Mafia 2018: The year of the missing mafia

[112 4,352]

22 minutes ago, Zfetch said:

In case anyone was wondering, nightfall will be tomorrow(Saturday) at 10PM PST.

Requests for a speed round will be denied.

Movement to grant me a vigilante kill

[112 4,352]

1 hour ago, Zfetch said:

I am tracker"- dt said
"we should um lynch DT he is a liar" - the town replied
"I AM TRACKER!" - DT echoed for four days and four nights
"...okay I'm actually doctor haha" - dt said
"WOLF!!!!!" - the townspeople said
"WOLF!" - ...The boy cried.

Doubt Tea you may have your last words

________________________________________

BJ confirmed mafia.

[Beluga Whale 4,131]

3 minutes ago, 112 said:

BJ confirmed mafia.

Wat

[112 4,352]

Just now, Beluga Whale said:

Wat

nvm the boy isn't DT

 

and him saying 'wolf' doesn't mean the person he accused/voted for is mafia

[Blue Jay 22 3,086]

Wtf? Now I have to eat a freaking hat.

[Beluga Whale 4,131]

It was weird when Stamkos just assumed by prediction of the setup was accurate. I know 112 stated this, but definitely smells of TMI. 

 

[Beluga Whale 4,131]

@DarthMelvin Proposition: let's start this round with a clean slate between us. It's important that we try to have a good dialogue imo. 

[Beluga Whale 4,131]

3 minutes ago, Blue Jay 22 said:

Wtf? Now I have to eat a freaking hat.

Please eat your MAGA hat. 

[Blue Jay 22 3,086]

No 2nd kill this time during nightfall and the game is still going. With 8 players total, I'm guessing the player that was converted ended as mafia, not cult. And if that's the case, then there probably isn't a cult in this game. The poisoning business however...not aware of any TP or Mafia role that deals with that.

 

My guess: 8 players - 2 scenarios I imagine:

 

6 TP, 1 mafia special, 1 3P

5 TP, 2 mafia, 1 3P

[Beluga Whale 4,131]

Just now, Blue Jay 22 said:

No 2nd kill this time during nightfall and the game is still going. With 8 players total, I'm guessing the player that was converted ended as mafia, not cult. And if that's the case, then there probably isn't a cult in this game. The poisoning business however...not aware of any TP or Mafia role that deals with that.

 

My guess: 8 players - 2 scenarios I imagine:

 

6 TP, 1 mafia special, 1 3P

5 TP, 2 mafia, 1 3P

Poisoner is a less common SK variant. Players targeted with the poison will die the following night. I'm almost certain this role is in the game.

[Beluga Whale 4,131]

Very fun fact: I'm pretty sure I was the first person to introduce the poisoner role to CDC mafia. And I gave the role to none other than Zfetch himself.

[112 4,352]

2 minutes ago, Beluga Whale said:

Poisoner is a less common SK variant. Players targeted with the poison will die the following night. I'm almost certain this role is in the game.

Could he have merged it with a cult?

[Beluga Whale 4,131]

Just now, 112 said:

Could he have merged it with a cult?

Possibly yes. 

[112 4,352]

1 minute ago, Beluga Whale said:

Possibly yes. 

If I ask you a serious of rhetorical questions, will you answer all of them?

[Beluga Whale 4,131]

1 minute ago, 112 said:

If I ask you a serious of rhetorical questions, will you answer all of them?

I will chime in on everything.

 

I was gonna have a following to my previous response but I got lazy and didn't really want to endlessly speculate about the setup.

[Beluga Whale 4,131]

Just now, Beluga Whale said:

I will chime in on everything.

 

I was gonna have a following to my previous response but I got lazy and didn't really want to endlessly speculate about the setup.

Follow up not following

[Blue Jay 22 3,086]

35 minutes ago, Beluga Whale said:

I know BJ loves to keep me alive when he's mafia and I'm town. Because he believes and wants to prove he can out maneuver me. 

Half-true. But also false.

 

Without giving too much away, the one thing I always to keep in mind when I play mafia is to play smart. I've definitely kept you around in the past when I've been mafia, I'll admit that, but I would never do so only to prove a point to you. Or anyone for that matter.

 

That's about as honest as I can get with you. Now you have you to tell me your mafia mindset.

 

[Blue Jay 22 3,086]

14 minutes ago, 112 said:

If I ask you a serious of rhetorical questions, will you answer all of them?

Maybe in the other thread.

[Beluga Whale 4,131]

4 minutes ago, Blue Jay 22 said:

Half-true. But also false.

 

Without giving too much away, the one thing I always to keep in mind when I play mafia is to play smart. I've definitely kept you around in the past when I've been mafia, I'll admit that, but I would never do so only to prove a point to you. Or anyone for that matter.

 

That's about as honest as I can get with you. Now you have you to tell me your mafia mindset.

 

That's fair. I believe that.

I know you enjoyed those times you tricked me. 

 

My mindset is the same as my town mindset: win the game at all costs. I try to only make the optimal choice for my team no matter what.

[Zfetch 3,277]

21 minutes ago, Beluga Whale said:

Very fun fact: I'm pretty sure I was the first person to introduce the poisoner role to CDC mafia. And I gave the role to none other than Zfetch himself.

I was suspended on CDC so I played that whole game through emailing you.
Worthy Ironman right here ;P