Jump to content
The Official Site of the Vancouver Canucks
Canucks Community

3 way trade proposal


Recommended Posts

Why does Edm lose? They dont need picks they need a team. they dont need Hemsky or Yakupov.

Hall RNH eberle

Perron gagne smyth

Edler Schultz

Del zotto Ference

You are correct but that doesn't take away the value of the picks. Edmonton is giving up a 23 year old on pace for 60 points and what looks like a potential top 3 draft pick and in return they get a #2 defenseman and a top 4 defenseman.. Basically Edler and Del Zotto isn't a lousy return but for what they are giving up they could easily get more.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You are correct but that doesn't take away the value of the picks. Edmonton is giving up a 23 year old on pace for 60 points and what looks like a potential top 3 draft pick and in return they get a #2 defenseman and a top 4 defenseman.. Basically Edler and Del Zotto isn't a lousy return but for what they are giving up they could easily get more.

Meh... Having that top 4 on D? How do they still suck like they are! They will get going and del zotto will feed the top 6 for days, while Edler is a veteran presence with a lot left. That is the type of top 4 and top 6 that take you somewhere, not a top 9 and top 2

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Meh... Having that top 4 on D? How do they still suck like they are! They will get going and del zotto will feed the top 6 for days, while Edler is a veteran presence with a lot left. That is the type of top 4 and top 6 that take you somewhere, not a top 9 and top 2

You are missing the point. Yes they do get better because they are the #30 offensive team but it does not make them a good team by any stretch and in return they are giving up their top offensive player who is only 23 and a top 3 pick. I mean what do you think the conversation rate is here?

Edler = top 3 pick

Vancouvers mid to last 1st = Eberle

You would have to be a huge homer to think that's what Edler and Vans 1st equal.

how does NYR lose? eberle is the best player in the trade

Maybe. But Callahan is extremely underrated on CDC. His point pace was only a hair below Eberle last year and his danger as a goal scorer is far above Eberle this season. In addition he is the heart and soul of the Rangers as well as a far superior leader and rounded player than Eberle is. Not to mention in addition to losing him they give up Del Zotto for a not so impressive spot in the 1st round. They drop defensively. Get a hit/miss long term plan pick. And they get an offensive player who is only slightly better than what they had. It;s 100% risk on the rangers part. No logical reason for them to accept that unless they are feeling desperate.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...