JohnLocke Posted April 30, 2017 Share Posted April 30, 2017 2 minutes ago, ilduce39 said: The regime adjusts his tin foil hat and suggests: perhaps there was a misunderstanding in the mafia PM about nightfall? nice catch. you may be on to something Link to comment
Master Radishes Posted April 30, 2017 Share Posted April 30, 2017 Interesting, ilduce. Diesel has been careful to avoid providing much in the way of opinions so far, just excuses for his lack of contribution. Worth keeping an eye on. Link to comment
J-23 Posted April 30, 2017 Share Posted April 30, 2017 My Scum List: Roster 1. Alain Vigneault2. DarthMelvin (Mafia)3. Zfetch (TP)4. Beluga Whale (TP)5. diesel_36. Armbar7. Blue Jay 228. Stamkos (Mafia)9. J-23 10. Master Radishes11. Time Lord12. JAY JAY 13. DoughtysCheck 14. numb3r 16 15. JohnLocke 16. ilduce69 This is my updated scum list. I'm starting to think Armbar is TP, but still don't know. I've stated my reasons for TL, and AV being Mafia earlier. Link to comment
J-23 Posted April 30, 2017 Share Posted April 30, 2017 15 hours ago, J-23 said: Also, to add on if Stamkos is a Mafia, then I would suspect TL as being a Mafia. I think he realized that Stamkos was getting less heat due to the heat getting put on me. Therefore, he threw some more shots at me because he knew more of you would jump on the J-23 bandwagon (By the way jumping on bandwagons is my thing) because he is a well respected, and smart Mafia player. Also, TL was defending Stamkos. 15 hours ago, J-23 said: And to add on, TL said this about me, "His posts don't seem genuine, just like last game." The only thing I haven;t done different this game is "jumping on bandwagons", but don't worry I'm going to jump on one soon. . For those who missed it, my opinions on TL being Maifa. Link to comment
ilduce39 Posted April 30, 2017 Share Posted April 30, 2017 On 2017-04-29 at 1:17 PM, JAY JAY said: I've been up since 6:00 pm Friday, so I'm not here much longer. For the reasons I've said or felt. (if I'm not back before NF1) Vote Stamkos 13 hours ago, JAY JAY said: Made it back before 3:00 am. Looks like a done deal! Unvote; Everyone I forgot to do that, don't know if that was a valid vote. Vote Stamkos Unvote; Stamkos Unvote I still think Stamkos is scum but J-23, BJ, and DM are also. 13 hours ago, JAY JAY said: Vote Stamkos Why does it feel as though we lynched the wrong one? 12 hours ago, JAY JAY said: Unofficial Vote Count - Round One Stamkos ( 6 ) - MR, JL, AV, DM, BW, JJ J-23 ( 2 ) - BJ, Arm Zfetch ( 1 ) - Duce TL ( 1 ) - Z Something about JJ feels odd this game. I mean, odd for JJ. It's just so.... overt that he swooped in at the last second to fix his "everyone" vote and waffle a bit before hopping on a slam-dunk bandwagon. Link to comment
ilduce39 Posted April 30, 2017 Share Posted April 30, 2017 On 2017-04-29 at 1:29 PM, diesel_3 said: I agree Stammer has drawn a lot of attention in the early going, but maybe now he is riding a shtick? Sounds like he has been the same way since he started playing the game. Has he acted differently in games past when he was turned out to be TP than when he was Mafia? Something about JJ being TP and saying he comes clean about being TP comes off as genuine to me, mostly because I can relate to last game I was in the same position near the end. So, no red flags on him for me yet. I'll need some more cliffs/hot takes at least until Sunday night since I'm using a crappy phone with a shattered screen and it's such a pain in the dink to read absolutely everything, I'm not purposely trying to be quiet or shady. Will check back in a few hours for updates. 12 minutes ago, Master Radishes said: Interesting, ilduce. Diesel has been careful to avoid providing much in the way of opinions so far, just excuses for his lack of contribution. Worth keeping an eye on. Yeah the above post he really drags his feet on the Stamkos lynch. I've made similar posts trying to take some heat off a teammate. Enough for now. Vote diesel_3 Link to comment
