Jump to content
The Official Site of the Vancouver Canucks
Canucks Community

[Proposal] Another Luongo Trade

Recommended Posts

First time starting a thread. Here's my proposal. I'm ready for the flaming...


To TOR: Luongo, Raymond

To VAN: Franson, Armstrong, Conditional pick


From what I've read on the Leafs' message board, Franson is not liked by Carlyle because of his work ethic. Being an RFA coming off a season where he has been benched for 25 games, I think a fair contract can be negotiated. The fact that he has a right-handed shot is a bonus. Also, from the Leafs' message board, it seems that most think Luongo's contract is too lengthy and the Canucks should take a salary dump. Despite being a bit expensive at $3M, Armstrong, the Leafs' salary dump, can be a good 3rd line grinder with playoff experience (with the Pens) when he's healthy and in the lineup. Furthermore, he only has one year left on his contract. The Canucks will part with Luongo, who will push the Leafs into a playoff spot, and Raymond, who is an RFA. This trade will give the Canucks some cap space to go after some free agents (Although I believe Luongo will go to Tampa).

To WPG: Ballard

To VAN: 2012 3rd round pick, Machacek


Credit to Steven Stamkos' Mullet for this trade suggestion. I think that Ballard, if given the minutes, will be able to thrive in Winnipeg. For those who watch the Giants several years ago, you know that Machacek is a two-way winger with some sandpaper. The Canucks don't have a lot of quality prospects, and this trade can address this issue. This trade will also give the Canucks cap space.


Schneider: $3.5M/year for 3 years (Not in the $4-5M range because he has yet to play a full season as the starter)

Franson: $1.5M/year for 2 years (Good value for a guy who can play 16 to 20 minutes of hockey)

Biron: $0.9M/year for 1 year (A safety net should Schneider falters; even though Lack should make for a decent backup, I feel that he should be allowed to play more)

Gragnani: $0.75M/year for 2 years (RFA resigning)



Daniel Sedin ($6.100M) / Henrik Sedin ($6.100M) / Alexandre Burrows ($2.000M)

David Booth ($4.250M) / Ryan Kesler ($5.000M) / ___________________ ($?)

Chris Higgins ($1.900M) / Maxim Lapierre ($1.000M) / Jannik Hansen ($1.350M)

Colby Armstrong ($3.000M) / Manny Malholtra ($2.500M) / Zack Kassian ($0.870M)


Dan Hamhuis ($4.500M) / Kevin Bieksa ($4.600M)

Alexander Edler ($3.250M) / ___________________ ($?)

Chris Tanev ($0.900M) / Cody Franson ($1.500M)

Marc-Andre Gragnani ($0.750M) / Andrew Alberts ($1.225M)


Cory Schneider ($3.500M)

Marty Biron ($0.900M)



Now, here are my questions:

1. Are the trades balanced and realistic and do they meet the needs of the teams (I have a feeling that a lot of people won't be happy with Armstrong joining the Canucks at $3M...)? If not, how would you change them? Are there any other trades you would make to improve the team?

2. Are the contract terms reasonable (Schneider and Franson in particular)?

3. With more than $9M left, who would you sign to fill the two spots and how much (Parise will probably be a popular choice, but that leaves about $2M for the defenseman. On defense, I'm looking at a right-handed shot like Wideman, but that might not be the best considering that he's a offensive defenseman.)?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I understand that Armstrong is probably more of a hindrance than a help with his cap hit, and, if possible, I would rather take a prospect or a pick instead since the point of the two trades is to open up cap space, which is a premium for a cap-spending team like Vancouver. This is especially true if they plan on chasing the big fish in free agency. The Luongo trade creates about $3.5M of cap space, and I guess that's worth something. I suppose acquiring Luke Schenn ($3.6M/year for 4 years) instead of Armstrong ($3M/year for 1 year) is more desirable. He has potential, and after a poor season, the Leafs is willing to part with him. Admittedly, I would much rather take a right-handed D in Schenn than Armstrong, but Schenn is worth more than Armstrong, and the question then becomes: Will the Canucks need to add to the deal, and if so, what?

From what I have gathered, the other teams on Luongo's list are Tampa Bay, Chicago, and New Jersey (with Florida being a long-shot due to finances). Chances are that Tampa will offer Lecavalier, which won't open up cap space for the Cancuks. I doubt Vancouver and Chicago will be able to work out a deal. New Jersey is tricky as well since we don't know whether Brodeur plans on retiring. As a result, I believe that, if we are looking for cap space, Toronto is our best bet.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We're getting majorly ripped off. Franson is another underachiever with potential like Raymond.

Armstrong is decent player but not even close to Lu in value.

The conditional pick better be a top ten overall if Lu shows up to training camp

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As a Jets fan I say no thank you.

It is not unfair but I like Machacek and don't want to trade the draft pick.

With Byfuglien, Enstrom, Bogosian, and Hainsey, as well as Stuart in ways being better alternatives than Ballard, I just don't see how he could be a fit in WInnipeg.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Create New...