Jump to content
The Official Site of the Vancouver Canucks
Canucks Community

Seannnp

Members
  • Posts

    595
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Seannnp

  1. 3 minutes ago, Sharpshooter said:

    Who makes you the arbiter of how Canucks supporters watch games? 
     

    It’s odd that you support the team but don’t support the teams’ ability to get the best draftee. 
     

    Do you want the Canucks to get the worst draft pick possible? 

    Everyone that is a fan of this team would like the best draft pick possible. However, the coaches and players of this team dont give a “mouses behind” for Bedard or a top 5 pick. They want to go out and win games. I’m happy when they lose and Im happy when they win. Lets just wait and see where the dust settles at the end. 
     

    everyone arguing about the best odds to draft at a certain position. The lottery could put

    you at 4th even as the worst team in the league and best chances to draft 1st. 
     

    Im still confident we end up with 5-6 in the draft. We are not bad enough to draft top 3 with the skill we have upfront. 

    • Like 1
    • Cheers 1
  2. This is a wait and see deal to see where the dominos fall. 
     

    Lots of people complaining but thats likely due to their lack of knowledge concerning this trade. So here are some points I want to make. 
     

    1. Currently the 1st pick sits at 13th based on odds which is the best position we couldve gotten. Trading to a contender and we surely get a worse position. 

     

    2. This was the best package offered - management as in every case takes the best package so its likely a defenseman worth trading for was not offered. 
     

    3. We likely are NOT done yet with rumors regarding Garland, Boeser, Miller, Schenn, and Myers. 
     

    4. Beuavillier was to make salary work but is a good player, under 26, only 4m on the books with 1 yr left after this and likely gets traded at this deadline or next. 
     

    5. Bo was a rental. We werent getting Newhook, Byram, and players of that ilk - at least not without an extension in place.

     

    6. Raty was a bonafide 1st rounder but had an underwhelming season in the SHL I believe which led to his stock dropping. Still has a high ceiling and a two-way 3rd line center floor but with top 6 potential. 
     

    7. Schenn and 1 of Boeser/Garland/Myers are almost certain to be moved for futures and prospects. I do not see Miller being moved with Horvat now gone. 
     

    8. Most importantly this improves our chances of improving our odds for 1st OA with the loss of Horvats production.

     

    9. If Islanders protection works out, we could potentially have a top 5 pick next year as I see Islanders regressing if Horvat doesnt resign which I dont believe he will. He will surely test free agency. 


     

     

  3. 4 hours ago, Bure_Pavel said:

    I disagree, I think Garland and Kuz are much better fits in a top 6 role and have better offensive skills + are younger. I think its fair to say Ilya is ahead of Podz, but that could change quite quickly if Podz takes the next step this season. 

     

    The best course or action would be to trade Garland and Miller hopefully getting a top 4 RD and 3C back + futures.

     

     

    Ideally, I wonder if Miller (extended) + for Weegar, Bennet, 3rd or 4th rounder would be something doable. Fills our top pairing right side, 3c and we get an additional pick. I would not be trading Garland now or in the future. 

    Sign Evan Rodrigues

    Trade Pearson, Dickinson for whatever closer to training camp.

     

    Not sure if this works cap wise, just an idea. 

     

     

    Garland Petey Boeser 

    Kuzmenko Horvat Mikhayev 

    Hoglander Bennet Podkolzin

    Rodrigues Lazar Lockwood

     

    Hughes Weegar 

    OEL Myers 

    Rathbone Schenn

     

    Demko 

     

     

     

     

     

    • Cheers 1
  4. 25 minutes ago, DefCon1 said:

    So would you say he can be as good as Pettersson?? He has been projected as a top 10 pick in many scouting reports and that is pretty impressive considering players like Jiricic, Nemec, Wright, Slaf, Minty etc. There is no home run consensus number 1 pick in this year's draft but I will say the top 10 are pretty close to each other. i don't see any big separation from the 1st overall to the 10th overall like I saw in previous draft years.

