Forgot your password?
September 18
September 17
April 13
2.3k
See all updates by logic
Can't believe how much better Phaneuf was than Weber in 2005
Caboose
Phaneuf consistently produces 40+ points, is incredibly physical, is the captain of a team, and has an edge to his game.
Don't tell me you wouldn't want him.
Strawberries
i would want phaneuf but he is for sure not top ten
BM24
Anyone can captain the Leafs. But seriously, there is no one worthy of that captaincy anyways...and I don't see Phaneuf as a top 10 defensemen.