Jump to content
The Official Site of the Vancouver Canucks
Canucks Community

Beluga Whale

Members
  • Posts

    9,769
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    7

Everything posted by Beluga Whale

  1. I definitely don't discriminately try to read the best players early. I try to read anyone I can. And usually the best players are the toughest to read.
  2. Didn't know that Imagine pouting anytime someone says something even slightly negative about you.
  3. Yeah, he didn't have a great start. I would have a nice, proper, juicy lynch pool of: GEP Jazz WW Otherwise MR (oh why not) Stamkos
  4. Fair I guess. But I mean, I don't have much to work with other than circumstantial things like that. I'm glad other people are seeing what I see with that MR post. That post made me so suspicious despite not being able to fully articulate why.
  5. I concur with this assessment, and will also give MR a certified, nice, proper, juicy scum read. Still probably not lynching him tomorrow because I said I wouldn't. We should go for a low poster imo. Too many players are completely coasting and they need to be culled (sorry for harshness).
  6. Lol I wasn't thinking of the full value that role could offer to the town. Again, not a bad play. Just surprised you'd claim immediately without exploring all the possibilities.
  7. Did I? Maybe I was being nice. It's not necessarily a bad claim. But I kind of expected you to handle it differently (assuming you're town).
  8. I'm just slightly concerned because the PGO would be a brilliant role to fake claim as mafia for obvious reasons. And I can see 112 trying that type of play as wolf.
  9. I believe so. That's why I didn't think it optimal for 112 to claim (if she's legit).
  10. Tough to say. AV said this would be far from vanilla so anything's possible.
  11. It's a real role but not one I've ever seen in a game before. My personal opinion is that it's a pretty bad role because it can easily shift the game just based on a single night action, and because it makes the player nearly invincible.
  12. What did you think 112 was talking about if you didn't think it was a claim?
  13. Random thought regarding 112 and Zfetch: Assuming they are town, wouldn't it have been better to not claim and to instead try to bait the mafia kill? I realize there's risk involved in 112's case, but I think it would have been worth it considering how often she's the target of the MK. I only bring this up because the circumstances of those claims make me a little wary.
  14. I thought the difference between wolf-MR and town-MR was that wolf-MR was too perfect. i.e. he avoids mistakes and doesn't give people reasons to really suspect him.
  15. Pretty sure we aren't supposed to talk about things like that.
  16. Not really sure what you're suggesting. I haven't been signed in anonymously for a couple months now.
  17. No It was an open question about how they'd play if they were w/w. I'm not suggesting that's the case in this game.
×
×
  • Create New...