Mafia: The Game [Suits]

[Aladeen]

Just now, Alain Vigneault said:

I think you're right that CL, if anything, is at least a safe option.  If he's mafia, its a fantastic lynch.  if he's sheriff (and therefore, clean) he's likely naive (or whichever is always TP investigation) so not much help anyways.

 

But jazz has really put me off.  Throws shade at il duce the whole game, says hes mafia, promptly votes duce and says i told you so and then backs out.   Plus him getting the same results as Zfetch (who is very likely to be TP since he posted his PM) is very suspicious.

 

Not enough attention is being paid to fwybwed and I can probably get behind that.  However, we'd be voting based on something only BW saw.  I doubt BW would lie though.  Idk.

 

 

You're preaching to the choir, If Jazz is TP he has played a bad bad game thus far... but between him and CL, at least Jazz has the possibility of being the sheriff he claims. 

 

I doubt that both CL and the duce are mafia because of how quick people were to follow me against Duce last round, which was partly why I gave into virt and ended up voting for CL.

 

Dr. S was against the CL lynch, even though he didn't cast a vote last round, he did say that we should lynch ilduce, heffy or M&H in a post.

 

The investigation of Lewt, makes it so he is probably TP if zfetch and Jazz are telling the truth.

 

So if we were just going off of the information we gained from the last nightfall (Dr. S was mafia) then CL should be lynched over ilduce for the first lynch.

 

For the second vote I think what we know now keeps the following players out of the noose:

 

Lewt

M&H

Zfetch

Jazz

Barzal 

Ilduce 

KH

 

 

BW caught Fwybwed using PM - now in actuality the fact that he slanked so bad that he probably should have been GKed may actually work in his favor because he claimed to be begging intoews in PM not to GK him.

 

However, fwybwed wasn't particularly active in the thread, now if he was in say mafia chat then perhaps intoews may have given him some leeway in that regard. So although I am mainly voting for fwybwed on BWs recommendation if we think it through logically he may be the best second lynch we have at this point. 

 

[CanucksLegacy]

Just take a strong hard look at who's leading all of you guys (for those few that don't already know, Aladeen). Jazz swayed so easily, Heffy so easily taking Aladeen's side given he's a veteran (do you even skepticize bro?) and look at AV, bandwagon central, "yup I agree with this and yeah I agree with that". Throws in the random disagreement to make himself look legit.

 

I'm going to predict that bassi joins the wagon on me at some point, and for someone who hasn't contributed much aside taking sides he's obviously one to look at. I would laugh so hard if these guys were all Mafia and they're the ones carrying the discussion.

 

The ones who've had the most experience (Heffy of note, bassi previous round) and are least skeptical of whoever is leading (Aladeen). I'd rather trust GG at this point because he's actually trying to think it through now. At least the guy is willing to think things out. And that's saying a lot since I doubted him since the game began.

 

"CL is safest lynch since he might be naive, real sheriff or lying. I totally can't be making this up cause I'm Mafia trying to make it easier by getting a sheriff lynched. If they're naive at least it's a TP, if they're real then that's bonus. It's ok the TP will follow me wherever I go." - your leader Aladeen (for the clueless: he obvious didn't say this, this is probably his logic from my perspective)

 

Just puck logic eh?

 

I'd like to think I'm pretty level-headed aside from last round, but you guys are really testing me. That's why I really, really hope I'm the naive sheriff. Then everything would make sense.

 

VoteA ilduce

VoteB Aladeen

 

At least, with this, you guys can't say I gave up too easily. I tried to stay alive, summarized pages of content to make it easier on the actives/inactives, and risked being suspended/permanently banned (though I didn't know this was a consequence at the time) from future games.

