He should have never been given a shot. He was instrumental in ruining the Flames. 2 years of zero defense, no focus on special teams, overplaying Phaneuf and reinforcing all of his bad habits, feuding with Kiprusoff, and completely mismanaging players like Tanguay and Huselius.
I hope no team in the league has to suffer with Keenan. The guy is off his rocker as far as I'm concerned and he will run any team into the ground with his complete lack of detail-oriented coaching.
You just listed all the reasons I think he should have stayed
I thought they would be more of a mess than they were when they brought him on. I didn't think they would make the playoffs.
I was actually most impressed that they did make the playoffs even though Sutter couldn't manage a roster (i.e. ending season playing games with incomplete lineup to make salary cap).