Jump to content
The Official Site of the Vancouver Canucks
Canucks Community

[Mafia] Game of Thrones (Game On)


Beluga Whale

Recommended Posts

24 minutes ago, thejazz97 said:

After reading the thread more, this is the perfect way to sum up everything. IMO this is dangerous behaviour.

 

Vote JJ

Really, after reading the thread more, you determine that I'm the best bet for mafia.

Well, it certainly seems to have worked out that way for me!

 

 

Link to comment
10 minutes ago, thejazz97 said:

Guys, I've been out all day again, so I'm sorry if my analyses aren't up-to-par.

As a suggestion you should probably read the thread throughly and many more times then.

 

But its 50 or so pages so I see why you wouldn't want to.

Link to comment
1 hour ago, falcon45ca said:

Tell me this...why would TP JJ set up a play to false claim that FWY was in PM's, then when FWY doesn't deny but actually passively admits he was in PM, not vote for him? 

 

If JJ's TP and looking for scum, then FWY's reaction should have immediately confirmed him as scum to JJ...but no vote? That's a terrible TP strategy...he makes a play to catch scum & then doesn't vote for the guy? How do you buy that?

 

 

I answered that. Why I tried the play, why I waited, and why I didn't vote for fwy.

Why ask anyone else if you won't/don't believe my reasonable and accurate answer.

In particular, I was looking for a reaction from fwy to try and gauge his faction. He did admit to being in a pm, but does that mean he is scum. I wasn't sure and he never really answered that question. Am I the bad guy because I tried the play, or am I the bad guy because I didn't vote for him. Either way, fwy's lynch was a done deal. I agree that mafia will jump on a wagon, and they know that a tp is getting lynched. They get tp cred when they jump off, and the lynch is a done deal.

But no, only I find that suspect. I didn't vote for fwy, so I must be mafia. I could have jumped on that wagon earlier and then jumped off when fwy was a done deal.

What I have done may be terrible tp strategy, but I'm still tp.

Funny that the last time I knew that someone was mafia, and  didn't for for them, it was you as mafia that tried to use that against me when I was tp.

Of course, that just might be a coincidence.

Link to comment
59 minutes ago, JAY JAY said:

Not breaking, but taking a break.

I need to cool off before I'm driven bonkers.

I voted myself to show my frustration.

Does no one not see how the sharks smell blood and rally(both TP and Mafia)

 

Unvote

 

One of the most frustrating things I find with this game, or rather with the players, is how an answer to a question or query is deemed wrong or not what a tp would say/do. Well I'm tp and say/do those things. I have done them before in other games.

I don't like bandwagons and have said this before. I rarely vote on a bandwagon, and if I believe the bandwagon is on mafia or not and the lynch is going through, I turn my attention elsewhere. I did it this time and I've done it before. In fact, the last time I did that a mafia tried to use that against me.

 

I think, by far, this is one of the most difficult games we've had in which to discern mafia from tp.

I'm thankfull for the two day rounds.

 

Right now my only question is why Aladeen questioned me on my thought that a thunderdome between him and 112 was

any kind of concern. In my view, because of their vs interaction, it would be interesting.

Why would the thunderdome person listen to me over anyone else.

I'd fear, and still do, the Vig. I haven't called on the Vig to kill anyone. Don't kill me Vig, you are only going to kill a tp.

 

 

Omg are you serious? You propose thunderdoming me and 112 for shiggles? You don't even show how or why either of us might be Mafia. We both could very well be TP but don't let that stop your recommendation right? As long as JJ is entertained what does it matter if we lynch another TP? This is basically what you're saying. Please correct me if I have misinterpreted your post.

Link to comment
18 minutes ago, Aladeen said:

Omg are you serious? You propose thunderdoming me and 112 for shiggles? You don't even show how or why either of us might be Mafia. We both could very well be TP but don't let that stop your recommendation right? As long as JJ is entertained what does it matter if we lynch another TP? This is basically what you're saying. Please correct me if I have misinterpreted your post.

What is shiggles? Is that giggles or laughs?

 

Every thing else is just a load. You are putting words in my mouth.

I say something, you turn it into whatever you want. WTF is up with you Alad.

I could correct you, but you have already shown me that what I say doesn't matter.

Maybe you should just stop trying to interpret and just pay attention.

 

See ya all tomorrow.

Link to comment
17 hours ago, One one two said:

 

  Reveal hidden contents

8BIq5W7.png?1

 

Cracking meme

 

17 hours ago, One one two said:

At the insistence of my mafia teammates I will stay until either the game has been won or I have been killed.