J-23 Posted April 30, 2017 Share Posted April 30, 2017 Mr. Mussolini makes some good points. Link to comment
DoughtysCheck Posted April 30, 2017 Share Posted April 30, 2017 sorry i just have a lot on my plate right now and not really that active. but i'm tp Link to comment
JAY JAY Posted May 1, 2017 Share Posted May 1, 2017 54 minutes ago, ilduce39 said: Something about JJ feels odd this game. I mean, odd for JJ. It's just so.... overt that he swooped in at the last second to fix his "everyone" vote and waffle a bit before hopping on a slam-dunk bandwagon. Well, the first quote of mine that you have: "I've been up since 6:00 pm Friday, so I'm not here much longer. For the reasons I've said or felt. (if I'm not back before NF1)" Vote Stamkos *** What can I say, it is the way it was. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Second quote: "Made it back before 3:00 am. Looks like a done deal! Unvote; Everyone I forgot to do that, don't know if that was a valid vote. Vote Stamkos Unvote; Stamkos Unvote I still think Stamkos is scum but J-23, BJ, and DM are also." *** I woke up early. Didn't expect to. While doing the Vote Record I wondered if my vote for Stamkos might be invalid. So I made sure it was corrected. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Third quote: "Vote Stamkos Why does it feel as though we lynched the wrong one?" *** Placed my vote in a new post so as to not conflict with the other post. (all that bolded vote/Unvote stuff) Is this the waffling? I wondered if we missed a stronger mafia lynchee. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ You are barking up the wrong tree my friend. Link to comment
Time Lord Posted May 1, 2017 Share Posted May 1, 2017 The points against AV and diesel are good. Don't really have anything to add yet. Vote AV Link to comment
diesel_3 Posted May 1, 2017 Share Posted May 1, 2017 Whoa Whoa, My point about Stamkos was only a question about his playing style, In no way did I try and take heat from him or even bus him at all. I was as active as I could be while with the family in Victoria, I would say I was more active then a few and had a legit excuse. I have yet to even sit down and read what has happened just before 1st nightfall and after. Link to comment
JAY JAY Posted May 1, 2017 Share Posted May 1, 2017 Mafia Team Stamkos - Confirmed DM - Confirmed TL - TBC One of AV, BJ, or J-23. Link to comment
JAY JAY Posted May 1, 2017 Share Posted May 1, 2017 Voting Record - Round One --START-- Pg Vote Tallys 1 AV votes Arm (1)-Arm JL votes BW (1)-Arm, (1)-BW Z votes JL (1)-Arm, (1)-BW, (1)-JL 2 BW votes JL (1)-Arm, (1)-BW, (2)-JL JJ votes BW (1)-Arm, (2)-BW, (2)-JL JJ unvotes BW (1)-Arm, (1)-BW, (2)-JL 3 Arm votes JJ (1)-Arm, (1)-BW, (2)-JL, (1)-JJ 4 BJ votes JJ (1)-Arm, (1)-BW, (2)-JL, (2)-JJ 5 MR votes Stam (1)-Arm, (1)-BW, (2)-JL, (2)-JJ, (1)-Stam 6 JL unvotes BW (1)-Arm, (2)-JL, (2)-JJ, (1)-Stam JL votes Stam (1)-Arm, (2)-JL, (2)-JJ, (2)-Stam BJ unvotes JJ (1)-Arm, (2)-JL, (1)-JJ, (2)-Stam BJ votes Stam (1)-Arm, (2)-JL, (1)-JJ, (3)-Stam 7 Arm unvotes JJ (1)-Arm, (2)-JL, (3)-Stam Arm votes Stam (1)-Arm, (2)-JL, (4)-Stam 10 JJ votes Stam (1)-Arm, (2)-JL, (5)-Stam 5 votes on Stam. TL votes J23 (1)-Arm, (2)-JL, (5)-Stam, (1)-J23 Why doesn't TL vote Stam? Starts a J-23 Wagon. BW votes J23 (1)-Arm, (1)-JL, (5)-Stam, (2)-J23 11 BJ unvotes Stam (1)-Arm, (1)-JL, (4)-Stam, (2)-J23 BJ votes J23 (1)-Arm, (1)-JL, (4)-Stam, (3)-J23 4-3 Stam over J-23. Getting to be a close race. AV votes Stam (1)-JL, (5)-Stam, (3)-J23 Does AV have to make a decision on teammates? Arm unvotes Stam (1)-JL, (4)-Stam, (3)-J23 Arm votes J23 (1)-JL, (4)-Stam, (4)-J23 Arm gives us a tie. Next votes should tell us something! Z unvotes JL (4)-Stam, (4)-J23 Z votes AV (4)-Stam, (4)-J23, (1)-AV I think mafia tag Z as a Special. (voting scum) 12 TL unvotes J23 (4)-Stam, (3)-J23, (1)-AV TL breaks the tie and doesn't vote. Why? DM votes Stam (5)-Stam, (3)-J23, (1)-AV DM slams it shut! Mafia sacrificing Stam. BW unvotes J23 (5)-Stam, (2)-J23, (1)-AV BW votes Stam (6)-Stam, (2)-J23, (1)-AV 13 Duce votes Z (6)-Stam, (2)-J23, (1)-AV, (1)-Z Z unvotes AV (6)-Stam, (2)-J23, (1)-Z Z votes TL (6)-Stam, (2)-J23, (1)-Z, (1)-TL I think mafia tag Z as a Special again.(voting scum) JJ unvotes Stam (5)-Stam, (2)-J23, (1)-Z, (1)-TL JJ votes Stam (6)-Stam, (2)-J23, (1)-Z, (1)-TL --END-- Link to comment
