Intoewsables Posted August 3, 2016 Share Posted August 3, 2016 2 hours ago, Aladeen said: You seem awfully sure Kryten was a Vanilla TP. We didn't get a result for what role Virt had in the nightfall why do you assume Kryten was Vanilla? I get why you think that's a TMI slip, but why would the mafia kill Kryten over a special if they knew he was regular TP? Link to comment
Time Lord Posted August 3, 2016 Share Posted August 3, 2016 6 minutes ago, Intoewsables said: If you look up "TWTBW" in the mafia dictionary, you'll find these two posts. How are they TWTBW? 6 minutes ago, Alain Vigneault said: Also, I feel TL reading JL as mafia is too convenient. How? Link to comment
Master Radishes Posted August 3, 2016 Share Posted August 3, 2016 7 minutes ago, Intoewsables said: If you look up "TWTBW" in the mafia dictionary, you'll find these two posts. He's confusing me. I think maybe that's his intention though? I dunno. Seems not like JL at all. Link to comment
Intoewsables Posted August 3, 2016 Share Posted August 3, 2016 Just now, Time Lord said: How are they TWTBW? They're insanely scummy posts to the point where I assume JL would think before doing that as scum? Is that not the definition of TWTBW? Link to comment
Master Radishes Posted August 3, 2016 Share Posted August 3, 2016 1 minute ago, Time Lord said: How are they TWTBW? Rule one of defending yourself when Mafia: don't counterattack your accuser. Definitely TWTBW...but JL is smarter than that, so maybe that's his defense strategy? Play dumb? Link to comment
Time Lord Posted August 3, 2016 Share Posted August 3, 2016 1 minute ago, Intoewsables said: They're insanely scummy posts to the point where I assume JL would think before doing that as scum? Is that not the definition of TWTBW? It is, but I was just wondering how you found them so insanely scummy. They looked fairly normal to me, maybe a bit on the scummy side. Link to comment
Intoewsables Posted August 3, 2016 Share Posted August 3, 2016 Just now, Time Lord said: It is, but I was just wondering how you found them so insanely scummy. They looked fairly normal to me, maybe a bit on the scummy side. I feel like tinfoil-y posts like "the mafia are out to get me! that's why [players] are voting for me! vote player" are almost always made by scum. Link to comment
Master Radishes Posted August 3, 2016 Share Posted August 3, 2016 I'm afraid I'm tunneling, but I feel JL calculated that response. It seems outside his usual TP range. I've played with him before as Mafia together...he calculates. Link to comment
Kazmanian Devil Posted August 3, 2016 Share Posted August 3, 2016 JL, Falcon, MH lynch pool imo Link to comment
AV. Posted August 3, 2016 Share Posted August 3, 2016 9 minutes ago, Time Lord said: How? @Time Lord 18 hours ago, Time Lord said: I highly doubt he's mafia so that's why I don't want to lynch. 3P seems like less of a threat especially because we've identified him and he can't kill. I'm thinking JL, but I'm open to suggestions. 18 hours ago, Time Lord said: I just looked at the player list. I don't think anyone is mafia. That's a first. 18 hours ago, Time Lord said: I don't know about JL actually. I get mixed vibes from his posts. http://forum.canucks.com/profile/92024-johnlocke/ They're all there if anyone wants to read them These posts from yesterday are my basis. I don't think I have them quoted in the correct order but you seemed, at best, 50/50 on JL and now he's mafia to you. Link to comment
ilduce39 Posted August 3, 2016 Share Posted August 3, 2016 Regime's Ruminations Hear ye, hear ye... MK -Kryten as an MK is an odd choice - while Falcon's suggestion of a veteran-led team having a "read" on Kryten made some degree sense, the Regime believes the opposite is more likely to be true. Like Aladeen said - it would probably take an investigation to motivate a first round kill. Further, with active MR, Toews and (albeit inactive) BW on the board it's an all-around odd choice. Result: Inconclusive. Voting Results The regime acknowledges Toews' assertion that the lack of activity at nightfall is because the Mafia were satisfied with the R1 lynch. Indeed, the mafia would gain more from lynching a 3P special in Virt than your humble Vanilla TP Duce. Virt- BW, JL, 112, BJ, KH, Dral Of the Virt lynch, which has the benefit of being a "pro-TP" lynch