Baer. Posted October 24, 2015 Share Posted October 24, 2015 Title: [Horvat // Thanks for Smoking.]Author: [Horvat] Length: [41:07]Link: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL7WLAejhh5r3JXAq42Gf6vGHcWTyXClEg Kyoto - Yung Lean 6/10 Good video productionAverage hookAverage lyricsDecent beatGet Buck - Pouya 3/10Average video productionPoor lyricsAverage hookAnnoying beatNever be Yours - Kali Uchis 4/10Entertaining video, quality productionHard to see how this is rap, unless I missed somethingHow I Look - Fat Nick 5/10Average lyricsAverage beatAverage lyricsYour typical trackEverything Good - Pouya Ft. SDotBraddy 8/10Catchy beat and lyricsGood hookTokyo Drift - Yung Lean Ft. Bladee, MonyHorse, PETZ, Junkman 2/10Off-beat rappingPoor beatBoring videoLife - Opion/Koan Sound 9/10Good lyricsCatchy beatGood productionHear Yee - Xavier Wulf 1/10Boring beatMonotone vocalsPoor productionpost hoc ergo propter hoc - Milo 6/10Good vocalsQuality video productionPoor beatGankin - Danzel Curry Ft JK the Reaper 4/10Average lyricsAverage beatPoor hookDiamonds - Yung Lean Ft Thaiboy Digital 7/10Decent beatAverage lyricsOff-tone at timesQuality video production________________________________________________________________________________Creativity 69/30 Variety 1337/30Track Flow ∞/10________________________________________________________________________________ Overall batman/200 8008/10 Link to comment
Kazmanian Devil Posted October 24, 2015 Share Posted October 24, 2015 Yung Lean - Kyoto-Don't understand a word he's saying-Beat's okay I guess-Hated it to be honest4/20Pouya - Get Buck-According to the description: "This music video is solely dedicated to the spice girls" :]-Nice flow-Most of the lyrics were stupid5/10Kali Uchis - Never Be Yours-Not even rap but okay-Not my style but I can respect it4.5/10Fat Nick - How I Look-Nothing lyrics again-Okay beat-Sounds like he has something in his mouth while he's rapping4/10Pouya - Everything Good ft. SDotBraddy-Sounds like something I'd hear on a GTA Radio station-Hook, beat, and flow all nice-I found it enjoyable7/10Yung Lean - Tokyo Drift ft. MonyHorse, PETZ, Bladee, Junkman-Beat reminds me of 3Hunna kind of-Terrible2/10Opiuo - Life-Voice reminds me of someone, can't quite figure it out.-Music sounded like a bunch of wet noises-Didn't like it3.5/10Xavier Wulf - Hear Yee-Really short-Kind of boring4/10Milo - post hoc ergo propter hoc (for Schopenhauer)-Actually pretty cool-Really chill-Lyrics actually make you think8/10Denzel Curry - Gankin' ft. JK the Reaper-Not bad, not great-Lyrics meh-Gets a point for that gunshot5/10Yung Lean and Thaiboy Digital - Diamonds-This kid again?-Same $&!#, different song6/20Creativity-I've never heard of any of these people so I guess it's creative25/30Variety-Too much Yung Lean12/30Track Flow7/10Overall-As hatedkid said, most of these aren't great if you're sober-I liked 2 songs3/10 Link to comment
GLASSJAW Posted October 24, 2015 Share Posted October 24, 2015 Horvat's taste in rap just doesn't really mesh with mine for the most part. 1. Yung Lean - Tokyo: 6.5/10- Won't lie, I love the production. The kid himself looks like the biggest idiot imaginable.- He's saying nothing but garbage: "i'm war ho, I'm warhol, I'm wario when I'm in Mario Kart" - only one of these statements is remotely believable. guess which one.- did I mention that I love the production?meaningless, empty track, but sounds good.2. Pouya - Get Buck: 2/10technically proficient. completely lacks soul, not a single genuine lyric or story being told, no unique talent on display (his technical proficiency just sounds like a bone thugs copy, as everyone has already said in the comments)some of the worst lyrics i've read in a hip hop song, and yet he concludes by calling himself lyrical, and by saying he 'hates being copied' (while using recycled metaphors throughout the entire song). i don't think he understands what a lyrical MC is, and he certainly isn't being copied, and he most certainly