Jump to content
The Official Site of the Vancouver Canucks
Canucks Community

[Mafia] Game of Thrones (Game On)


Beluga Whale

Recommended Posts

16 hours ago, Beluga Whale said:

Round 1 Final Vote Count

 

 

Fwybwed (7)

 

Aladeen, Time Lord, King Heffy, Mau5trap, Dr.Strangelove, Kakanucks, Kazmanian Devil,

 

Falcon (3)

 

Jay Jay, Blue Jay, One one two,

 

Alain Vigneault (2)

 

Fwybwed, JohnLocke

 

Jay Jay (1)

 

Alain Vigneault

 

One one two (1)

 

falcon45ca

 

Kaz (1)

 

Zfetch

 

Not Voting (4)

 

g_bassi, Dral, Otherwise, thejazz97

 

At this time, this is how I am seeing things if we can determine Falcon is telling the truth. 

 

Mafia Read - Will readily lynch

Mafia Lean - Can be persuaded to lynch

50/50 - non lynch option for me because of probability of TP special  *unless new info comes up. 

 

Mau5trap - has been agreeable and hasn't stuck his neck out at all it would seem. He was quick to side with me on a number of points which always gets my attention. One thing I do as mafia is agree with those that are TP to get them on my side, it felt like he was doing that with me. 

 

Dr. Strangelove - His posting habits are much like they have been when he has been mafia in the past. As 112 pointed out his reads of the game felt off, no hard stance on who was likely scum. He flip flopped on his read on me from having me as possibility of scum to possibility of town. If Dr.S is town he needs to change up how he has played the last few games because the last few games he was mafia. 

 

Kakanucks - A few slip ups perhaps? Her posting seems oddly timed and sometimes a gut feel does work in the case of mafia. 

 

Va Jay Jay - Oh boy, voting for himself, experimenting with TP's lives, not voting for players when he thinks they are mafia because it would just be "throwing away his vote". Does anyone else find it odd that he was not willing to throw away his vote when he great reason to believe that fwybwed was mafia but happily does it to himself (knowing himself to be TP as is his claim)

 

Otherwise - No scum hunting, only comments of note are how we should never have voted someone because of getting caught in a PM. I have seen it work more often than not to find scum, especially when the person caught seemingly gives up like Fwybwed did. Although she hasn't posted much her posts have TMI feel to them, hinting at she knows what is being said in mafia chat and what their plans are and how they feel about what's going on in the thread. 

 

112 - I have been less certain of her in the past couple of pages than I felt before, but still she dismisses anything related to her saying that her mafia team mates convinced her to keep playing and not to delete her account. Well one part of that is true that her account isn't deleted, was the other part true or just a joke? I guess in her mind it's soooo obvious it doesn't dignify a response. 

 

BJ -  Has played well actually he hasn't missed a beat, no noob responses, claims to have played before IRL, but IRL mafia is very different than forum mafia, is he a dupe? is he coached? still up in the air IMO and dancing around answering the question doesn't give off very TP vibes, the mafia already have more info than us so don't hold anything back if you're actually playing for the town to win. If you are Horvat I think you should be proud you've changed your game and come out and let us know, if you are a truly a noob my scum lean turns to a scum read. 

 

AV - Much like mau5trap I feel that AV is too agreeable. He has contributed a lot more that mau5trap and is why I have him as a scum lean vs a full on read. He has been ever eager to follow on bandwagons which has contributed to most of why I feel he might be mafia. Always looking for a bandwagon to hop on to that TP proposes is good but sometimes it may just be a result of a lazy TP. Also Falcon did find a post there that shows that what AV posted was not the case.

  

Kaz, Jazz, Zfetch, Dral, JL, TL, Falcon - I have all these guys as blue because there is a fine line between being mafia and posting scummy and being TP special and posting scummy as to not be targeted by the mafia. I think all these players have the potential to be either some moreso than others but I don't want to expose any that I feel may actually be TP special. 

 

A lot of these reads do hinge on Falcon actually telling the truth if it turns out he is full of crap then I will have to readjust my reads. 

Link to comment

I just want to take a minute here to talk about SHROOP.

 

SHROOP is an acronym for Scott Howard's Rule Of Odd Posting. 

 

 I find it odd in of itself that player's here quote this like it actually has any meaning. I find it more odd that players who have never even played with the guy quote it. I actually have played mafia with him.

 

The rule basically suggests that Mafia are more likely to make posting errors over town players because there is a greater chance that they are going to revise their posts and make spelling or grammatical errors because of that. 

 

As I posted in Virt's failed game:

Shroop is asshat backwards, the reality is that TP are more likely to screw up a post than Mafia.

 

1) TP just write and post because they have nothing to hide. Therefore things like spelling mistakes and grammatical errors are going to be more frequent with TP than with mafia who read over their posts one or two times before posting.

 

2) I could see where a mafia would make mistakes in a post but generally it will be thoughts within a post taking a different direction. For example, lets say I am talking about the scumminess of someone I know is town, I write something that indicates how they are likely scum but in reality that is exactly what makes me scummy, I will try to alter it a bit and take a different angle as a conclusion, so as not to make the town take a closer look at me in that light.