as well, JL and BJ would be highest on the Regime's suspicion list. BJ has been discussed in the thread and JL was illuminated by this post: 1 hour ago, Master Radishes said: No. The 'get a reaction' excuse may work for 112, but there's no way a TP looks at her Sheriff claim, thinks 'totes fake, but I'm going to pretend to go with it without any explanation!', and votes for Aladeen just to 'get a reaction'. Townspeople are far more suspicious of fake claims than Mafia are. If that was seriously your thought process, then it even goes as far as to imply you knew 112's affiliation if you were that trustworthy of a random roleclaim from a slanking player. If you had said 'I was really busy and wasn't paying attention' I would be more inclined to believe you were TP. But your explanation here says you knew exactly what you were doing. The regime also voted for Aladeen but honestly believed in his guilt. The post MR is referring to seems like someone trying to come up with a better reason to justify their vote. On MH The regime almost blocked MH in order to cut through his spam in the first round. While an MH lynch is not appropriate, perhaps a Vig kill would be as even if TP (of which it is not certain) spam is very much anti-town. Tin-Foil moment: AV is a player the Regime often mis-reads when TP. This game, he has flown completely under the Regime's radar. Definitely giving off a different vibe. Vote JL Danger Zone Falcon BJ MH (For reasons explained) 1 Link to comment
ilduce39 Posted August 3, 2016 Share Posted August 3, 2016 The regime also adds that, while it is now apparently the "lowest form of scum hunting" inactive players are likely suspects. Link to comment
JohnLocke Posted August 3, 2016 Share Posted August 3, 2016 Are you guys for real? Like really? Please read over my posts and THINK ABOUT why I'm playing the way I've played. Link to comment
Time Lord Posted August 3, 2016 Share Posted August 3, 2016 1 minute ago, Alain Vigneault said: @Time Lord These posts from yesterday are my basis. I don't think I have them quoted in the correct order but you seemed, at best, 50/50 on JL and now he's mafia to you. Switch the 2nd and 3rd post. JL was my top scum read but I wasn't confident, and my confidence in the read only decreased over time. But there was never any other person who I found more suspicious (until falcon recently), so today I came back to JL after MR made some points against him. Link to comment
Master Radishes Posted August 3, 2016 Share Posted August 3, 2016 Ugh. Are we about to get more roleclaims? I'm just going to go to bed. Zfetch's statement "This is not a vanilla game" is wreaking havoc on our ability to scumhunt. 1 Link to comment
Time Lord Posted August 3, 2016 Share Posted August 3, 2016 Just now, Time Lord said: Switch the 2nd and 3rd post. JL was my top scum read but I wasn't confident, and my confidence in the read only decreased over time. But there was never any other person who I found more suspicious (until falcon recently), so today I came back to JL after MR made some points against him. Edit - I don't find falcon more suspicious now, I meant to say that no one rivalled JL in terms of scumminess until falcon recently Link to comment
ilduce39 Posted August 3, 2016 Share Posted August 3, 2016 The regime would suggest one of: Jay Jay - posts have been very Jay Jay-esqe, but is he not usually more active? Scum reads very similar to the regime but non-committal. According to Zfetch, he tracked all the activity did not vote himself? g_bassi - slankmaster bassi is ever-dangerous as mafia. GFY - see g_bassi, only... more. for a potential Vig kill, barring additional input. Link to comment
Aladeen Posted August 3, 2016 Share Posted August 3, 2016 15 minutes ago, Master Radishes said: Ugh. Are we about to get more roleclaims? I'm just going to go to bed. Zfetch's statement "This is not a vanilla game" is wreaking havoc on our ability to scumhunt. I have a suspicion there are a lot of roles in this game. I still have an investigation and need to use it before the end of the round. Link to comment
Blue Jay 22 Posted August 3, 2016 Share Posted August 3, 2016 Apologies. Just wrapped up an 8 drive. I'll be able to post here and there when I'm in the cabin and not doing family things. Reading through now. Link to comment
Recommended Posts