[CanucksLegacy]

In b4 I last minute switch from ilduce to myself and people still think I'm Mafia. For people that are so skeptical of inactives, they sure look good wanting to lynch an active who actually has a sense of what's going on over an inactive 

[Aladeen]

Just now, CanucksLegacy said:

Just take a strong hard look at who's leading all of you guys (for those few that don't already know, Aladeen). Jazz swayed so easily, Heffy so easily taking Aladeen's side given he's a veteran (do you even skepticize bro?) and look at AV, bandwagon central, "yup I agree with this and yeah I agree with that". Throws in the random disagreement to make himself look legit.

 

I'm going to predict that bassi joins the wagon on me at some point, and for someone who hasn't contributed much aside taking sides he's obviously one to look at. I would laugh so hard if these guys were all Mafia and they're the ones carrying the discussion.

 

The ones who've had the most experience (Heffy of note, bassi previous round) and are least skeptical of whoever is leading (Aladeen). I'd rather trust GG at this point because he's actually trying to think it through now. At least the guy is willing to think things out. And that's saying a lot since I doubted him since the game began.

 

"CL is safest lynch since he might be naive, real sheriff or lying. I totally can't be making this up cause I'm Mafia trying to make it easier by getting a sheriff lynched. If they're naive at least it's a TP, if they're real then that's bonus. It's ok the TP will follow me wherever I go." - your leader Aladeen (for the clueless: he obvious didn't say this, this is probably his logic from my perspective)

 

Just puck logic eh?

 

I'd like to think I'm pretty level-headed aside from last round, but you guys are really testing me. That's why I really, really hope I'm the naive sheriff. Then everything would make sense.

 

VoteA ilduce

VoteB Aladeen

 

At least, with this, you guys can't say I gave up too easily. I tried to stay alive, summarized pages of content to make it easier on the actives/inactives, and risked being suspended/permanently banned (though I didn't know this was a consequence at the time) from future games.

You are so ridonkulouusly mafia it's hilarious... I had given you the benefit of the doubt and you claim GG has put more thought into this game than I have is an absolute joke. I have logically come to the conclusion that you are the best bet for being mafia and your argument is that I have (Just like BW) am playing some kind of a long con from the beginning of this game? You haven't addressed how Dr. S didn't want you voted off, but instead recommended we lynch ilduce. I can see where Virt's frustration came from last game. 

 

REMINDER TO ALL TP and SK:

 

42 minutes ago, Aladeen said:

I encourage all TP and the SK to vote for CL and Fwybwed so it can't be swung last second like last round.

 

 

If intoews made this game 1/3 mafia from the get go we barely have the mafia outnumbered at this point. 

 

 

[King Heffy]

8 minutes ago, CanucksLegacy said:

Just take a strong hard look at who's leading all of you guys (for those few that don't already know, Aladeen). Jazz swayed so easily, Heffy so easily taking Aladeen's side given he's a veteran (do you even skepticize bro?) and look at AV, bandwagon central, "yup I agree with this and yeah I agree with that". Throws in the random disagreement to make himself look legit.

 

I'm going to predict that bassi joins the wagon on me at some point, and for someone who hasn't contributed much aside taking sides he's obviously one to look at. I would laugh so hard if these guys were all Mafia and they're the ones carrying the discussion.

 

The ones who've had the most experience (Heffy of note, bassi previous round) and are least skeptical of whoever is leading (Aladeen). I'd rather trust GG at this point because he's actually trying to think it through now. At least the guy is willing to think things out. And that's saying a lot since I doubted him since the game began.

 

"CL is safest lynch since he might be naive, real sheriff or lying. I totally can't be making this up cause I'm Mafia trying to make it easier by getting a sheriff lynched. If they're naive at least it's a TP, if they're real then that's bonus. It's ok the TP will follow me wherever I go." - your leader Aladeen (for the clueless: he obvious didn't say this, this is probably his logic from my perspective)

 

Just puck logic eh?

 

I'd like to think I'm pretty level-headed aside from last round, but you guys are really testing me. That's why I really, really hope I'm the naive sheriff. Then everything would make sense.