has copied others.but, like i said, technically proficient3. Kali Uchis - Never Be Yours: 7/10great beat/production. hardly much of a rap song, she's basically just singing. still a cool though.4. Fat Nick - How I Look: 4/10Didn't annoy me like Pouya did, but the production is weak, the hook is weak. Nothing I would ever want to hear again5. Pouya - Everything Good. 3.5/10Rapping about Florida over a beat from LBC, using the midwest Bone Thugs flow. does this kid have his own identity? sounds like he hasn't even gone through puberty yet.don't like this stuff at all. no heart, no authenticity.6. Yung Lean - Tokyo Drift: 4/10Weak lyrics, pretty cool production. the guy who starts rapping at like 2:30 might be the worst rapper i've ever heard lmaokinda cool to hear japanese rap, though.7. Opiuo - Life (KOAN remix) -/10.not rap.8. Xavier Wulf - Hear Yee: 2/10Just don't like it. Trap is my least favourite style of hip hop, and this just doesn't do anything with it to interest me at all, sorry9. Milo - Post Hoc: 8.5/10Great production, good lyrics.Nothing particularly original though, sounds like something a Clouddead affiliate would do.Not surprised to read Milo is friends with Busdriver.10. Denzel Curry - Gankin: 1/10.Terrible production, godawful lyrics. Utterly generic in every way. Sorry dude, just not my thing11. Yung Lean - Thaiboy Digital: 5/10Decent production again. Horrible lyrics, once again. What's the deal with that other dude singing? lmao. either way, it's oddly listenable.Overall, I'd give this about a 4/10, with some serious, serious low points. Link to comment
Horvat Posted October 24, 2015 Author Share Posted October 24, 2015 Yeah i feel you Glassjaw... idk i like to feel my music probably cause im stoned Link to comment
hatedkid666 Posted October 24, 2015 Share Posted October 24, 2015 Yeah i feel you Glassjaw... idk i like to feel my music probably cause im stonedThis is my first mixtape exchange so maybe i shouldnt, but I feel bad, you got destroyed. I do agree with everyone regarding the format, maybe an /10 score for each individual track and a /100 for the whole tape Link to comment
g_bassi13 Posted October 24, 2015 Share Posted October 24, 2015 I offer a pre-emptive apology for my review, as it will probably be saltier than it needs to be, because of the Blue Jays. Link to comment
g_bassi13 Posted October 24, 2015 Share Posted October 24, 2015 Kyoto - Yung Lean 5.5/10- I liked the lightness of it, but this rapper himself is pretty awful. I struggle to grab on to a word he says, and when I do, it feels like he's saying nothing.- I spaced out while listening to it, so I don't know whether that's a plus or a negative on a hip hop track like that. Though part of the reason, and a definite knock against it, is again how lacking in any presence this Yung Lean guy is.Get Buck - Pouya 3/10- Says a lot without saying anything at all.- I took nothing away from this track, but while a good rapper should be cocky, if they're going to be, they really have to back it up in some way. Any way. He didn't.Never be Yours - Kali Uchis 8.5/10- Love this song. It's going to end up on my own playlist for later listening. - Dunno if it's necessarily hip hop, don't care. How I Look - Fat Nick 3/10- Sounds like filler on a try hard main stream album. There's nothing to this song.Everything Good - Pouya Ft. SDotBraddy 2.5/10- Worse than his other song up there. - When I saw this guys name come up I was interested to see if he could up his game in any way, but that was bad. Repetitive, lazy crap.Tokyo Drift - Yung Lean Ft. Bladee, MonyHorse, PETZ, Junkman 4/10- I'm going to steal Hatedkid's comment, I couldn't distinguish it from the the first song, so I'm not going to rate it too high, even if it should maybe be reviewed independently of that first track. I don't think it serves the mixtape well for such a similar thing to show up againLife - Opion/Koan Sound 4/10- Sorry to again reference a previous reviewer first rather than the song itself, but I think Glassjaw is maybe out of place in saying this doesn't qualify. It isn't rap perhaps, but I do think it is hip hop, and certainly fits in somewhere in this spectrum. Maybe I'm just covering my own ass for future sake for saying that, because I've included a song with no words, but I think fair's fair, lol.