Mafia! The Dark Tower: Game Over - Town Win!

[naslund.is.king]

 

1 minute ago, Kurisu said:

Cheers naslund.is.king for accurately predicting every Mafia and bragging about it, then muffling a sheriff for no apparent reason.

 

@vig

@sk

When i go down as towns it just cements it for me

Did alot better then i ever expected

[thejazz97]

Just now, thejazz97 said:

 

I think we should also keep an eye on who otherwise voted for - MR. I'd have him as pretty towny right now, but she called out aladeen for no reason and got him. round 2 was the same with MR.

 

so is MR scum? is otherwise? 

to be fair, there's a fairly large chance that it was also just a lucky guess

[J-23]

vote bj

[Kurisu]

1 minute ago, thejazz97 said:

I'd casted my vote on him earlier, and I think I'm hoping for 100% on my OG list, but that's wishful thinking.

 

If naz is confirmed SK, I'd think that's probably our best option, no?

 

I think we should also keep an eye on who otherwise voted for - MR. I'd have him as pretty towny right now, but she called out aladeen for no reason and got him. round 2 was the same with MR.

 

so is MR scum? is otherwise? 

 

unvote, vote naz

Nobody is confirmed SK.

 

Sane said he's "between mafia and town" then said he was joking and that he's watcher, so he's going to let us know what he sees tonight.

 

Yeah otherwise could be Mafia.

[naslund.is.king]

2 minutes ago, thejazz97 said:

I'd casted my vote on him earlier, and I think I'm hoping for 100% on my OG list, but that's wishful thinking.

 

If naz is confirmed SK, I'd think that's probably our best option, no?

 

I think we should also keep an eye on who otherwise voted for - MR. I'd have him as pretty towny right now, but she called out aladeen for no reason and got him. round 2 was the same with MR.

 

so is MR scum? is otherwise? 

 

unvote, vote naz

The only thing about me that is SK is where i was born Moose jaw SK

It Hurts Jazz 

 

[thejazz97]

I'll also say this... I think if BJ flips mafia, AV's town. but if BJ flips town - do we know the vote switcher is a town role?

[thejazz97]

1 minute ago, Kurisu said:

Nobody is confirmed SK.

 

Sane said he's "between mafia and town" then said he was joking and that he's watcher, so he's going to let us know what he sees tonight.

 

Yeah otherwise could be Mafia.

my bad then

 

unvote

[AV.]

Yes, it is.  I'm the Town's Vote Forcer.

 

It means it forces somebody to vote the direction I choose, it doesn't switch.

 

 

[thejazz97]

Just now, Alain Vigneault said:

Yes, it is.  I'm the Town's Vote Forcer.

 

It means it forces somebody to vote the direction I choose, it doesn't switch.

 

 

yeah, but you're switching their vote to what you want

 

it's semantics lol

[luckylager]

Sane and Carlutch are interesting.

I'm holding onto to carlutch for the "no PM" intro post. I know everybody got a welcome PM from our host.

Sane's "not mafia not tp" claim was rank, which he later changed to a watcher claim which is clearly a tp role and this was after BJ had claimed follower, which imo are basically the same thing.

I understand we have a couple of sheriffs. 

But if we had a watcher and a follower, wouldn't one of them have to be slightly retarded like Sheriff J23?

[thejazz97]

Just now, luckylager said:

Sane and Carlutch are interesting.

I'm holding onto to carlutch for the "no PM" intro post. I know everybody got a welcome PM from our host.

Sane's "not mafia not tp" claim was rank, which he later changed to a watcher claim which is clearly a tp role and this was after BJ had claimed follower, which imo are basically the same thing.

I understand we have a couple of sheriffs. 

But if we had a watcher and a follower, wouldn't one of them have to be slightly retarded like Sheriff J23?

no, the follower role can be like tracker I'd think. and watcher and tracker have different functions. If someone hardclaims tracker though, we'd have a throwdown

[J-23]

[thejazz97]

@luckylager I'll agree with you on the no PM thing though

[Kurisu]

1 minute ago, luckylager said:

Sane and Carlutch are interesting.

I'm holding onto to carlutch for the "no PM" intro post. I know everybody got a welcome PM from our host.

Sane's "not mafia not tp" claim was rank, which he later changed to a watcher claim which is clearly a tp role and this was after BJ had claimed follower, which imo are basically the same thing.

I understand we have a couple of sheriffs. 

But if we had a watcher and a follower, wouldn't one of them have to be slightly retarded like Sheriff J23?

Nah. Watcher, follower, tracker all do something different. None of them are that powerful, but very useful with good prediction.

[Kurisu]

In a game where everyone has a role, I'm not surprised to see a watcher AND a follower.

[luckylager]

1 minute ago, thejazz97 said:

no, the follower role can be like tracker I'd think. and watcher and tracker have different functions. If someone hardclaims tracker though, we'd have a throwdown

But what's your take on sane claiming - not to not maf - then switching to watcher, which is clearly a tp role.

[thejazz97]

Just now, Kurisu said:

Nah. Watcher, follower, tracker all do something different. None of them are that powerful, but very useful with good prediction.

What's the difference between follower and tracker? I'm gonna go check OP, but still

[Kurisu]

I think we should hear out Sane. We know the extent of Naslund's role and he used it in an anti-town manner.

 

@Blue Jay 22 Have you planned a follow?

 

1 minute ago, thejazz97 said:

What's the difference between follower and tracker? I'm gonna go check OP, but still

[thejazz97]

Just now, luckylager said:

But what's your take on sane claiming - not to not maf - then switching to watcher, which is clearly a tp role.

not sure, tbh

 

he's new to mafia, did he slip up and backtrack? or did he just misunderstand his role because he's new?

[luckylager]

AV claimed to have the power to manipulate someone in his intro post.