Jump to content
The Official Site of the Vancouver Canucks
Canucks Community

Beluga Whale

Members
  • Posts

    9,769
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    7

Everything posted by Beluga Whale

  1. GEP was way more involved in his last two games (as town).
  2. Tin-foil that I have to express: When I read this post I can't help but suspect that it comes from a wolf POV (with all the information). Idk, maybe this is me not understand town!MR's mindset, but I just find this to be a strange conclusion for an uninformed villager to make. Someone else give their thoughts on this, please.
  3. After reflecting, I do see that we've been a bit more distant than usual in our discussion. Especially 112 and I. Maybe things have changed. There have been recent games where I have trusted 112 and BJ when I shouldn't have, and it cost me.
  4. Is it just me or did 112 suddenly start posting a lot less after I called her out? @112 don't worry, I fully expect to receive your wrath for suggesting you'd be a timid wolf :p
  5. Yeah, re-reading certainly has tremendous value. That still remains my main method for me to narrow down the wolves after players have flipped. Also, I wouldn't say it's necessarily easier finding wolves in real-time. But I do find it easier to find the villagers. There are subtle things that villagers will do and say, (or more importantly, things that wolves won't do) that I can usually only pick up on when I see it happen in real time. But of course, these same things can be found retroactively in you're observant enough.
  6. I don't agree with this. I think most of us are tough to read as wolves, and we don't usually get cleared until later on. But saying there's at least 1 wolf in any group of 5 players isn't a stretch.
  7. Ok, I agree with that. I didn't make it clear but I was asking about why you didn't like my response to being asked why I wasn't anon.
  8. I think it looks townish, but it's possible he's a wolf giving an extra effort to seem like he has the role of a reg. TP.
  9. Where are these names even coming from? Idk, just seems crazy to me that you're theorizing the entire mafia team when we have almost no information. That's not how mafia works imo
  10. Ok no more help for you Pretty sure everyone willl testify that I'm always giving unsolicited advice to everyone, lol.
  11. Yeah I have a problem with check this thread incessantly whenever I have a moment
  12. I disagree. I want the wolves to be in the vulnerable position of having to choose how to affect the vote. That's one of our best bets of catching them imo. But I mean, trying to form a consensus now isn't necessarily a bad idea.
  13. It has an impact on me psychologically. Last game I was confident in my scum read on him and his mislynch ended up costing the town a lot. I'm averse to making the same mistake on a player like that when I'm apparently not great at reading him. Again, I'm just tlaking about round 1. In subsequent rounds I'll reevaluate.
  14. Slank-watch @Time Lorde @J-23 @Where's Wellwood @morrissex95 @otherwise
  15. Lucky seems genuine imo. I'm not lynching MR again in R1 after we messed up last game. Give him a round.
  16. Some useful info here for new players: https://cdcmafia.fandom.com/wiki/CDC_Mafia_Rulebook#comm-2331
  17. The vigilante is a role that one of the 18 players in the game has. They submit a kill (via PM) each night, hoping to hit a wolf (mafia). It should be noted that when we say NIGHT, we mean the end of the round. Which in this case is Sunday night.
  18. We have to assume the roles were completely random. But it would actually be easier for you and him to understand the game if you were mafia.
×
×
  • Create New...