I doubt this means anything but I'm including it because multiple people read in to it

 

16 hours ago, falcon45ca said:

Vig hit TP!

 

Who could've predicted that...

TMI

 

9 hours ago, otherwise said:

wow this game is like a mosh pit everyone is pushing and fighting and bumping into one another, people are  dancing and other people are getting hit in the face with flying limbs.  just total chaos. It's great.

 

and while I do enjoy chaos and can't help but think that much of this chaos is manufactured within the mafia PM and there are mafia fighting mafia as well as mafia getting TP riled up to fight other TP.

 

9 hours ago, Blue Jay 22 said:

Sounds like something a mafia person would say. Especially the highlighted points. Who advocates chaos and confusion? Shouldn't all mafia know who there fellow mafia members are anyway by now?

The chaos thing isn't really a valid point, but there is potential TMI in Otherwise's 2nd paragraph

 

9 hours ago, falcon45ca said:

I have my theory on it was the MK that didn't go through, and I've left some massive hints as to why I think the MK missed.

 

Just look at the optics...why would the Mafia target Bassi, who is more harm to himself & town than the Scum by a wide margin? I believe I know who they targeted & why it didn't work.

 

112 already let it slip...Mafia are scum hunting now, they want to know why their kill didn't go through.

 

Falcon is either making assumptions, giving himself away as special, or has TMI

 

9 hours ago, One one two said:

King Heffy was probably the scummiest person on that bandwagon btw

I agree with this

 

9 hours ago, mau5trap said:

I should have said something earlier to perhaps boost my credibility, but I felt wary of Falcon in the first round when he was going off on the behavior of other players. And he's acting super suspect this round. He knows way too much. Feels like you're poking around in areas you shouldn't be poking around in.  

Why would you need to boost your cred?

 

9 hours ago, One one two said:

Dr. S's list was too ambivalent. He's scummy.

This is true, and not something I really picked up on when I first read his list

 

9 hours ago, One one two said:

We shouldn't be letting Kaz/Z sail through the game like this.

I agree

 

9 hours ago, Blue Jay 22 said:

Not a huge fan of otherwise's game so far. He hasn't done any scum hunting for himself or the group, even though he has had plenty of time to do so. The following post is also still bothering me:

 

 

 

Otherwise is scummy yes

 

8 hours ago, Aladeen said:

But he didn't defend himself and you didn't vote for him, that should have been the smoking gun that you were right (at least that would have been a true TP's Rationale) 

Yes

 

8 hours ago, One one two said:

Jasper's bandwagon on me looked awful. I may be biased tho

It did

 

6 hours ago, King Heffy said:

So JJ pretends he caught fwyb in a PM and then doesn't even vote for him.  That's a sign he may have known he would come up TP.  Looks like the mafia were trying to take out a weaker player/easy target for a lynch.

 

6 hours ago, One one two said:

 

This is fluff of the scummy type.

Yep, has been slanking hard and adds nothing new to discussion with this post

 

6 hours ago, One one two said:

VK heffy.

RT

 

6 hours ago, Blue Jay 22 said:

 

Either you are the world's fastest reader, or a liar liar pants on fire.

 

Unvote

Vote 112

BJ transcends potato at this point

 

Strongly doubt there's anything to 112's WiFi claims

 

6 hours ago, Kakanucks said:

112

Blue Jay 22

mau5

Kaz

Kakanucks

JL

TL

JJ

KH

Dral (sub for Qwags)

AV

Falcon

Jazz (sub for Kassian87)

Dr. S

Zfetch

Aladeen

Otherwise (sub for Chris)

 

Dead: FwyB, g_bassi

 

I don't think I missed anyone.

 

 

6 hours ago, Kakanucks said:

@One one two You change your mind so quickly, its quite hard to follow sometimes.

 

Especially your votes, just IMO. A little bit all over the map.

 

Another quiet player saying innocuous things to appear active imo

 

Kaka is extremely scummy

 

5 hours ago, Aladeen said:

At this time, this is how I am seeing things if we can determine Falcon is telling the truth. 

 

Mafia Read - Will readily lynch

Mafia Lean - Can be persuaded to lynch

50/50 - non lynch option for me because of probability of TP special  *unless new info comes up. 

 

Mau5trap - has been agreeable and hasn't stuck his neck out at all it would seem. He was quick to side with me on a number of points which always gets my attention. One thing I do as mafia is agree with those that are TP to get them on my side, it felt like he was doing that with me. 