    Shouldve mentioned not my write up lol.


    I dont think he will be as good as Pettersson as i feel they are two different players. JL is more of a goal scorer whereas Petey is more of a playmaker with an ability to score 30-40 goals if that makes any sense. 
     

    i think this was a great pick. Hes 17 years old, played last season in the SHL against men and was quite productive - guessing his size wasnt much of an issue there. He’ll like grow to 6’1 or so and maybe 185-190lbs. 
     

    Some on here keep arguing about size but the game has evolved and high skilled players are dominating the league regardless of size, Petey is a great example of that, along with Debrincat. Anyone think Dach is hard to play against? We took BPA regardless of need which i will support every single time. 

  5. Out/Likely Out

    Eriksson

    Beagle 

    Roussell

    Virtanen

    Edler

    Sutter

     

    In

    Garland

    Dickinson

    OEL

     

    Players likely still to be traded

    Holtby

    Schmidt


    OEL will be much better now that he has a competent team and players he can pass to. OEL will return to form no doubt in my mind.

     

    Once we move Schmidt and Holtby we free another 10m in cap space. 
     

    We need to find a 3c/4c and a top 4 dman and our roster is set. 
     

    Miller Pettersson Boeser

    Garland Horvat Hoglander

    Pearson Dickinson Podkolzin

    Motte ??? Hymore 

     

    Hughes OEL

    Rathbone ???

    Juolevi Myers 

     

    Roster definitley looks improved in my opinion

    • Like 1
  6. This is what I WANT happening this offseason
     

    Trade Virtanen+ Lockwood for Domi 

    Trade Schmidt + 2nd Round pick + small add for Parayko

    Extend Parayko 7.5m x 7 years (sign and trade)

    Use our 9th OA to select Johnson/McTavish

    Trade Braden Holtby 

    Buy-Out Beagle

    Buy Out Roussel 

    Send Eriksson to the minors/retire 

    Resign Edler 3.0m/ 1 yr w/bonuses

    Resign Hamonic 3.5/ 2 yrs

    Sign Ryan Getzlaf 2-2.5m/ 1 yr w/bonuses

     

    Domi Pettersson Boeser

    Miller Horvat Hoglander 

    Pearson Getzlaf Podkolzin 

    Motte Dickonson Hymore 


    Hughes Parayko 

    Rathbone Hamonic 

    Juolevi Edler 

     

    Demko


    Who better to mentor Podkolzin and further develop Horvat than Getzlaf? In two years time Johnson/McTavish will be ready to take over 3c. 

  7. Trades

     

    To Van

    Reinhart 

     

    To Buff

    Schmidt

    DiPietro 

    Lind

    2nd Round Pick 2022

    3rd Round Pick 2022 (MIN)

     

     

     

    To Van

    Jordan Greenway 

    3rd Round Pick 2022 

     

    To Min

    9th OA 2021

    Eriksson 25% Retained 

     

     

     

    Sign

    Adam Larsson 4.75 x 4-5

    Edler 3.25 x 1 

    Sutter 2.5 x 2 

    Hamonic 2 x 2 

     

    Buyout

    Roussell

    Virtanen

     

    Expansion Draft

    Myers 

     

     

     

    Greenway Pettersson Boeser

    Reinhart Horvat Hoglander

    Pearson Miller Podkolzin

    Highmore Sutter Motte 

     

    Hughes Larsson

    Edler Rathbone 

    Juolevi Hamonic 


     

    The Canucks are looking for a 3c. Why not move Miller to 3c and look for a top 6 forward - Reinhart fits the bill and we finally have a winger for Horvat. Buff gets a d partner for Dahlin, a potential goalie for the future, a top 9 prospect in Lind and 2 draft picks to begin what i hope is the last rebuild for them. 
     

    Greenway likely gets lost in the expansion draft if he stays in Minnesota. I love what Greenway brings to the table. We give up the 9th OA for a top 6 winger and lose the Eriksson contract. Win-Win for all involved??

