Jump to content
The Official Site of the Vancouver Canucks
Canucks Community

Has The Power Balance Shifted To The East?


The Bookie

Recommended Posts

I found this to be an interesting read on Puck Daddy this morning. Thoughts? I'd agree that Vancouver has stepped down from being a clear-cut powerhouse to being more of a question mark contender. We're probably in the second tier of Western teams (w/ St Louis and San Jose) who will need to hope for some favourable bounces, injury luck and catching fire at the right time to go all the way. And of course, packing so many of the superpowers into one division isn't necessarily a good thing, as we've seen in past years where Western teams beat each other to a pulp in the early rounds of the playoffs and have nothing left to give in the finals.

Anyhow, the article:

Since time out of mind in the NHL (you know, dating back like two lockouts ago), the Western Conferencehas been appreciably stronger than the East. The teams that aren't clustered up and down the east coast of the continent long held sway in terms of overall quality, even if they had a general paucity of truly superstar players.

While Sid Crosby and Alex Ovechkin and Steven Stamkos were lighting up the league in most of the last several years, five of the last seven Stanley Cup winners came out of the West, as did seven of the last nine Presidents' Trophy winners. When looked at as a whole, the West consistently was producing No. 6, 7, and 8 seeds that would have been division winners in the East.

But now, it's time to ask if those days have come to an end. Yes, with the shift of the Red Wings to theEastern Conference, the West lost one of its giants, but more importantly it seems that the teams in the East which are truly good have finally and definitively passed their Western counterparts. While it's not necessarily fair to base such a seismic shift on results from last season, which featured no interconference games, there was an even split among top-10 teams in the league between the East and West.

Five apiece may not sound like a large amount, and indeed that's the same number as the two previous seasons, but with the Red Wings moving East and potentially pounding on the weaker siblings in its new division (getting Toronto, Florida and Tampa five times a year each all but guarantees the Wings another playoff appearance).

Moreover, though, the Canucks seem to be pretty much done as a true power in this league, as they were for the last several years, the Ducks look like they are going to regress hard, and adding the Jets to the Western picture helps no one but the actual good teams in their division — of which there are two — pad out their stats a little bit.

Interestingly, because of the imbalance in the number of teams in each conference, it seems very likely that people will be complaining about the number of crap teams from Conference III getting into the playoffs over those from the East that actually deserved to participate in the postseason. The odds that the third-place team behind the Blackhawks and Blues — maybe the Predators, maybe the Wild — have fewer points than the fourth-place team in either the PatrickPlus or Flortheast (or both, I suppose) seems extraordinarily high.

Based on what we saw last season, there's little reason to believe that Chicago won't be the best team in the league once again. They are superbly built and lost relatively little in terms of actual strong contributors this summer. They might miss Dave Bolland, they might miss Viktor Stalberg, but they won't miss either so much that they're not an early Cup favorite once again.

After that, though, you have to think that the real seat of power is in the PatrickPlus.

Pittsburgh is there, the Rangers look poised to stop playing disappointingly now that they have a new coachHenrik Lundqvist and some of their skillsier forwards does not actively hate, the Islanders seem to be on an upward trajectory even if their current goaltending situation remains at least a little unnerving, and you can't imagine that the Flyers do as poorly this time around as they did last season.

Columbus is a bit of a wild card, obviously, and I'm not sure they can replicate something like last season with their only major addition this offseason having been an injured Nathan Horton.

New Jersey could be truly awful, and I'm not sure how much I trust Washington to do well outside the Southeast, or Alex Ovechkin to replicate anything close to an MVP performance. I suspect the answer is "very little."

The Flortheast is pretty credible too, though. Boston can't really hope for much more mileage than they got last year, but that still gets them pretty far. The Senators have improved, the Red Wings have come in, the Canadiens are likely going to finish pretty high despite their best efforts to sign nothing but garbage this summer. The less said about Toronto, Buffalo and the Florida teams, the better obviously, but nonetheless that's four out of eight teams I'd rate as being at least good, and in some cases potentially great.

The West not so much. Chicago and Los Angeles are the only one's I'd consider strong enough on paper to be anything like a Cup favorite, with St. Louis and San Jose a ways back of them. After that, how good anyone is, in an entire 14-team conference, is very much open for interpretation. The Canucks' ability to succeed under a new coach, who's going to ask the Sedins to block shots, seems up in the air.

The remaining questions are far more pressing. Can Edmonton take a big enough step forward? Can Minnesota overcome a shaky goaltending situation and lack of forward depth? Can Nashville get anyone to score goals? Was last-year Mike Smith the Mike Smith we always thought he was going to be? Can Dallas or Colorado improve in any appreciable way? I'm not sure there's any good answer to those questions. Not any that those teams would really like to hear, at any rate.

It will be very interesting to see how the conference imbalance affects things going forward; it's going to be much easier to make the playoffs in the West than the East, and that's not going to change any time soon (barring an expansion team or two being added to the mix, just for fun).

Teams in the East also tend to be the ones that make a lot of money, and by and large they look like they're going to have a decent amount more cap space in the coming years when the ceiling reaches heights that begin to resemble those in some of Europe's grander cathedrals.

