I would have picked Price last November, but not now. The people managing teams know a lot more about this than I do though. We made the playoffs this year without Price and I am very happy we have such a strong starting rotation that all combined makes less than him. Thankfully Shapiro/Atkins knew not to spend that much on Price unlike AA.
I'm still optimistic about keeping them but if they both walk oh boy are things going to get ugly. Rogers told Shapiro in August to "spend what it takes to keep this team competitive" so lets just wait and see.