- That said, I do not like the song. It's pretty dull for a song that tries to be different.Hear Yee - Xavier Wulf 2 /10- I don't get the youtube ratings on the song. Thought it was maybe the worst entry on the whole thing. Especially if you're the host that's talking about flow and togetherness of the mixtape that destroys a lot of it.post hoc ergo propter hoc - Milo 8.5/10- Sounds like some average dude talking at times, rather than someone working on a melody. But the song worked. I found myself hanging on whatever he was saying.- Really, if someone else rapped this song, maybe filled out the production, I could see it exploding.Gankin - Danzel Curry Ft JK the Reaper 1.5/10- I turned it off part way through. I maybe get the other entry choices, but this one I don't.Diamonds - Yung Lean Ft Thaiboy Digital 5/10- Better than the second, but not the first. And again, too damn similar. Overall 3.5/10I could appreciate how it took me a little out of my comfort zone by providing me with a type of music I don't always listen to, but it doesn't mean I enjoyed it. I think a lot of the music was outright bad. Most of it was too repetitive.Again sorry for the saltiness. Blame the Jays. Link to comment
hatedkid666 Posted October 24, 2015 Share Posted October 24, 2015 How many people are review it/how many people are left to review it. (and when we're done horvat's lets do mine ) Link to comment
g_bassi13 Posted October 24, 2015 Share Posted October 24, 2015 How many people are review it/how many people are left to review it. (and when we're done horvat's lets do mine )There are 10 participants. 5 have reviewed. One said that you have their thoughts down verbatim (You should still review, Jazz). One is the mixtape creator themselves. So that leaves 3.I don't think we can wait for every single person to review every mixtape before we move on, but I don't know what that cut-off should be all the same. They could always catch up and review after as well, I suppose. Link to comment
hatedkid666 Posted October 24, 2015 Share Posted October 24, 2015 There are 10 participants. 5 have reviewed. One said that you have their thoughts down verbatim (You should still review, Jazz). One is the mixtape creator themselves. So that leaves 3.I don't think we can wait for every single person to review every mixtape before we move on, but I don't know what that cut-off should be all the same. They could always catch up and review after as well, I suppose.Yeah, don't see why they couldn't catch up if they fall behind Link to comment
Baer. Posted October 24, 2015 Share Posted October 24, 2015 It goes without saying that not everybody will be able to or even want to post a review every night. I don't see why we should delay, especially with the weekend coming up, people will have plenty a chance to post their review. What I'm trying to say is this will take forever if we keep waiting for everybody to post since we all have different schedules and time zones. If 1 or 2 people haven't posted, it shouldn't hold up everybody else. Link to comment
Zfetch Posted October 24, 2015 Share Posted October 24, 2015 Kyoto - Yung Lean 4/20I guess it's somewhat listenable. Meh- not my thing.Get Buck - Pouya 3/10A little better. Too generic.Never be Yours - Kali Uchis 7/10Not really close to rap. Pretty nice flow though.How I Look - Fat Nick 2 /10I don't care how he looks, he sounds awful.Everything Good - Pouya Ft. SDotBraddy 8/10Beat is nice. Artists could have been better, but this is pretty good.Tokyo Drift - Yung Lean Ft. Bladee, MonyHorse, PETZ, Junkman 1/10NoLife - Opion/Koan Sound 3/10It's unique- I'll give it that.Hear Yee - Xavier Wulf 1/10Sounds like every crappy rap song I've ever heard.post hoc ergo propter hoc - Milo 4/10MehGankin - Danzel Curry Ft JK the Reaper 2/10I like curry. I don't like Denzel Curry.Diamonds - Yung Lean Ft Thaiboy Digital 4/20Too much autotune. Generic beat and flow.Creativity 20/30 Variety 20/30Track Flow 3/10________________________________________________________________________________ Overall 82/200 4/10 Link to comment
