Probably the best way to decide it TBH. Still, I'd let him play, he comes back at the end of each game to try to get in the next. I mean, if he really wanted to be an ass wouldn't he just post in the thread while the game was going and not give a crap? And bug people as well? I understand you want to be cautious Peaches cause this is your game, but I just don't see CPJ trying so hard to get in this game to mess it all up.