Jump to content
The Official Site of the Vancouver Canucks
Canucks Community

(Proposal) Van - Cbj - Edm

Recommended Posts

This is my idea for aquiring the top two picks:

To Edmonton: Rick Nash + Jack Johnson + Roberto Luongo + Yann Sauvé + 2012 1st (Van)

To Columbus: Kevin Bieksa + Keith Ballard + Taylor Hall + Manny Malhotra + 2012 2nd (Van) + Anton Rodin

To Vancouver: 2012 1st (Edm = 1st ovr) + 2012 1st (Cbj = 2nd ovr)

Edm signings: Brad Stuart, Alex Semin, Jarret Stoll, Matt Carle

Oilers 2012-13 line up:

Rick Nash - RNH - Jordan Eberle

Alex Semin - Sam Gagner - Ales Hemsky

Ryan Smyth - Jarret Stoll - Shawn Horcoff

Darcy Hordichuk - Eric Belanger - Ben Eager

Jack Johnson - Brad Stuart

Cam Barker - Matt Carle

Andy Sutton - Ladislav Smid

Roberto Luongo

Devan Dubnyk

Cbj signings: Tomas Vokoun, Travis Moen, Paul Gaustad, Michael Rosival

Cbj 2012-13 line up:

Taylor Hall - Ryan Johansen - RJ Umberger

Cam Atkinson - Derrick Brassard - Kristian Huselius

Travis Moen - Paul Gaustad - Mark Letestu

Derek Dorsett - Daryl Boyce - Jarred Boll

James Wisniewski - Kevin Bieksa

Keith Ballard - Fedor Tyutin

Marc Methot - John Moore

Tomas Vokoun

Steve Mason

Van signings: Zach Parise, Ryan Suter

Draft Nail Yakupov and Ryan Murray

Daniel Sedin - Henrik Sedin - Nail Yakupov

David Booth - Ryan Kesler - Zach Parise

Alex Burrows - Jordan Schroeder - Nicklas Jensen

Chris Higgins - Maxim Lapierre - Jannik Hansen

Alexander Edler - Ryan Suter

Dan Hamhuis - Ryan Murray

Chris Tanev - Kevin Connauton

Cory Schneider

Eddie Lack


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Taylor Hall has about the same value as the #2 pick.

So that means that Columbus trades Rick Nash and Jack Johnson (their two best assets) for Bieksa, Malhotra, Ballard, a second round pick and Rodin! They get absolutely destroyed! Hey Columbus, do you want two bad contracts and one decent defenseman...in exchange for your franchise!?!?!?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think the Oilers would prefer to just keep Hall and Yakupov. Rick Nash would be a downgrade on Hall while making an insane amount of money. Luongo's contract is too long and by the time the Oilers have a realistic shot at making a cup run, he will be in his mid-30's. The Canucks 1st round pick is almost a 2nd round pick.

Plus with these new big contracts plus those signings, the Oilers likely wouldn't be able to sign Eberle or RNH.

I do like the thought of picking up Johnson and Sauvé though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Create New...