     

    I think Larsson would be the perfect d partner for Hughes and if we could get him for under 5, we absolutley need to explore this option. Im not 100% sold on Hamonic but not sure what other options are out there. 
     

    Normally Id try to clarify further but its 3am and i just cant be bothered to do so. 

    • Cheers 1
  8. Why not Trade 

     

    Miller, Schmidt, 1st in 2021, Woo

    for 

    Seth Jones, Boone Jenner

     

    We get our 3c and 1d 

     

    Sign Nugent Hopkins 6m x 5

    Resign Edler  3m x 1 

    Resign Hamonic 2m x 2 

     

    Myers to Seattle in ED

    Roussell BUYOUT

    Erkisson (Retire hopefully) 

     

    Podkolzin Pettersson Boeser

    Nugent-Hopkins Horvat Hoglander

    Pearson Jenner Motte

    Highmore Beagle Lockwood

     

    Hughes Jones 

    Edler Rathbone 

    Juolevi Hamonic 

     

  9. On ‎10‎/‎22‎/‎2020 at 10:18 AM, Provost said:

    $2.55 million is a low enough number to maybe make him tradeable.

     

    If there is still an opportunity to use him to shed cap, I still do that.

     

    I don’t think he is good enough for our top line and he isn’t a fit on the Horvat line which will have lots of defensive responsibilities.

     

    We have other, cheaper options for the 3rd line.

    Cheaper options for 3rd line? Less than 2.55m? Other than Gaudette, who?

  10. On 9/26/2020 at 10:04 AM, Moose Nuckle said:

    That's not the point, the point is to have fun speculating and creating interesting trade scenarios. 

     

    Also trading Boeser and Eriksson for Bertuzzi is nothing like trading Eriksson and a 1st round pick to shed him. 

    Agreed. It’s actually much worse. Boeser is what most teams want thier 1st round picks to turn into. 

  11. 1 hour ago, IjustNEEDaTROYgamble said:

    you are crazy and should never include Demko in this trade as this is giving him away and not understanding that Vancouver has Arizona over a barrel and are negotiating against yourself.

    Some have him included as a sweetener to dump Eriksson. I would love to keep both him and Markstrom but we can only protect 1. After the Schneider for a top 10 pick and how it has played out, Demko likely only fetches a 2nd rounder. I don’t think we can land OEL without a top prospect (at least I think he’s still a prospect) like Demko. Smaller pieces and bad contracts aren’t going to get it done. Have to give to get to improve this team and OEL vastly improves this team on the backend. 

     

    Arizona doesn’t have to trade OEL. I also haven’t read that he has demanded a trade. The only leverage we have is that Vancouver is one of two destinations he is willing to go to. 

  12. OEL

     

    for 

     

    Sutter

    Virtanen

    Juolevi or Rathbone or Woo

    Demko 

    Eriksson 

     

    Kuemper may be on the move and this could help push them to make the deal and she’s his salary. Demko can be thier future starter. Virtanen likely slots into thier 2nd line whilst Sutter takes over 3rd line Center duties which they seem to have a need for. Juolevi or Rathbone potentially gives them a top 4 damn.  Eriksson gets them to the cap floor without having to pay real dollars which seems to the the real reason they are trying to move OEL out. 

     

    We could then sign Markstrom, Toffoli and Tanev. 

    • Haha 1
  13. On ‎9‎/‎8‎/‎2020 at 1:41 PM, BigTramFan said:

    I think you have misread and perhaps thinking my detailed roster was for next season? But it's for 2021-22.

     

    The roster for 2021-22 (which is TWO off seasons from now) should not include the following guys because their current contracts will have ended and IMO JB should not resign them: Edler, Stecher, Fantenberg, Benn, Sutter, Baertschi. There are some tough decisions to be made about Markstrom and Tanev.

