Jump to content

Welcome to canucks.com Vancouver Canucks homepage

* - - - - 1 votes

Cam Cole (Vancouver Sun) RIPS Mike Gillis and Canucks to Shreds - Defends Alain Vigneault

This topic has been archived. This means that you cannot reply to this topic.
155 replies to this topic

#151 aqua59


    Canucks Third-Line

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 3,237 posts
  • Joined: 16-January 08

Posted 08 May 2013 - 07:32 AM

Who, really, to blame for fall of the Canucks?


Posted Image

Cam Cole Vancouver Sun

Mike Gillis wasn’t around to be interviewed Monday, probably because he sensed the media’s eagerness for a post-mortem on his Vancouver Canucks, and it’s bad form to perform an autopsy on a corpse that’s still twitching.

But who’s kidding whom?

This series, and this season, and this Canuck era are all over.

For a lot of reasons — not the least of which is the coming realignment that will no longer allow them an exalted playoff seeding by virtue of sitting atop the weakest division in hockey — it is time to start getting used to how the other half lives.

Yes, Vancouver. Again.

There is only one way for an organization to remain strong while its core ages gracefully, a la the Detroit Red Wings, and that is with a constant replenishment of NHL-level talent that can grow into bigger roles as the stars begin to fade.

That will not happen with the Canucks, not soon enough, because the cupboard is, if not entirely bare, decidedly bereft of young impact players capable of curing the team’s No. 1 deficiency: a lack of offensive firepower.

To use the elegant analogy of Detroit’s Pavel Datsyuk: lots of piano movers, not many who actually play the instrument.

Henrik and Daniel Sedin are still there front and centre, superior human beings that they are, to answer nightly for the club’s impotence.

But without a lot more help than Gillis has given them in the way of a supporting cast, they are not going to be able to dominate games even remotely the way they once did.

And the San Jose Sharks — with ample assistance from a rulebook that has been allowed to slide back nearly to pre-2005 levels of permissible interference — have provided a pretty good road map, in building their 3-0 series lead, for future opponents to short-circuit the twins’ cycling, telepathic Sedinery.

Ryan Kesler has been hurt too often to hold out hope of ever seeing him return to his 41-goal, Selke-winning form of 2010-11. Moreover, he and Alex Burrows and Max Lapierre made such a bed of nails for themselves over the years with antagonistic behaviour and embellishment, it hardly matters if they’ve tried to reform — and Burrows, at least, has.

Kevin Bieksa’s artful skewering Monday of Sharks’ “so-called Canadians” Joe Thornton and especially Logan Couture for diving and overacting doesn’t change the fact that referees apparently have no intention of ever looking at the three Canucks with an unjaundiced eye. When they’re on the ice, the calls will always tend to go the other way.

“We’re the embellishers,” Vigneault said Monday, stone-faced. The question mark was implied.

Meanwhile, Canuck management is carrying a plethora of albatrosses into the off-season — roughly $13.8 million worth of wasted contracts with Roberto Luongo twiddling his thumbs, Keith Ballard evidently consigned to the discard heap and the ever-injured, grossly overrated David Booth taking up space — and unless Gillis can go, cap in hand, to owner Francesco Aquilini and ask him to buy out a couple of them, and eat some of Luongo’s salary in order to move him, they will be hamstrung when they try to re-stock the shelves.

And wouldn’t you love to be a fly on the wall when that conversation takes place?

So far, we haven’t come to anything that’s Alain Vigneault’s fault, unless you think a sterner hand, earlier, by the head coach would have broken Burrows and Lapierre and Kesler of their thespian tendencies.

Sunday night’s third-period meltdown by Cory Schneider — in a game that, arguably, might have been Luongo’s to lose, based on his play in the first two — obscured a whole lot of other ills, most glaringly the lack of scoring, but also the utter invisibility of any number of forwards who’ve been exposed next to the dynamic, deep and muscular cast of the Sharks.

But really, it’s a little late now to be terribly outraged about the demise of the Canucks, because the die was cast last summer.

That’s when (we only found out much later) they were already all but certain that Manny Malhotra wasn’t going to make it back yet made no provision for the day when they’d have no one who could win a faceoff, let alone anchor a decent third line.

It’s when they didn’t trade Luongo, gambling that the market was going to improve if they held onto him. No one could have predicted how abjectly that gamble would fail, or how the consequences of that failure would dog the team all season long.

And then, at the trade deadline, Gillis’s cure for the lack of scoring depth was to trade for Derek Roy, another smurf centre for an organization that is fairly teeming with them. The Sharks have brushed Roy aside like a mosquito, as surely as they, or any other sizable playoff opponent, would have dismissed Jordan Schroeder or Andrew Ebbett.

The expression on Vigneault’s face after Game 3, the redness in his eyes, said: “I’m all out of ideas.”

The atmosphere in the Canucks’ room was shell-shocked, funereal.

“There’s not much to draw from right now,” said Luongo, who didn’t allow a goal in his 15:53 of relief work and looked as though he might bite a hole in his tongue when someone asked if he felt he should have started the game.

“There are not many positives in the first three games,” he said. “There are a couple of guys who are playing their hearts out. Other than that …”

And still we search in vain for the compelling reason to fire Vigneault that’s such a popular theme as this team’s era of excellence winds down, and Gillis’s loyal cornermen try to misdirect the responsibility.