Quote

So the flow of the post changing is more indicative of scum vs. the post containing spelling or grammatical errors IMO. 

This is Aladeen's Rule About Posting Effusion.

Link to comment
2 minutes ago, One one two said:

Do you have any thoughts on JL specifically?

Yes, and I hope I am wrong here because he is one of the people I think is TP special. He has played just like this before a TP special and I only answer this now because you asked specifically. 

Link to comment

Some of what BJ has posted in the last few hours has been very much deflection, IMO.  I have to check again but I'm fairly sure he didn't even respond to my 3 points.  Whether that's frustration or legitimately no answers or counterpoints, it's an enigma right now.

 

It would be fantastic for TimeLord to come out and play too.

 

hopefully Zfetch comes to this thread soon and can answer my questions from last night.

---

me being agreeable is weird.  I've only voted for the people I have suspicions of (BJ and JJ).  What Falcon quoted was a bit out of context.  I had him as scummy to start off this round.  A few of his responses prompted me to say that I could see him as TP.  Then 112 came and pointed out his assumption that last nights kill was an MK.  Then I said I could get on board with a possible lynch, implying this if the town go down that route.

Link to comment

Round 2 Vote Count

 

 

 

Jay Jay (4)

 

falcon45ca, Aladeen, Jay Jay, Alain Vigneault

 

One one two (2)

 

thejazz97, Blue Jay

 

Dr.Strangelove (1)

 

One one two

 

Not Voting (10)

 

Dral, Otherwise, Time Lord, King Heffy, Mau5trap, Dr.Strangelove, Kakanucks, Kazmanian Devil, JohnLocke, Zfetch

 

 

 

Alive (17):

 

1) Alain Vigneault

2) JohnLocke

3) Dr.Strangelove

4) Time Lord

5) Aladeen

7) 112

8) Kaz

9) Chris Otherwise

10) Mau5

11) Falcon

12) Kassian87 thejazz

13) Zfetch

14) JJ

15) Qwags Dral

16) Kakanucks

18) King Heffy

19) Blue Jay

 

Dead (2): Fwybwed, g_bassi

 

Link to comment

Alive (17):

 

1) Alain Vigneault - TP

2) JohnLocke - TP lean

3) Dr.Strangelove - Mafia

4) Time Lord - TP

5) Aladeen - TP

7) 112 - ?

8) Kaz - TP lean

9) Chris Otherwise - Mafia lean

10) Mau5 - ?

11) Falcon - Mafia

12) Kassian87 thejazz - Mafia lean

13) Zfetch - ?

14) JJ - TP

15) Qwags Dral - Mafia

16) Kakanucks - Mafia lean

18) King Heffy - ?

19) Blue Jay - TP

Link to comment
2 minutes ago, Time Lord said:

Alive (17):

 

1) Alain Vigneault - TP

2) JohnLocke - TP lean

3) Dr.Strangelove - Mafia

4) Time Lord - TP

5) Aladeen - TP

7) 112 - ?

8) Kaz - TP lean

9) Chris Otherwise - Mafia lean

10) Mau5 - ?

11) Falcon - Mafia

12) Kassian87 thejazz - Mafia lean

13) Zfetch - ?

14) JJ - TP

15) Qwags Dral - Mafia

16) Kakanucks - Mafia lean

18) King Heffy - ?

19) Blue Jay - TP

So are you saying that 3 of the Mafia team decided they wanted to get subbed out this game?  Elaborations on each player could probably help too.

Link to comment
47 minutes ago, Aladeen said:

 

Kaz, Jazz, Zfetch, Dral, JL, TL, Falcon - I have all these guys as blue because there is a fine line between being mafia and posting scummy and being TP special and posting scummy as to not be targeted by the mafia. I think all these players have the potential to be either some moreso than others but I don't want to expose any that I feel may actually be TP special. 

 

don't wanna call out TP special -> groups up people who might be TP special 

 

Claaaaaaasic Alabeen :P

Link to comment
1 minute ago, Aladeen said:

:blink:

28 minutes ago, Aladeen said:

Yes, and I hope I am wrong here because he is one of the people I think is TP special. He has played just like this before a TP special and I only answer this now because you asked specifically. 

why why would u say something like this

 

 

Link to comment
3 minutes ago, JohnLocke said:

don't wanna call out TP special -> groups up people who might be TP special 

 

Claaaaaaasic Alabeen :P

I think you missed what I was trying to say there. In many ways all those players in that group have played a scummy game a TP special could be playing like they are just to make it so that they won't stand out. It's not to say I think all those players are TP special just that that could account for why they are playing how they are.

Link to comment
2 minutes ago, JohnLocke said:

why why would u say something like this

 

 

Because I was asked what I thought about you. 

 

Just now, JohnLocke said:

is that better? 

Yes because that is what we agreed on when we first met that we would never go to sleep angry at each other :wub:

Link to comment

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...