Jump to content
The Official Site of the Vancouver Canucks
Canucks Community

Should Bonino be traded


inkorea

Recommended Posts

His contract would allow us to get a slightly better player who's more expensive or get a player of similar ilk and a prospect or just a pick and a prospect for him.

I'm not against it, but at the same time, who do you prefer Richardson or Bonino? We can really only keep one can't we.

I would give Richardson 3 year 5 million or 1.75, 1.75, 1.5

Bones is younger with a similar cap, but would fetch more in a trade. Maybe at the draft or next deadline if we're not in it, but then we have to resign Richy as well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Minister, You mentioned Bonino's ideal cap(our situation).

Assuming we re-sign Matthias, Vey & possibly promote Gaunce, I don't see any impending crunch(sure wish capgeek didn't go extinct).

I'd suggest with all the emerging youth, we're better to parlay this benefit to a team in cap world, dire straits. Of course, for something else of equal benefit.

edit: ^Above..well put Derp-certainly agree.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

higgins for a late second

bonino markstrom 3rd for couturier

hansen for a early third

weber for a late 4th

richardson for a third

tanev for yakupov and a 3rd

stanton fir bag of pucks

draft a bunch of dmen with all these extra picks

sedin sedin burrows

vrbata couturier yaks

kassian horvat virtanen

kenins mattias dorsett

gaunce/mcmillan

hamhuis clendenning

edler corrado

sbisa bieska

miller

lack

young fiesty lineup with speed and grit the bottom two lines would be ultra fast and rough on teams

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In my opinion, Higgins is the one that will and needs to be traded. Bonino is much younger and more skilled and can continue to improve. Higgins' role is diminishing because his age won't allow him to play like he used to be able to.

Higgins was very effective because he could score 20 goals in a season and can move between second and third line, meaning he could provide some offence when needed but can also play the checking role and skate, and play the physical game.

Now, his play this season seems to indicate that he is not good enough to hold on to a regular second line spot. Although he still skates well, he does not play physical game anymore and does not throw hits and we have possibly better options at 3rd line LW position. That basically makes him expendable. Of course I'd like us to keep him for the playoffs but I don't see his spot on the team for the next season.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

higgins for a late second

bonino markstrom 3rd for couturier

hansen for a early third

weber for a late 4th

richardson for a third

tanev for yakupov and a 3rd

stanton fir bag of pucks

draft a bunch of dmen with all these extra picks

sedin sedin burrows

vrbata couturier yaks

kassian horvat virtanen

kenins mattias dorsett

gaunce/mcmillan

hamhuis clendenning

edler corrado

sbisa bieska

miller

lack

young fiesty lineup with speed and grit the bottom two lines would be ultra fast and rough on teams

You weren't completely idiotic until that point even if you did purge the roster.

No… I take it back...

That was all pretty dumb.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Minister, You mentioned Bonino's ideal cap(our situation).

Assuming we re-sign Matthias, Vey & possibly promote Gaunce, I don't see any impending crunch(sure wish capgeek didn't go extinct).

I'd suggest with all the emerging youth, we're better to parlay this benefit to a team in cap world, dire straits. Of course, for something else of equal benefit.

edit: ^Above..well put Derp-certainly agree.

Mainly because it allows us to add a piece in the offseason or at the deadline with a higher cap hit or commitment.

It's true we aren't in an immediate crunch…. and Bonino certainly helps with that… but other teams are. Maintaining good value contracts to offset veteran deals is how you overcome the cap structure. Bonino being signed for 2 more at that hit is incredible. It's legitimately one of the best contracts in the league if he plays to his potential…. some thing that is much more likely if we add a player to help him.

Wea rent rebuil;ding… we aren't tearing it down… we are transitioning. Bonino and that cap hit are a big part of the plan. There was a reason that JB made sure he was a focal point ion the deal. I can't be the only one that sees that, right?

If Bonino does get moved it will only be for a young, top end piece signed for multiple years. The likelihood is small.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Coastal,

I'll try not to summarize

your thoughts, nor misconstrue

The intent that you have posted with

Just try to see your view...

Bonino's ok, & has scored some key goals. But man, I'm afraid come spring our top 6 will get stomped on. Our bottom 6 will probably be killer, but is it enough?

i do not know

it is obvious to many who follow baseball

that what happens when a batter gets hotter

is that pitchers adjust

then the batter has to adjust

and so on

younger players often have trouble with these adjustments

but with experience they get better

the same applies to hockey players and hockey teams

the canucks played an up tempo more risky style to open up the season

very briefly they were in 1st place in the league

other teams adjusted to them and exposed weaknesses

and shut down younger players, bonino in particular

and he has not successfully adjusted

the league may have figured him out and he has nothing more to give

or he may need more time

the team as a whole seems to be adjusting more recently

and is playing a more effective style

bonino may need a bigger winger or two to thrive

if vrbata can return to the top line again

and burrow shifts to the 2nd line again and plays left wing again

and kassian sorts out his game

he could be the more weighty and skilled right winger the 2nd line needs

if bonino cannot adjust

horvat appears fairly close to making the jump to 2nd line duties

this is a transition year

next year likely will be as well

we will see which players can really step it up

and earn permanent spots on the squad

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Depends on the deal. Bonino seems to be a pretty mercurial C, pretty consistent on the PK but not much else. He didn't really get a chance to play much with Vrbata before the injury so who knows if all he was missing was a decent sniper.

