Mafia: Switch

[Time Lord]

8 minutes ago, Blue Jay 22 said:

Bold, but don't think so. She claimed an uncommon role early in R1, and has been questioning others who claim a similar role. I doubt she would claim switcher as mafia given how she wouldn't know how many others could be one.

If she's a mafia switcher, I don't think she would assume that there's a TP switcher. And for some reason role claims are easily believed, so it basically gave Hashtag a ticket to the end of the game (which is probably still going to happen even though I'm pointing it out)

6 minutes ago, Blue Jay 22 said:

Why her? There are 2 others claiming the same role that have not been as upfront with their actions.

Why would J-23 put attention on himself as mafia? To potentially get hashtag lynched when he can just MK her?

 

In AV's case, I don't see why anyone would ever want to be the 3rd one to claim a role unless it's the truth. 

 

 

 

[Time Lord]

5 minutes ago, HashtagNucks said:

The role doesn't say anything about there being more then one Switcher in the game.

So it would be a really awkward move for a Mafia Switcher to come out in the fashion I did.

 

There's definitely something going on with TL though.
Not sure why i'd be his first and consistent person to vote for.

Originally I thought there was one switcher and they'd be 3P based on Zfetch's tendency to make the 3P a big deal, or mafia because it doesn't seem like a TP role to me. I guess I was wrong about that last part though.

[NotMyBurroughs]

20 minutes ago, Time Lord said:

If she's a mafia switcher, I don't think she would assume that there's a TP switcher. And for some reason role claims are easily believed, so it basically gave Hashtag a ticket to the end of the game (which is probably still going to happen even though I'm pointing it out)

Why would J-23 put attention on himself as mafia? To potentially get hashtag lynched when he can just MK her?

 

In AV's case, I don't see why anyone would ever want to be the 3rd one to claim a role unless it's the truth. 

 

 

 

I agree with a large majority of what you said.

 

I lean more towards not trusting AV's claim. 
I forget who mentioned the possibility of two switchers and they swap roles with who the other picked.

AV jumping in adds much more uncertainty. 

I would really like to hear from J-23. Him being so silent after being asked a fairly crucial question is very suspicious. Gives him time to talk to teammates about how to answer.

[J-23]

3 hours ago, DarthMelvin said:

Ahh yes.

 

@J-23 who did you choose?

 

BJ has openly stated he is no longer the doc. if J-23 choice were maf before he/she may not be now making  BJ maf. Hmmmm We need that confirmation. Pure speculation tho

 

I jyst got the role this round, haven't chose anyone yet.

[NotMyBurroughs]

12 minutes ago, J-23 said:

I jyst got the role this round, haven't chose anyone yet.

That's definitely not how my switcher role works

[J-23]

1 minute ago, HashtagNucks said:

That's definitely not how my switcher role works

Well all I know is I am a Switcher, who is a TP. If you want me to prove it, please lynch me this round. Then all these other guys like AV, and # will be &^@#ed.

[DarthMelvin]

Hash who did you pick?

 

And J-23 since you are now switcher What was your previous role???

[DarthMelvin]

1 hour ago, J-23 said:

Well all I know is I am a Switcher, who is a TP. If you want me to prove it, please lynch me this round. Then all these other guys like AV, and # will be &^@#ed.

Not necessary. 

[J-23]

Just now, DarthMelvin said:

Hash who did you pick?

 

And J-23 since you are now switcher What was your previous role???

I am roleblocker. If I tell you who I chose in nightfall, it may change things up..am I allowed?

[J-23]

1 minute ago, J-23 said:

I am roleblocker. If I tell you who I chose in nightfall, it may change things up..am I allowed?

Like am I allowed to explain the role and all that or no?

[DarthMelvin]

is Role blocker a maf role?

[NotMyBurroughs]

5 minutes ago, DarthMelvin said:

Hash who did you pick?

 

And J-23 since you are now switcher What was your previous role???

I said it right after nightfall, I switched with Blue Jay. Who has since confirmed.

 

3 minutes ago, J-23 said:

I am roleblocker. If I tell you who I chose in nightfall, it may change things up..am I allowed?

You are? Then how did you just become the switcher?

Please do share who you blocked and what's happened since then.

[J-23]

Just now, HashtagNucks said:

I said it right after nightfall, I switched with Blue Jay. Who has since confirmed.

 

You are? Then how did you just become the switcher?

Please do share who you blocked and what's happened since then.

I role blocked you, it may explain why your nightfall with choosing BJ22 didn't work.

[J-23]

1 minute ago, DarthMelvin said:

is Role blocker a maf role?

TP role..

[NotMyBurroughs]

Just now, J-23 said:

I role blocked you, it may explain why your nightfall with choosing BJ22 didn't work.

It did work. It switched Blue Jay's role according to him.

And why would you block someone claiming a role, they were going to prove via using it at nightfall

 

[Master 112]

Who did AV target?

[J-23]

Just now, HashtagNucks said:

It did work. It switched Blue Jay's role according to him.

And why would you block someone claiming a role, they were going to prove via using it at nightfall

 

You sure bud..read the role over again, and can you quote the post where BJ said his role switched, I think I missed it..

[DarthMelvin]

OK So J-23 says he is now a Switcher, 

And AV says he is a switcher.

And #y says she is a switcher.

 

one of these players may no longer be a switcher?

 

 

[NotMyBurroughs]

Just now, J-23 said:

You sure bud..read the role over again, and can you quote the post where BJ said his role switched, I think I missed it..

I don't understand this.

 

Why would did you pick me to block when I was going to claim my role?

 

[NotMyBurroughs]

AV also said he switched Blue jay. Which doesn't then disprove J-23 claiming he role blocked me. Although I'd wonder if that block would show in the nightfall post.