All of which doesn't exactly foreshadow good things for the future of the Western Conference and its collective Stanley Cup aspirations, but just like when they had to offload all their good players after the 2010 Final, the Blackhawks do seem to love a challenge.

http://sports.yahoo....-143606473.html

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There's more than a few points I question about this.

Columbus is not a question mark. They'll make the playoffs. The Islanders are more of a question mark. Jersey now has a solid goalie instead of two old men. Flyers have injured Giroux and such a questionable defence even with the addition of overpaid Streit.

To say Anaheim is trending down is kinda silly as they've two top shelf goalies a solid top 6 a gritty and mean bottom 6 and a large rugged d corp. LA is more of a question mark than a contender after losing a few guys who propelled their team in the playoffs.

To say the Rangers will be better based on losing Torts is a seriously sideways comment, and skillsier...really?

And the Wings, yes they should make the playoffs but now they're in a division where skating and mobility are a much bigger threat than the grind it out west, they'll be facing mirror images of themselves for sure.

Canucks who knows.

Not a bad read but questionable comments all the same

Link to comment
Share on other sites

honestly you don't necessarily have to be AMAZING to make the finals. Just hard work (a little luck might help, but mainly hard work).

I mean look at 2012. New Jersey hardly ever makes the playoffs nowadays, but the one time they did they went all the way to the finals. And the Coyotes made the conference finals. And an 8th seeder won it all.

Anything can happen. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 months later...

Here's an update on this thread about 15-18 games into the 2013-2014 season.

Clearly, the power in the league has NOT SHIFTED TO THE EAST despite Detroit moving to the east.

  1. 10 of the top 16 teams in the league are from the west
  2. Teams ranked #1-#6 in the league are all from the west. You would have to go to the 7th team (Tampa and Pittsburgh tied for 7) in the league overall before finding the #1 team(s) from east.
  3. All the teams ranked #9-#11 (LA, Nashville, Dallas) in the West conference would miss the playoffs if they started today despite all having better records than teams #7 and 8 in east (Montreal and NY Rangers)
  4. The Metropolitan Division in the East is so weak that the Rangers (#8 in East) with 16 pts would make it into the playoffs without even needing a wildcard spot, but would rank in #12 in the Western Conference.

Conference Standings as of 8 Nov 2013

Eastern Conference

Rank TEAM GP W L OTL
PTS

1 TAMPA BAY 15 11 4 0
22

2 PITTSBURGH 16 11 5 0
22

3 DETROIT 17 9 5 3
21

4 TORONTO 15 10 5 0
20

5 BOSTON 15 9 5 1
19

6 WASHINGTON 16 9 7 0
18

7 MONTRÉAL 17 8 8 1
17

8 NY RANGERS 16 8 8 0
16

9 OTTAWA 16 6 6 4
16

10 CAROLINA 16 6 7 3
15

11 NY ISLANDERS 16 6 7 3
15

12 NEW JERSEY 15 4 7 4
12

13 COLUMBUS 15 5 10 0
10

14 FLORIDA 16 3 9 4
10

15 PHILADELPHIA 15 4 10 1
9

16 BUFFALO 18 3 14 1
7

Western Conference

Rank TEAM GP W L OTL
PTS

1 ANAHEIM 17 13 3 1
27

2 COLORADO 14 12 2 0
24

3 PHOENIX 17 11 4 2
24

4 VANCOUVER 18 11 5 2
24

5 SAN JOSE 16 10 2 4
24

6 CHICAGO 16 10 2 4
24

7 ST. LOUIS 14 10 2 2
22

8 MINNESOTA 17 9 4 4
22

9 LOS ANGELES 16 10 6 0
20

10 NASHVILLE 15 8 5 2
18

11 DALLAS 16 8 6 2
18

12 CALGARY 16 6 8 2
14

13 WINNIPEG 17 6 9 2
14

14 EDMONTON 17 4 11 2
10
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Perhaps the balance of power has shifted to the East on paper.....but it sure seems like the balance of power is still in the West when the game is played on the ice.

Does anyone know what the records are between conferences so far this year. Last I heard the West had a better record by a wide margin.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That Metrosexual division ... man, it's astounding how bad it's been to start the season. The Rangers seem to be rounding into form, but I think that's the big one that's thrown the stats all out of whack. Consider what they said about it in the original article:

After that, though, you have to think that the real seat of power is in the PatrickPlus.

Pittsburgh is there, the Rangers look poised to stop playing disappointingly now that they have a new coachHenrik Lundqvist and some of their skillsier forwards does not actively hate, the Islanders seem to be on an upward trajectory even if their current goaltending situation remains at least a little unnerving, and you can't imagine that the Flyers do as poorly this time around as they did last season.

Just a little bit off..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Couldn't find any current records (as of Oct 18th it was 31-11-4), but it appears the only Western team that has a losing record against the East are the Oilers. All other Western conference teams have winning records in games against the East.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Lol, no offense but no way lol.

The Canucks are currently 7th in the west. If they were in the easy they'd be tied for 1st...top 7 teams are west teams right now...telling you east is a free for all style where anyone can roam around. West is structured more defensive and much more tougher hockey...west >>>>> east

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is one of those "what the hell are you talking about" articles. If I were to make a list of the top ten teams in the NHL, there would be three Eastern teams (Pittsburgh, Boston, Detroit). I mean, just look at the current standings. Los Angeles isn't even in the top 8. The West is crazy deep.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...