The 1C role should be our biggest concern going forward. We don't have an offensive all star C in the system. If the Oilers win the McEichel sweepstakes, how much will they still need Draisaitl? Packaging Bonino with something to make this happen will not be the worst thing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Depends on the deal. Bonino seems to be a pretty mercurial C, pretty consistent on the PK but not much else. He didn't really get a chance to play much with Vrbata before the injury so who knows if all he was missing was a decent sniper.

The 1C role should be our biggest concern going forward. We don't have an offensive all star C in the system. If the Oilers win the McEichel sweepstakes, how much will they still need Draisaitl? Packaging Bonino with something to make this happen will not be the worst thing.

Those players aren't the easiest to find without tanking. Teams will almost never trade them. Our best chance is that one of our draft picks, whether it is McCann or someone else, develops a lot better than we expected, or we find a gem in the later rounds.

We may have to wait a few more years before we are terrible enough to pick high enough, unless we win the lottery sometimes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We have too many forwards and especially if we get Matthias and Dorsett re-signed.

I'd like to see Bonino and Higgins shipped out.

I think Matthias and Kassian can be made into a real good 2nd line if you added a little more skill in place of Dorsett like Jensen or Virtanen (next year)

Horvat looks like will be a real good 3C next year.

I don't think Matthias and Kassian can be made into a real good 2nd line by just adding Jensen or Virtanen next season. The potential is there, but that line may easily run into consistency problems as Kass and Matthias are not exactly the most consistent players and Jensen and Virtanen are rookies. I think Bonino-Vey-Vrbata has better potential to be the more reliable second line and Dorsett/Jensen/Virtanen-Matthias-Kassian to be a great third line body throwing line that we can deploy against LA, SJ, and ANA. Besides, I don't think Virtanen will make the team next year and even if he does, he will make it as a fourth line RW besides Horvat. Even then, I will be surprised (somewhat pleasantly) if Virtanen beats out Hansen for the 4RW position.

Horvat is already a 3C, but he will still play as a 4C position next season. A 4C that we can send out against Malkin and Crosby or anyone else in the NHL. Isn't that great!!

My best guess at next year's lineup, barring a trade would be:

Sedin-Sedin-Burrows

Bonino-Vey-Vrbata

Dorsett-Matthias-Kassian

Jensen-Horvat-Hansen

Kenins is the first callup. If Jensen doesn't make the team at some point next season, then it is very likely that like Grabner and Schroeder, his time on this team will come to an end. Jensen is a top 6 player but if he wants to make the team, he needs to be versatile and learn to adjust his role to play anywhere on the lineup much like Virtanen did for team Canada at WJHC and like Burrows when he first broke into the league. Failing to adjust will result in him losing a roster spot to younger, up and coming players.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Excelling in fall vs the spring is a different kettle of fish.

I like Bonino, but Vey is starting to hit his stride.

The cap-hit benefit is offset by the number of ELC C's we have emerging. Trade it to a team that REALLY needs the cap savings(eg:Tor, Mtl, etc...)

Of course this is dependent upon Matthias first re-signing. We've also got Richardson for depth, more proficient for bottom-6 FO's.

You don't make a trade based on a handful of games.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think the question should be if Mattias or Horvat can be a better second line center than Bonino. Put Mattias back into his natural position and he is a much better player. Bonino is a decent cap hit that can get us a B level prospect or a mid round draft pick.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i do not know

it is obvious to many who follow baseball

that what happens when a batter gets hotter

is that pitchers adjust

then the batter has to adjust

and so on

younger players often have trouble with these adjustments

but with experience they get better

the same applies to hockey players and hockey teams

the canucks played an up tempo more risky style to open up the season

very briefly they were in 1st place in the league

other teams adjusted to them and exposed weaknesses

and shut down younger players, bonino in particular

and he has not successfully adjusted

the league may have figured him out and he has nothing more to give

or he may need more time

the team as a whole seems to be adjusting more recently

and is playing a more effective style

bonino may need a bigger winger or two to thrive

if vrbata can return to the top line again

and burrow shifts to the 2nd line again and plays left wing again

and kassian sorts out his game

he could be the more weighty and skilled right winger the 2nd line needs

if bonino cannot adjust

horvat appears fairly close to making the jump to 2nd line duties

this is a transition year

next year likely will be as well

we will see which players can really step it up

and earn permanent spots on the squad

Why is it that every single time when I read your posts, it's like Im reading a poem. :P

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...