Zfetch Posted October 24, 2015 Share Posted October 24, 2015 Kyoto - Yung Lean 4/20I guess it's somewhat listenable. Meh- not my thing.Get Buck - Pouya 3/10A little better. Too generic.Never be Yours - Kali Uchis 7/10Not really close to rap. Pretty nice flow though.How I Look - Fat Nick 2 /10I don't care how he looks, he sounds awful.Everything Good - Pouya Ft. SDotBraddy 8/10Beat is nice. Artists could have been better, but this is pretty good.Tokyo Drift - Yung Lean Ft. Bladee, MonyHorse, PETZ, Junkman 1/10NoLife - Opion/Koan Sound 3/10It's unique- I'll give it that.Hear Yee - Xavier Wulf 1/10Sounds like every crappy rap song I've ever heard.post hoc ergo propter hoc - Milo 4/10MehGankin - Danzel Curry Ft JK the Reaper 2/10I like curry. I don't like Denzel Curry.Diamonds - Yung Lean Ft Thaiboy Digital 4/20Too much autotune. Generic beat and flow.Creativity 20/30 Variety 20/30Track Flow 3/10________________________________________________________________________________ Overall 82/200 4/10 Link to comment
thejazz97 Posted October 24, 2015 Share Posted October 24, 2015 Not gonna lie, I just didn't feel like reviewing this at the time. That being said, still not much of a fan and I still share many of hk's sentiments. And I'm assuming I was supposed to be high when listening to this, which I wasn't.Kyoto - Yung Lean 5/20- Would like an instrumental. Video and lyrics sucked.Get Buck - Pouya 4/10- I like the flow, but like HK said, nothing special. Content's not really my thing either.Never be Yours - Kali Uchis 1/10-No.How I Look - Fat Nick 2/10-No, again. At least the beat is decent.Everything Good - Pouya Ft. SDotBraddy 4/10- I like the 90s vibe. But it's just another rap song.Tokyo Drift - Yung Lean Ft. Bladee, MonyHorse, PETZ, Junkman 4/10- Not gonna lie, that's one of the dopest beats I've heard. But boing lyrics bro.Life - Opion/Koan Sound 10/10- "Not really rap but I like the song" - hatedkid666- I gave it 10 for the beat alone.Hear Yee - Xavier Wulf 1 /10- "Boring song, boring production" - hatedkid666post hoc ergo propter hoc - Milo 4/10-not bad lyrically. at all. terrible production though.Gankin - Danzel Curry Ft JK the Reaper 2/10- It's like it tried to be cool, but failed.Diamonds - Yung Lean Ft Thaiboy Digital 7/20- so boring. But the bass is good. so I gave it 7 for that.________________________________________________________________________________Creativity 4/30 - Too much of the same. The 4 is for the Milo song lyrics.Variety 4/30- Not much variety.Track Flow 8/10- "All tracks flowed well together for the most part" - hatedkid666________________________________________________________________________________ Overall 5/10"Lots of really weak and boring trap songs" - hatedkid666 Link to comment
hatedkid666 Posted October 24, 2015 Share Posted October 24, 2015 i appreciate how much im being quoted Link to comment
Horvat Posted October 24, 2015 Author Share Posted October 24, 2015 i appreciate how much im being quoted next one will be up tonight Link to comment
hatedkid666 Posted October 24, 2015 Share Posted October 24, 2015 next one will be up tonightCHOOSE MINE OR ELSE UR NOT COMING TO MY BIRTHDAY PARTY Link to comment
GLASSJAW Posted October 24, 2015 Share Posted October 24, 2015 Never be Yours - Kali Uchis 1/10-No.post hoc ergo propter hoc - Milo 4/10-not bad lyrically. at all. terrible production though. you trippin Link to comment
g_bassi13 Posted October 25, 2015 Share Posted October 25, 2015 nayI'm with him, those are easily the two best songs in the mix. Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.