 

VoteA ilduce

VoteB Aladeen

 

At least, with this, you guys can't say I gave up too easily. I tried to stay alive, summarized pages of content to make it easier on the actives/inactives, and risked being suspended/permanently banned (though I didn't know this was a consequence at the time) from future games.

Aladeen isn't being lynched.  The guy is clearly tp and I frankly agree with his thinking.  We can't be wasting votes as the mafia can easily stuff the vote if players get only a vote or two against them.

[CanucksLegacy]

Just now, Aladeen said:

You are so ridonkulouusly mafia it's hilarious... I had given you the benefit of the doubt and you claim GG has put more thought into this game than I have is an absolute joke. I have logically come to the conclusion that you are the best bet for being mafia and your argument is that I have (Just like BW) am playing some kind of a long con from the beginning of this game? You haven't addressed how Dr. S didn't want you voted off, but instead recommended we lynch ilduce. I can see where Virt's frustration came from last game. 

 

REMINDER TO ALL TP and SK:

 

 

Do you really think Dr. S would be dumb enough to overtly protect a teammate like that? Are you kidding me? You've played this game more than I have. I CALLED HIM OUT in one of my very first POSTS, Dr. S was acting like he was last game 

 

Can you not blame me for thinking you're doing some long con, you've been one of, if not the biggest flip-flopper so far this game.

[CanucksLegacy]

55 minutes ago, Aladeen said:

I encourage all TP and the SK to vote for CL and Fwybwed so it can't be swung last second like last round.

 

 

If intoews made this game 1/3 mafia from the get go we barely have the mafia outnumbered at this point. 

 

Helping Aladeen remind everyone. fwybwed/ilduce/Aladeen would be great candidates for SK, whichever one isn't the second lynch..

 

[CanucksLegacy]

4 minutes ago, King Heffy said:

Aladeen isn't being lynched.  The guy is clearly tp and I frankly agree with his thinking.  We can't be wasting votes as the mafia can easily stuff the vote if players get only a vote or two against them.

I basically got "I'm agreeing with Aladeen because I can." Bolded for reference come nightfall.

 

 

[Aladeen]

8 minutes ago, CanucksLegacy said:

Do you really think Dr. S would be dumb enough to overtly protect a teammate like that? Are you kidding me? You've played this game more than I have. I CALLED HIM OUT in one of my very first POSTS, Dr. S was acting like he was last game 

 

Can you not blame me for thinking you're doing some long con, you've been one of, if not the biggest flip-flopper so far this game.

The spew we get from a mafia player who didn't see his death coming is about the best we can hope for. So let's see what is more likely here. 

 

I faked DCgate + was willing to die to figure out if the sheriff situation in the first round only to be saved by BW within the last 20 minutes to lynch one of our team mates + BW foreseeing us lynching the legit sheriff (you) in this round so decided to have his team kill him after getting to the pinnacle of TP cred + Dr. S realizing that he was going to be SK killed last round decided to incriminate you by supporting you not to get lynched.

 

VS

 

You pretending to be sheriff after Virt lied about tracking you to BW only to say you did indeed investigate the very person that round he LIED about?

[Mathew Barzal]

Vote CL

[CanucksLegacy]

1 minute ago, Aladeen said:

The spew we get from a mafia player who didn't see his death coming is about the best we can hope for. So let's see what is more likely here. 

 

I faked DCgate + was willing to die to figure out if the sheriff situation in the first round only to be saved by BW within the last 20 minutes to lynch one of our team mates + BW foreseeing us lynching the legit sheriff (you) in this round so decided to have his team kill him after getting to the pinnacle of TP cred + Dr. S realizing that he was going to be SK killed last round decided to incriminate you by supporting you not to get lynched.

 

VS

 

You pretending to be sheriff after Virt lied about tracking you to BW only to say you did indeed investigate the very person that round he LIED about?

