Mafia: The Holy Grail (Game Over - SK Wins!)

[Aladeen]

Just now, Master Radishes said:

This round: townies begin to coalesce.

 

Also this round: Aladeen attacks in all directions.

Just two directions certain scum MR and Certain monkey potato probably town but may as well not be. 

[Master Radishes]

Someone like WW might fit the bill of a scum trying to nod along but keep to the sides of things.

[Master Radishes]

Anyway I sleep now.

 

Unvote; vote Aladeen

 

Go big or go home.

[Time Lord]

1 minute ago, Master Radishes said:

Anyway I sleep now.

 

Unvote; vote Aladeen

 

Go big or go home.

wait one minute

[Aladeen]

Just now, Master Radishes said:

Anyway I sleep now.

 

Unvote; vote Aladeen

 

Go big or go home.

Please thunderdome us! I don’t want to live in a town that doesn’t see this fooker for what he is. When he is literally taunting us with his scumminess. 

[Time Lord]

Ok screw it I'm doing it

 

I am the sheriff!!!

 

N0 - SD (town)

N1 - Tanev (town)

N2 - AngryElf (3P)

N3 - Toews (town)

[Time Lord]

For AE it actually said Angel (3P)

[Aladeen]

I Hope you’re right about fetch man. 

[Time Lord]

So now I think ilduce and I should decide on a pool of players that he can vig kill and a pool of players that I can investigate

[Aladeen]

Him watching MR doesn’t confirm his alignment by any stretch. Doc should definitely not come out and will have to pick between duce and TL to protect. 

[Time Lord]

Should we just lynch AE or try to find mafia instead of 3P?

[J-23]

Just now, Time Lord said:

Should we just lynch AE or try to find mafia instead of 3P?

Find Mafia

[Aladeen]

Just now, Time Lord said:

Should we just lynch AE or try to find mafia instead of 3P?

My Aladeenis says MR man, 3p can wait especially an uninvested 3p that may actually trigger an SK with his death. 

[Alchemy Time]

we should only hit AE if we find the 3rd member of his team

[Aladeen]

23 minutes ago, Master Radishes said:

Let the Sheriff decide, should one exist (tracker is pretty sheriff-esque and having both feels unfair for the mafia). They might've copped a dead town so the numbers don't work as well as you guys are hoping.

This sounds like a salty scum blaming mechanics of the game to the position they are in. 

[Time Lord]

lucky - very likely TP

Ilunga - need more info

ilduce - confirmed TP

Aladeen - fairly likely TP

Zfetch - basically confirmed TP in my mind, not really feeling the tinfoil theory on him

Toews - confirmed TP

AE - confirmed 3P

MR - not sure

AT - likely TP

shiznak - not sure

WW - had a TP lean but not sure anymore

Time Lord - confirmed TP
DM - not sure

jazz - not sure

SD - confirmed TP
J-23 - not sure

 

so yeah my mafia leans on jazz and shiznak were never really that strong to begin with and I don't have any true mafia leans now, just feels like we need to keep eliminating the unknown people

[Time Lord]

If hitting AE activates the SK is that really a bad thing? They'd probably want to hit mafia right now, I could see them making the pool even smaller

[Alchemy Time]

iirc I've never played with this type role before so idk the objective strat but my instinct says not to activate it til we know who it is

[Alchemy Time]

willing to concede to more experienced players here though

[Blue Jay 22]

Round 4 Vote Count:

 

Shiznak (3) -  Luckylager, Alchemy Time, Time Lord

Master Radishes (3) - Shiznak, Snake Doctor, Aladeen

Ilunga (2) - Intoews, Zfetch

AngryElf (1) - Angry Elf

Snake Doctor (1) - Jazz

Aladeen (1) - Master Radishes

 

No Votes (5): Ilunga, ilduce39, Where's Wellwood, DarthMelvin, J23

 

@DarthMelvin you must vote this round

Edited September 24, 2023 by Blue Jay 22