 

Dr. Strangelove - His posting habits are much like they have been when he has been mafia in the past. As 112 pointed out his reads of the game felt off, no hard stance on who was likely scum. He flip flopped on his read on me from having me as possibility of scum to possibility of town. If Dr.S is town he needs to change up how he has played the last few games because the last few games he was mafia. 

 

Kakanucks - A few slip ups perhaps? Her posting seems oddly timed and sometimes a gut feel does work in the case of mafia. 

 

Va Jay Jay - Oh boy, voting for himself, experimenting with TP's lives, not voting for players when he thinks they are mafia because it would just be "throwing away his vote". Does anyone else find it odd that he was not willing to throw away his vote when he great reason to believe that fwybwed was mafia but happily does it to himself (knowing himself to be TP as is his claim)

 

Otherwise - No scum hunting, only comments of note are how we should never have voted someone because of getting caught in a PM. I have seen it work more often than not to find scum, especially when the person caught seemingly gives up like Fwybwed did. Although she hasn't posted much her posts have TMI feel to them, hinting at she knows what is being said in mafia chat and what their plans are and how they feel about what's going on in the thread. 

 

112 - I have been less certain of her in the past couple of pages than I felt before, but still she dismisses anything related to her saying that her mafia team mates convinced her to keep playing and not to delete her account. Well one part of that is true that her account isn't deleted, was the other part true or just a joke? I guess in her mind it's soooo obvious it doesn't dignify a response. 

 

BJ -  Has played well actually he hasn't missed a beat, no noob responses, claims to have played before IRL, but IRL mafia is very different than forum mafia, is he a dupe? is he coached? still up in the air IMO and dancing around answering the question doesn't give off very TP vibes, the mafia already have more info than us so don't hold anything back if you're actually playing for the town to win. If you are Horvat I think you should be proud you've changed your game and come out and let us know, if you are a truly a noob my scum lean turns to a scum read. 

 

AV - Much like mau5trap I feel that AV is too agreeable. He has contributed a lot more that mau5trap and is why I have him as a scum lean vs a full on read. He has been ever eager to follow on bandwagons which has contributed to most of why I feel he might be mafia. Always looking for a bandwagon to hop on to that TP proposes is good but sometimes it may just be a result of a lazy TP. Also Falcon did find a post there that shows that what AV posted was not the case.

  

Kaz, Jazz, Zfetch, Dral, JL, TL, Falcon - I have all these guys as blue because there is a fine line between being mafia and posting scummy and being TP special and posting scummy as to not be targeted by the mafia. I think all these players have the potential to be either some moreso than others but I don't want to expose any that I feel may actually be TP special. 

 

A lot of these reads do hinge on Falcon actually telling the truth if it turns out he is full of crap then I will have to readjust my reads. 

JL is in green in the table (not shown due to CDC being WOAT), but blue in the summaries

 

Which did you mean?

 

3 hours ago, Time Lord said:

Falcon was posting exactly like mafia falcon earlier in the game with plenty of posts but nearly no content. He's changed since then, but keep in mind that it was only really after he was called out.

 

Also I don't like some of the votes he's made so far. Early on, he voted Chris for assuming that BW rigged the roles. Now he's voting for JJ because "lynch all liars" which I strongly disagree with and it was pretty obvious that it was part of JJ's plan. I don't see why JJ would do that as mafia.

 

Vote falcon

The points on Falcon make sense, but I don't think they make him a good lynch candidate yet

 

I could see Mafia trying what JJ did, given Fwybwed's history

 

2 hours ago, Aladeen said:

 

You follow Virt cause he investigated Chris with zero proof that he was what he claimed in the first round but now you vote for falcon who has soft claimed tp special? Doesn't make a lot of sense from my perspective TL pretty inconsistent to say the least. 

Yes

Link to comment

Unvote

 

Considering how bad BJ, JJ, and Falcon are (well, that may be harsh but idgaf) at this game, I wouldn't be surprised if they actually are all TP but let their obvious handicaps play into them looking scummy.  

 

I'll leave the three stooges to some other people to decide their fate.

Link to comment
27 minutes ago, Alain Vigneault said:

Unvote

 

Considering how bad BJ, JJ, and Falcon are (well, that may be harsh but idgaf) at this game, I wouldn't be surprised if they actually are all TP but let their obvious handicaps play into them looking scummy.  

 

I'll leave the three stooges to some other people to decide their fate.

I call Moe.

Link to comment

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...