Anyone who thinks that arranging the forward lines differently, or changing the defence pairs, or putting this player or that out on the ice at the end of a game would have made the difference is dreaming in Technicolor.

Not that coaching doesn’t have an impact; it surely does. Not that there isn’t some truth to the idea that after seven seasons, a fresh voice, some fresh ideas, can sometimes be a tonic to a group that’s lost its way.

But let’s not insult anyone’s intelligence: Scotty Bowman couldn’t have won a Cup with this outfit.

Not this year.

Posted Image


Loyalty by a GM to other management and players is a death wish for that GM. It sounds harsh but when emotion get in the way of a business decision bad results are what you'll get in the end. It happened to Burke more than once and it's happened to Gillis and now Mr Aquillini. He knows he's become too close to Gillis and if Gillis eventually loses his job I can bet the Aquillini' won't get so close to the next GM.
We all have to remember this is a business. AV is just a piece of the puzzle that now needs fixing.
I haven't heard the usual Burke built this team stuff lately, now Gillis gets that part too,the stinky part.
This is where a GM makes his mark. This team has been pretty good since Gillis took over.

Where does the scale tip when it comes to Gillis. I have been a huge Gillis supporter and I"m simply disappointed because I'm coming to the reality he's not who I thought he was when it comes to managing. Where are all the young fresh players with this new approach? The cupboards are more or less dry. You've got a heck of a mess to clean up Mr Gillis.

It's time to lose your emotions and clean the office end of the Canucks out. Your scouting staff is a joke.

Billy Ball management has been a disaster.

The Luongo situation has been a disaster that could have been worse if it weren't for Luongo's class. (from his contract to how this season has been handled in regards to being traded).

Now last nights out come. This team is old , slow and out of punch. That's the result of thinking this team was the great team it was just 2 short years ago. Your skill to evaluate your team failed.

Those are three huge things where Mr Gillis has failed not to mention the little things. Does taking the team to the Cup out weigh this?

#152 EmployeeoftheMonth


    Canucks All-Star

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 18,774 posts
  • Joined: 04-September 06

Posted 08 May 2013 - 07:44 AM

Hodgson was AVs fault not MGs

Hodgson was Hodgsons fault.

It's time for AV to go but that's not one of the reasons.
Posted Image
Posted Image

#153 Gally


    KJ's Butler

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 5,860 posts
  • Joined: 18-March 12

Posted 08 May 2013 - 09:59 AM

Hodgson was Hodgsons fault.

It's time for AV to go but that's not one of the reasons.

I phrased it wrong, it was more AV's fault than Gillis'. Gillis didn't want Hodgson to become a free agent and was doing his job. Hodgson could have played 2nd line RW but in the end it doesn't matter and I agree it was mostly Hodgson's fault he needed to be more patient. What's done is down though.

Edited by Gally, 08 May 2013 - 10:00 AM.




my mom wouldn't let me touch the laptop because I have to stand after I eat....kinda stupid



#154 smackyo23


    Comets Regular

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 438 posts
  • Joined: 19-May 11

Posted 08 May 2013 - 10:10 AM


AV's eyes weren't red because he was out of ideas. They were red because he knows he's getting fired for being incompetent. Keep putting Ballard in the pressbox and ripping him publically for making a few mistakes after he played great at the beginning of the season. Yes, let that happen when Bieksa has been incredibly inconsistent the entire season. Never send a message to Bieksa. Keep him in there and never hold him accountable. Good riddance to AV. He has always played favourites and it has cost this team.

I wish we had an offensive coach that would have used Grabner and Hodgson properly (i like Kassian too). AV would always be complaining about Grabner's defensive play, but do you know who I saw on the PK against the Pens yesterday? Grabner. AV doesn't appreciate pure offensive skill. He just likes to hate on them. So glad to see him gone.

It always cracked me up when AV or MG ( I can't remember which one) said that the Hodgson was playing protected minutes which is why he was producing points at a pretty good level. What a load of nonsense. If it was the protected minutes, why don't they do that with any of our other players? Oh yeah, they can't shoot like hodgson.

This is my thought, just said it before I could :)
Posted Image

#155 WiseOne


    Comets Star

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 522 posts
  • Joined: 12-March 13

Posted 08 May 2013 - 10:11 AM

He is absolutely right. I wrote a few times on these boards that the "cupboard is bare." I tought Roy was a good acquisition, however I did not do my homework enough on him - only 1 goal in 20 playoff games? We needed offence, and yet he went with an assesst that couldn't score.

The goaltending is a mess, however that in part is AV's fault as Luongo should have played the whole series.
Posted Image 

#156 BenDrinkin


    Canucks Regular

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 2,436 posts
  • Joined: 14-December 07

Posted 08 May 2013 - 10:13 AM

I liked what Gillis did with the Canucks, certain moves undoubtedly got us to the finals, but now things are looking bad. I could live with him staying on or being fired.

Canucks.com is the official Web site of The Vancouver Canucks. The Vancouver Canucks and Canucks.com are trademarks of The Vancouver Canucks Limited Partnership.  NHL and the word mark and image of the Stanley Cup are registered trademarks and the NHL Shield and NHL Conference logos are trademarks of the National Hockey League. All NHL logos and marks and NHL team logos and marks as well as all other proprietary materials depicted herein are the property of the NHL and the respective NHL teams and may not be reproduced without the prior written consent of NHL Enterprises, L.P.  Copyright © 2009 The Vancouver Canucks Limited Partnership and the National Hockey League.  All Rights Reserved.