AV. Posted May 1, 2017 Share Posted May 1, 2017 Tbh, I'm not even sure how I try and defend myself when I'm not really sure why I'm being voted for lol. Link to comment
J-23 Posted May 1, 2017 Share Posted May 1, 2017 @Alain Vigneault Why are you not Mafia? Link to comment
JAY JAY Posted May 1, 2017 Share Posted May 1, 2017 This is J-23's list from page 12. My Scum List: 1. Alain Vigneault Stated suspicions2. DarthMelvin I did wonder? Why is DM TP? He hasn't done anything. (flipped Mafia)3. Zfetch Not sure - seems a reasonable conclusion. (flipped TP)4. Beluga Whale It's the whale - hard to judge faction (flipped TP) 5. diesel_36. Armbar What were the conclusions?7. Blue Jay 22 8. Stamkos Was the Town fave. (flipped Mafia)9. J-23 What else of course 10. Master Radishes Another tough one to get a handle on11. Time Lord Stated suspicions12. JAY JAY ? is this based on others conclusions 13. DoughtysCheck Why is DC TP - mostly a no show - Why? 14. numb3r 16 Mostly a no show - no original thought except maybe on DM 15. JohnLocke Came after JL's claim 16. ilduce69 Again, why? What do you base this on? Mafia Suspicious Town Not sure Stamkos earlier posts make him look as if he is Mafia, and he has dipped ever since he has been accused of being one. Armbar looks like Mafia to me, he has been really quiet, the other game we played he was way more active, and he was a TP. Also, I think Armbar and AV were trying to bus a teammate in Stamkos. If Stamkos is Mafia then so is AV. AV is trying to act like Stamkos is Maifa (Jumping on the bandwagon) therefore it would like he isn't Mafia. He knows Stamkos is taking a lot of heat, and it's better now to bus a teammate. Wouldn't Armbar be Mafia also. You have him RED like AV. Link to comment
diesel_3 Posted May 1, 2017 Share Posted May 1, 2017 6 hours ago, Blue Jay 22 said: Do you have any thoughts to present so far? The vote misunderstanding is understandable, but the game had been going on for a little bit. @Armbar reason for the suspicion was because I thought you were disengaged with the J-23/Stamkos situation when it arose, though I did see that you added thoughts. No, I honestly haven't picked up on anything. Link to comment
JAY JAY Posted May 1, 2017 Share Posted May 1, 2017 Re: J-23's list from page 12. 15 players not including himself. J-23 tagged 5 players as TP - One who has since flipped scum. Tagged 3 as scum - One who has since flipped scum. Tagged 4 as suspicious - One who has since flipped TP. Tagged 3 as not sure - One who has since flipped TP. Why tag Zfetch, Diesel, and MR as Not Sure but find DM, DC, and Duce as TP? I don't have a problem with not having a read on someone, but you have a TP read on players who are virtual no-shows. J-23's list from page 15 My Scum List: Roster 1. Alain Vigneault Remained consistent with this one-still scum.5. diesel_3 Same read6. Armbar Dropped from scum to suspicious.7. Blue Jay 22 Same read9. J-23 10. Master Radishes Same read11. Time Lord From suspicious to scum.12. JAY JAY Same read 13. DoughtysCheck Same read 14. numb3r 16 Went from suspicious to not sure. 15. JohnLocke Same read 16. ilduce69 Same read This is my updated scum list. I'm starting to think Armbar is TP, but still don't know. I've stated my reasons for TL, and AV being Mafia earlier. Can you bring those reasons again to this round. Thanks. Link to comment
JAY JAY Posted May 1, 2017 Share Posted May 1, 2017 Second Round - King Pin gets his investigation - Stay alert! Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.