Yeah, 112 doesn't seem like mafia at all to me. At least based on the times I was mafia with her.
I agree that mau5trap would be a better candidate but I'm not 100% convinced on him yet. Still confident with my AT vote.
Peaches suspicion list
Gut feelings:
Kesler87
Beluga Whale
Malkin Cookies
Legit suspicions based on posting style and history:
Go Faulk Yourself
Alchemy Time
Captain Aerosex