     

    I haven't "gutted" the defense, it is just that our D corps is aging out and it is time for a revamp. We need to get younger, bigger, tougher and better puck movers in our D corps. I think that Pesce, Cernak, Tryamkin would be excellent targets to get younger and tougher (these guys would replace Edler and Tanev). We also need the likes of Juolevi, Rathbone, Rafferty to come in and improve our zone clearances and offense from the back end.

     

    Regarding Hoglander and Podkolzin. I expect both players to make the roster in 2021-22. I think it is clear that JB will need to rely on these younger guys coming through and replacing the Sutters of the team, so that our roster stays young and we can afford to pay for our core players like Pettersson and Hughes.

     

    One final note...I am not actually suggesting that JB should target Hall this off season. I believe the money should be spent on improving our back end, as we have some excellent forward talent coming through our farm system that will provide the boost our offence that we need to become a contender.

     

    What I hope the Canucks Roster will look like in 2022-2023 (The year we win the CUP)

     

    Hoglander Pettersson Boeser

    Miller Horvat Podkolzin

    Toffoli Gaudette Anderson (CLB)

    Motte Haula MacEwan

    Lind

     

    Hughes Pietrangelo

    Juolevi Myers

    Rathbone Rafferty

    Woo

     

    Demko

    DiPietro

  14. Re-Sign Markstrom 4 years 22million prior to the draft

    Re-Sign Virtanen to 1 year 2.5million show me contract

    Re-Sign Leivo 3 year/6.6million

     

    Trade Demko and additional piece for 1st round pick (20-30OA) at the draft

    Mutual termination of Louis Eriksson's contract after bonus is paid.

    Trade Stetcher, Goldobin, Baertschi, Sutter, to whoever for whatever preferably 1 for 1 role players and/or picks

    Let Tanev walk (could trade Tanev for Barrie at the deadline)

     

    Sign JG Pageau 4 years/16million

    Sign Thomas Greiss 2 years/4.5 million

    Sign Barrie 6 years/45million

    Sign depth defenseman

     

    I firmly believe that Hoglander lands a spot on the big club right out of training camp.

     

    Miller Pettersson Virtanen

    Pearson Horvat Boeser

    Hoglander Pageau Gaudette 

    Roussel Beagle Leivo

     

    Edler Barrie

    Hughes Myers

    Juolevi Rafferty/Trymakin

    Benn

    Faantenberg 

     

    Markstrom

    Greiss

    DiPietro

     

     

     

    • Like 1
  15. 19 hours ago, IjustNEEDaTROYgamble said:

    Go after Manson or Lindholm for Stetcher, Gaudette and Woo with Ducks picking up salary for only this season as either player has 2 more years at 4.1 for Manson and 5.2 for Lindholm which will replace Tanev next year at an affordable price. 
     

    Canucks are going to let Stetcher walk anyways as there are younger cheaper options for 6th defenseman in Utica, Gaudette can be replaced by Madden, Focht or Costmar and Woo is an acceptable loss with Rathbone, Juelovi are making the jump in the next few years. Prospects are also supposed to be used as ammunition to get a better player and not just horded until they flame out or have a breakout season. 

    Oh man if we could get Lindholm in a Canucks Jersey..but barring an overpayment the Ducks never even consider it.

     

  16. On ‎2‎/‎8‎/‎2020 at 11:18 AM, Lazurus said:

    Pretty sure Tryamkin will sign here in March. He was able to play a offensive and this year, a defensive role in Russia and performed in the top 3 in Vancouver in his rookie and only season, tops in fights, +/- and shutting down the opposition's best players. He never got pushed around. Adds "space" for the skill players and will be cheap. They should try to get him signed for Gudbranson money. He and Fantenberg make Tanev available for growing the future.

     

    Stecher could be a throw in to move one of the elephant contracts, Stecher, retention and Eriksson for a bad contract in return and LTIR type deal although I am certain this loop hole will be closed next CBA. 

     

    Stech and Guad for Risto would be a good deal, defense wins championships.

    except Stetcher is better at defense than Risto is lol

×
×
  • Create New...