi was the doctor and that's why MR wasn't saved.
  13. Whoops. I added Caboose to your quote because I thought you missed him. I guess caboose is Mafia twice.
  14. I'm just suggesting that it could be one way that you could be found visiting someone and still be Mafia without your target dying. Why?
  15. You could be the kingpin. It would allow you to investigate people, conviently every two rounds.
  16. My rational for the Caboose suspicion is in my post above.
  17. I agree that the best course of action is to go with what MR says. However, there is another possible scenario in play. Let's say that MR is mafia. Hypothetically, the Kingpin could have investigated VIC and found out his role. Obviously, the mafia would want him dead. So MR uses his amazing way with words and comes out as the 'Private Investigator' formulating a story that fits with the deaths and revelations so far. VIC has no choice but to come out as the Policeman but it looks like him just trying to save his ass. In this scenario, MR, OTTS, and BDM are probably mafia. On the other hand, if VIC is mafia and is just trying to save his ass then OTTS and MR are probably TP. BDM could still be on the fence. Caboose is probably mafia in both cases since Aladeen's 'Psycho Sheriff' result timing was just too good to save Caboose from an almost certain lynch. Aladeen wouldn't have needed claim GFY as his 'result' if Caboose was a TP since the mafia could have just let that lynch go through, and tricked us into lynching GFY (or any other TP) in a later round when a mafia was leading the lynch count. Aladeen is mafia either way. vote Aladeen
  18. and by 'that' I mean Aladeen's sheriff claim. Someone else posted an 'If KH is mafia and Dral is TP...' kind of thing earlier. Anyways, I'm terribly confused as to what went on post-nightfall, and it seems like regardless of my vote Aladeen will be lynched so I'll let that happen and see the results of that before deciding who to trust.
  19. I'm sure I read something like that earlier in the thread. Am I the only one who remembers something similar to that being posted?
  20. I'll probably be out the rest of the night. I'll try to check in but for now vote Caboose Going with my initial suspicion from just after nightfall.
  21. My vote change from you to Gumball was a bit of a knee jerk reaction to Gumball's 'error'. I think it'd be better to dwell on it some more first.
  22. Honestly, I don't know who to vote for between Gumball and Caboose. I find both suspicious. And there's always the VIC/OTTS angle to consider. unvote for now.
×
×
  • Create New...