I would rather have a bunch of tall highly skilled players.
People forget, you can list all the 5'10 or under guys you want but there is a difference between having one or two on your team compared to having tons.
Edmonton is going to have to trade a bunch of them because of this same issue and I would rather not go through the same thing. Right now the way our prospects are looking, we definitely need up and coming size. Like it or not, no matter how skilled these guys are, a bunch of them up and down our line up simply would not work.
Say something like this happened
Sedin Sedin Rodin
Schroeder Hodgson Grabner
As your top 6. Do you really think that would cut it? Top 4 defenseman would tear them apart. We need a few roid monkeys and if they don't bulk up or grow, we should trade one or two. I would be fine if they were like Burrows or Kesler gritty but they really don't seem like those type of players so they at least need some size to survive like the Sedins.