So:

1. You were willing to confuse TP just for $&!#s and giggles

2. You have some complex Mafia strategy to confuse everyone to take advantage of the no PM rule.

3. All part of the plan above.

4. Defends me to help me appear like a teammate in the eyes of "TP" like you.

 

Obviously PMs was a big part for me last time, it helped find inconsistencies in stories or claims. Now that there are no PMs, i'd say the playing field has had to adjust. 

 

As for the Virt incident, the probability of him faking and me claiming, I understand are slim. However, like I said before, if you were to ask me what are the odds that two unaffiliated parties (KH and TL) in the previous game (DBZ) claimed the same character (Karin/Korin) out 100s of possible characters, what would you say? Virtually impossible, but yes, it did happen.

 

[CanucksLegacy]

4 minutes ago, Mathew Barzal said:

Vote CL

Don't forget to:

 

VoteA 

VoteB

 

Since there's two lynches tonight.

[Mathew Barzal]

Just now, CanucksLegacy said:

Don't forget to:

 

VoteA 

VoteB

 

Since there's two lynches tonight.

Thanks for the reminder, honestly it was a mistake for me to join this game. I can't keep up with the posting rate and I'm just doing the TP a disservice by sitting out.

 

VoteA: CL

VoteB: Aladeen

[Aladeen]

 

3 minutes ago, Mathew Barzal said:

Thanks for the reminder, honestly it was a mistake for me to join this game. I can't keep up with the posting rate and I'm just doing the TP a disservice by sitting out.

 

VoteA: CL

VoteB: Aladeen

Wow just wow man Read some of this game and then go slap yourself for your second vote and then if you are TP come back and change it.

[Aladeen]

I think we can safely assume Barzal isn't the SK, the SK is definitely keeping up with this game. 

[AV.]

1 minute ago, Aladeen said:

I think we can safely assume Barzal isn't the SK, the SK is definitely keeping up with this game. 

Bad read I think.

 

Wouldn't an SK want to draw the least speculation to himself?  Barzal saying that he hasn't kept up + doing the bare minimum to avoid a GK would lessen the chance of MAFIA having anything to work with if they decided to go specialist hunting/3rd party hunting.  The only drawback of staying low like Barzal has is that the TP can become suspicious of him being MAFIA. 

[Aladeen]

1 minute ago, Alain Vigneault said:

Bad read I think.

 

Wouldn't an SK want to draw the least speculation to himself?  Barzal saying that he hasn't kept up + doing the bare minimum to avoid a GK would lessen the chance of MAFIA having anything to work with if they decided to go specialist hunting/3rd party hunting.  The only drawback of staying low like Barzal has is that the TP can become suspicious of him being MAFIA. 

Maybe, but I feel fairly confident the SK wouldn't vote for me at this point of the game. But the SK is the least of our concerns right now anyways. I think the reluctance to follow my logic and the vote I have laid out speaks volumes to the fact that I am probably right and the mafia don't want CL and Fwybwed voted out this round.

[g_bassi13]

VoteA CL

VoteB Fwybed

 

Need to get Fwybed out.

 

Not sure if this is agressive TP Aladeen, or defensive Mafia Aladeen, because the two sometimes blend together for me. But I'm willing to give him more of a benefit of the doubt as he's at least active for now. Heffy is probably acting like the most TP guy here.

[AV.]

I'll go with my gut (and I really don't feel like singing to the choir again or w.e Aladeen said/meant)

 

VOTE A: ILDUCE39

 

 

[Mathew Barzal]

The animosity in this thread is real, I got angry just reading the last two rounds.

 

UnvoteA;UnvoteB.

 

VoteA: CL

VoteB: fwybwed

 

I wish I knew more about Aladeen's posting style to understand his motives. Everything I read was just baseless spew from both sides - concrete evidence there was not.

 

Gut's telling me this is the wrong direction but my gut kind of f*cked the TP over last game.