Ok guys, Roy's and Pominville's stats are pretty much identical, main difference is PIM's Roy have more than twice as many, I for one would rather have the player with more grit
You are simply looking at stats. Pominville is a better leader, better defensively, and has another year on his contract. Canucks should be happy with Roy, but lets not compare him to Pominville.
While I will agree about the less of a leader, and rental part I think you are off base with the defense, from what I've seen of both of them I'd give advantage to Roy on defense